What MPs and council chiefs think of county’s unitary bid

Ian Hudspeth

Ian Hudspeth

First published in News

OXFORDSHIRE County Council leader Ian Hudspeth has called for a debate on whether Oxfordshire should be run by just one local authority instead of the existing two-tier system involving a county authority and five district councils.

As reported in yesterday’s Oxford Mail, left, Mr Hudspeth, said he wanted to look into the costs of setting up a county-wide unitary authority and said a discussion would have to take place. The Government has said it will not approve any local government reorganisation in this Parliament, but it raises the prospect of changes taking place after next year’s General Election.

Oxford City Council has said it could go it alone as part of proposals put forward by the Labour Party.

Here, MPs and other council leaders give their reactions.

Oxford Mail:

Oxford East MP Andrew Smith: I think a single main level of local government makes sense – improving democratic accountability because it would be clearer to the public who is responsible for what, and increasing efficiency because it would avoid duplication.

I think the county is too big an area for the single local council though, so I would favour one for central Oxfordshire, one for the north of the county and one for the south.

It’s ludicrous that Swindon, Reading and Milton Keynes can organise all their own local services in a single tier, but Oxford can’t.

Oxford Mail: Tony Baldry

Banbury MP Sir Tony Baldry: I think the present two-tier structure works perfectly well for Oxfordshire. It enables those decisions that can most effectively be taken locally to be taken locally through district councils such as Cherwell and enables those matters that need to be decided more widely and strategically to be dealt with countywide by the county council. A unitary city and an otherwise unitary county would effectively be taking us back to pre-1972.

 Oxford Mail: MP Ed Vaisey

Wantage MP Ed Vaizey: This is a matter for council leaders in Oxfordshire and for my colleagues in the Department for Communities and Local Government.

I know that in joining together services in South Oxfordshire and Vale of White Horse has had an impact in terms of cost savings and effectiveness but Ian’s plan requires a much larger debate which I am sure he and other leaders will be willing to participate in.

Oxford Mail: John Howell

Henley MP John Howell: I know there are many who will side with him in wishing for a unitary authority but it isn’t going to happen before the election.

It is an interesting idea which needs to be looked at more carefully.

Oxford Mail: David Cameron

Witney MP and Prime Minister David Cameron: Not in favour of a unitary bid 

Barry Norton, West Oxfordshire District Council leader: It would be the biggest mistake to go to a massive unitary the size of that. It is clearly shown in terms of budget management that the larger the authorities, the more problems they have with keeping close control over financial matters.

The cost of setting up a large unitary, which would have to be met by funds which would then have to get back over a very, very long time.

Matthew Barber, Vale of White Horse District Council leader: I think it is a non-event. This government has said there will be no reorganisation in this Parliament and I don’t see any appetite for it in the next Parliament.

History suggests that Whitehall tends to impose any change on local government anyway.

Oxford City Council leader Bob Price: The current government is not interested in local government re-organisation; it is not on the agenda at the moment.

Certainly speaking from a city point of view, we are completely different to the rest of the county and we feel it would have a negative impact on the city.

There certainly is a political issue, but the city as a community would lose out dramatically.

Oxford West and Abingdon MP Nicola Blackwood did not respond to a request for her views on the issue before the Oxford Mail went to press last night.

Nor did South Oxfordshire and or Barry Wood, leader of Cherwell District Council.

Our top stories:

Sexual assault on woman in Oxford yesterday linked to earlier rape

Oxford Mail: Thames Valley Police logo

4:35pm Monday 22nd September 2014

A WOMAN was sexually assualted in the city yesterday, in an attack police have linked to a rape over the weekend.

Update: Man bailed after teenager raped in city centre

Oxford Mail:

11:57am Saturday 20th September 2014

A MAN arrested after a woman was raped in the city centre on Saturday morning has been bailed.

UPDATE: Tributes paid to Ann Ducker, leader of South Oxfordshire District Council, who has died

Oxford Mail: South Oxfordshire District Council leader Ann Ducker

10:21am Monday 22nd September 2014

Ann Ducker, leader of South Oxfordshire District Council, has died.

Corn Exchange's future debated

Oxford Mail: The Corn Exchange

9:10am Monday 22nd September 2014

The future use of the Corn Exchange will be discussed at a meeting tonight.

Minibus in accident near Littlemore

Oxford Mail: oxfordshire fire and rescue logo

9:10am Monday 22nd September 2014

A minibus carrying a group of youngsters was involved in a crash with a car on the A4142 Eastern Bypass. Three adults, 10 teenagers and a child were involved in the crash.

Electricity line drama after fire wrecks shed in Yarnton

Oxford Mail: oxfordshire fire and rescue logo

9:10am Monday 22nd September 2014

Electricity cables collapsed after a blaze in a large garden shed in Yarnton on Sunday.

Attacks prompt appeals for more police on the streets

Oxford Mail:

9:00am Monday 22nd September 2014

TWO men were last night in police custody after two women were raped in Oxford.

Shoppers jump in to stop would-be shoplifter

Oxford Mail: Thames Valley Police logo

8:30am Monday 22nd September 2014

SHOPPERS stopped a would-be thief from escaping from a Wallingford supermarket without paying for a trolley full of goods.

Schoolboy back on the ball after ceramic skull ‘miracle’

Oxford Mail:

8:30am Monday 22nd September 2014

A YEAR ago schoolboy Ollie Kirk became one of the first people in the UK to have half of his skull replaced with a ceramic implant.

Source of chemical that killed fish untraceable

Oxford Mail: Environment Agency logo round

8:00am Monday 22nd September 2014

INVESTIGATORS have been unable to find out the source of a chemical that killed more than 4,000 fish in a Didcot stream.

A green and pleasant event for first Earth Trust runners

Oxford Mail:

8:00am Monday 22nd September 2014

ICONIC landscapes greeted runners who took part in the Earth Trust’s inaugural 10k cross-country race round the Wittenham Clumps beauty spot.

Mystery Oxford pong is back, say residents

Oxford Mail: Pictures submitted by our readers of their memories of Didcot Power Station leading up to the demolition of three of the cooling towers.

7:10am Monday 22nd September 2014

THE mysterious ‘Oxford stink’ has returned for a third time, according to city residents.

Oxford youth hostel manager talks of blaze in laundry room

Oxford Mail: oxfordshire fire and rescue logo

7:10am Monday 22nd September 2014

A YOUTH hostel manager has described how a fire broke out in a laundry room.

Dancing in the streets as Charlbury holds its fair

Oxford Mail:

7:00am Monday 22nd September 2014

MORRIS dancing, cow-milking contests and a Spitfire fly-past were the attractions at this year’s Charlbury Street Fair.

Comments (7)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

8:33am Thu 3 Jul 14

jlnnn1 says...

It ain't broke so don't try to fix it. Beware of grandiose top downcentralisation. It just increases the number of bureaucrats, costs more money and is less efficient
It ain't broke so don't try to fix it. Beware of grandiose top downcentralisation. It just increases the number of bureaucrats, costs more money and is less efficient jlnnn1
  • Score: -1

8:39am Thu 3 Jul 14

Sophia says...

Interesting manoeuvres here

Based on the 2010 Election, a single county authority would have nearly but not quite half voting Tory.

Who knows, we might have real politics again

Certainly an end to the one party State that is Oxford today
Interesting manoeuvres here Based on the 2010 Election, a single county authority would have nearly but not quite half voting Tory. Who knows, we might have real politics again Certainly an end to the one party State that is Oxford today Sophia
  • Score: -1

8:41am Thu 3 Jul 14

Sophia says...

Interesting manoeuvres here

On 2010 election results, a single county authority would have nearly half tory votes but not quite

We might have some actual politics again

An end to the one party state that is Oxford today

Sounds good
Interesting manoeuvres here On 2010 election results, a single county authority would have nearly half tory votes but not quite We might have some actual politics again An end to the one party state that is Oxford today Sounds good Sophia
  • Score: -3

8:44am Thu 3 Jul 14

Sophia says...

"Beware of grandiose top down centralisation"

But is isnt. It's one layer fewer. In fact, from an Oxford view it's more like centralisation

I agree though that if it aint broke dont fix it is better than the current belief of both parties that reorganisation is a panacea for every problem
"Beware of grandiose top down centralisation" But is isnt. It's one layer fewer. In fact, from an Oxford view it's more like centralisation I agree though that if it aint broke dont fix it is better than the current belief of both parties that reorganisation is a panacea for every problem Sophia
  • Score: -2

10:08am Thu 3 Jul 14

DEnright says...

Let the County Council run all our services? The County which has ignored West Oxfordshire and our transport needs for the best part of a century and has an economic development plan that casts West Oxfordshire as a dormitory and retirement home for growth elsewhere? The County which for the last decade has been a home for Conservative bungling and neglect, with unbalanced budgets and services reorganising too often to get to grips? Hmmm, let me think...
Let the County Council run all our services? The County which has ignored West Oxfordshire and our transport needs for the best part of a century and has an economic development plan that casts West Oxfordshire as a dormitory and retirement home for growth elsewhere? The County which for the last decade has been a home for Conservative bungling and neglect, with unbalanced budgets and services reorganising too often to get to grips? Hmmm, let me think... DEnright
  • Score: 4

1:18pm Thu 3 Jul 14

Marcus2 says...

It seems to me that the District Councils are much closer to what people think than the County Council. So perhaps unitary bodies based on the City and District Councils would be more democratic and responsive. That is so long as Kidlington does not end up within what appears to be the shambles that is the City!
It seems to me that the District Councils are much closer to what people think than the County Council. So perhaps unitary bodies based on the City and District Councils would be more democratic and responsive. That is so long as Kidlington does not end up within what appears to be the shambles that is the City! Marcus2
  • Score: 1

6:49pm Thu 3 Jul 14

Jameslouis says...

Oh god please please please do not let the Oxford Be run by one council, especially not Labour, every county run by Labour has high poll tax rates, high wastage. In my opinion Labour especially in Oxford is one of the most useless, corrupt, dishonest run councils in the UK, high wages, large pensions, excessive allowances claimed no no no not those morons, and in my opinion every single piece of land would be built on by universities with none being built for the general public due to financial incentives offered by the universities to council members
Oh god please please please do not let the Oxford Be run by one council, especially not Labour, every county run by Labour has high poll tax rates, high wastage. In my opinion Labour especially in Oxford is one of the most useless, corrupt, dishonest run councils in the UK, high wages, large pensions, excessive allowances claimed no no no not those morons, and in my opinion every single piece of land would be built on by universities with none being built for the general public due to financial incentives offered by the universities to council members Jameslouis
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree