Scores of hospitals’ shift levels fall below minimum

Trust chief executive Sir Jonathan Michael

Trust chief executive Sir Jonathan Michael

First published in News Oxford Mail: Photograph of the Author by , Health reporter, also covering Kidlington. Call me on 01865 425271

ALMOST 60 staff shifts in the county’s hospitals were below the “minimum safe” level in March, new figures have revealed.

Oxford University Hospitals NHS Trust must now publish their staffing figures every two months.

They show how for March, 58 shifts went to the “escalation” level, meaning staff had to be drafted in from elsewhere.

This was out of 5,947 total shifts, of which about two thirds were at the agreed staffing level.

Staffing numbers are decided by the hospital, ward-by-ward, depending on what staff are needed.

Health bosses have given assurances that they are doing all they can to combat the less than one per cent below “minimum safe” levels.

The trust’s acting chief nurse Liz Wright told the Oxford Mail that ‘minimum safe’ means “there is an increase in activity or short notice sickness but that actions are taken locally to support needs of patients”.

She added: “Should a ward area be identified as having levels below this then the process of ‘escalation’ s means that the matron or divisional nurse will act to move staff around from outside the ward and/or take other actions to support the team.”

And local nursing representatives have said they appreciate work being done to increase recruitment.

Royal College of Nursing officer for Bucks & Oxon, Victoria Couling, said: “We are always concerned about the issue of nursing shortages.

“It is very important that the hospital needs to be staffed to safe levels with permanent staff.

“We are aware that the trust has invested a significant amount of money to increase nursing levels, with Oxfordshire being an expensive recruitment area.

“We have regular meetings with the hospital and we agree this is an important issue.”

Children’s services shifts made up 10 of the below “minimum safe” level, but the trust said seven midwifes had been offered a post and are due to start in September.

A total of 40 of all shifts across the trust had “surplus” staff and about two thirds – 4,257 shifts – were at the full agreed level over the month.

Some 1,690 were classed as the “minimum safe” level, and 58 were the level below “minimum safe”.

These “escalation” shifts meant action had to be taken to fill gaps – but bosses said not all were filled.

The trust would not say how many shifts were not covered when asked by the Oxford Mail, but its report said it took steps to “ensure patient safety”, such as changing workloads, admitting emergencies to other wards and bringing in other ward staff.

It said: “By adopting such measures a safe clinical environment for patients was maintained in all cases.”

The report said escalation shifts “occurred largely due to short notice sickness and/or inability to fill with temporary staff.” It said this was “in spite of a suite of options being considered as part of the process” and, for example, extra staff in other wards being brought in.

The trust said: “It was not always possible to fill all escalation shifts.”
Chairman of official watchdog Healthwatch, Larry Sanders said: “We want good care for the people of Oxfordshire and that requires adequate staffing and therefore this lack of full staffing is very serious.”

Oxford Mail: Andrew Smith

Andrew Smith MP

Oxford East Labour MP Andrew Smith said: “It is vital for patient safety that staffing levels provide proper cover and gaps are filled.”

The figures come after inspectors last week raised concerns about staff shortages at Oxford’s John Radcliffe Hospital.

Concerns made in the Care Quality Commission (CQC) inspection included a “lack of sufficient numbers” in surgery, maternity and operating theatres.

The problems are despite a trust-wide increase in full-time roles from 9,102 to 9,590 in 2013/14.

Trust chief executive Sir Jonathan Michael told last Wednesday’s trust board the figures are “testament to good staffing management”.

He said: “I wouldn’t wish members of the board to be concerned that [minimum safe] equals anything other than safe staffing levels.”

The figures were published under instructions from NHS England and the CQC, which last week rated the trust good under its Hard Truths scheme, which demanded public figures between April and June.

The CQC reported the trust said Oxford’s high cost of living and lack of hospital parking and its cost led to recruitment difficulties.

It saw delays in patients being discharged from intensive care to surgery and this “put pressure on staff” to discharge them.

Staff also reported “high levels of stress and low morale due to workload” and operating theatre lists cancelled about once a week due to shortages.

Neurosurgery doctors told inspectors “sometimes the medical staffing levels felt unsafe” with one junior doctor looking after 74 patients out of hours.

But the trust said its spreadsheet-based recording system is “fragile” and “open to user error” and needs to be replaced by a more “robust” system.

  • Top News

Our top stories:

Randolph Hotel: The show must go on for neighbouring Oxford Playhouse

Oxford Mail:

7:20am Tuesday 21st April 2015

WHILE a fire raged at the Randolph Hotel on Friday, next door at the Oxford Playhouse it was a case of “the show must go on”.

Randolph Hotel: Former Maitre D’ left shocked by damage

Oxford Mail:

7:10am Tuesday 21st April 2015

FORMER Randolph Hotel Maitre D’ Giuseppe Vurchio said he was shocked by Friday’s devastating blaze.

Randolph Hotel: Structural engineer declares building safe with it likely to re-open next week

Oxford Mail:

7:00am Tuesday 21st April 2015

THE Randolph Hotel is hoping to reopen by Monday after structural engineers said the building was safe.

School places: How am I supposed to walk my four-year-old 40 minutes to primary?

Oxford Mail:

6:30am Tuesday 21st April 2015

A MOTHER whose son was refused a place at his two first choice primary schools says she now faces a 40-minute walk to the one allocated by Oxfordshire County Council.

Lord Mayor and two councillors give reference for bookies' robber

Oxford Mail:

6:30am Tuesday 21st April 2015

PERSONAL references for an armed robber jailed for more than six years came from the Lord Mayor of Oxford and two city councillors.

Cheney trust is choice to run new Barton Park Primary School

Oxford Mail: New Oxfordshire county council logo

6:10am Tuesday 21st April 2015

THE trust that will manage the primary school in the new Barton Park development was decided by councillors yesterday.

Tuberculosis victim accused of breaching Asbo by spitting inside medical centre

Oxford Mail:

5:30am Tuesday 21st April 2015

A HOMELESS man given an anti-social behaviour order for trying to spread tuberculosis (TB) has gone on trial in Oxford Crown Court.

Randolph Hotel: Damage runs to millions but we may re-open on Saturday

Oxford Mail:

8:08am Monday 20th April 2015

THE manager of Oxford’s Randolph Hotel has said the fire caused millions of pounds of damage.

Randolph Hotel: Flambe cooking thought to be cause of fire

Oxford Mail:

8:00am Monday 20th April 2015

FIRE crews were expected to return the flame-stricken Randolph Hotel to management today after spending the weekend making the building safe.

UPDATE: Randolph Hotel: Beaumont Street reopens westbound

Oxford Mail:

3:05pm Monday 20th April 2015

BEAUMONT Street is set to partly reopen later today after engineers assessed damage to the Randolph Hotel following Friday’s fire.

Jury retires to consider verdict in Robert Dobinson murder trial

Oxford Mail:

3:21pm Monday 20th April 2015

THE jury has retired to consider its verdict in the trial of a woman who denies fatally stabbing her boyfriend in a drunken rage.

Update: Delays expected until midnight after signalling problems between Oxford and Charlbury

Oxford Mail: A First Great Western High Speed Train

11:03am Monday 20th April 2015

There are delays and cancellations on train services between Oxford and Charlbury due to signalling problems.

Oxford United striker Kemar Roofe celebrates double delight

Oxford Mail:

9:30am Monday 20th April 2015

Kemar Roofe insists he does not know where his future lies after netting his second double in a fortnight to help Oxford United to a 3-0 win at Tranmere Rovers on Saturday.

Randolph Hotel: Blaze a 'damaging blow' to city's tourist trade

Oxford Mail:

8:03am Monday 20th April 2015

THE blaze has been described as a “damaging blow” to the city ahead of tourist season.

Comments (1)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

10:21am Tue 20 May 14

Mark L. says...

“We are aware that the trust has invested a significant amount of money to increase nursing levels, with Oxfordshire being an expensive recruitment area"

So why did you cut Nurses pay by ending the recruitment and retention payments last year then. Most shifts my wife works are short staffed. On xmas day and New Years eve, she was the only trained nurse looking after 15 patients. Short staffed, shift after shift yet correct staffing level on the days of the CQC inspections. Easy when you know in advance.
“We are aware that the trust has invested a significant amount of money to increase nursing levels, with Oxfordshire being an expensive recruitment area" So why did you cut Nurses pay by ending the recruitment and retention payments last year then. Most shifts my wife works are short staffed. On xmas day and New Years eve, she was the only trained nurse looking after 15 patients. Short staffed, shift after shift yet correct staffing level on the days of the CQC inspections. Easy when you know in advance. Mark L.
  • Score: 6

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree