A DOCTOR told a jury he does not believe explanations from a mother accused of breaking her baby daughter’s leg.
Jade Collison, of Juniper Close, Banbury, has pleaded not guilty to one count of inflicting grievous bodily harm during January last year.
The 19-year-old also denies one count of inflicting actual bodily harm on her daughter, who the Oxford Mail has chosen not to name.
Opening the case at Oxford Crown Court, prosecutor Sam Mainds said the injury was discovered after the infant, then six months old, was taken to Horton General Hospital in Banbury on January 29.
The child had two bruises on her face, which Collison said were caused when she fell against her cot.
But giving evidence yesterday paediatrician Dr Peter Ehrhardt said he did not believe this.
He said: “The explanation given was that she was propped up in a sitting position in the cot and she fell over and hit her head on the bars of the cot. I don’t accept that, I think it is not possible. She couldn’t get enough energy falling over to produce a bruise like that.”
Collison claims her daughter’s leg was broken when her partner stepped on it, but she did not realise it was a serious injury.
Dr Ehrhardt said although this was a plausible explanation for the break, he did not think it was true.
He said: “This baby would be really, really distressed. This baby would be really, really unhappy that night.
“The level of pain in the defence’s document does not match with the amount of pain you would feel if you had broken a bone.”
The trial continues.
- Do you want alerts delivered straight to your phone via our WhatsApp service? Text NEWS or SPORT or NEWS AND SPORT, depending on which services you want, and your full name to 07767 417704. Save our number into your phone’s contacts as Oxford Mail WhatsApp and ensure you have WhatsApp installed
Our top stories
12:40pm Monday 5th October 2015
A FATHER accused of shaking his 11-week-old baby to death has been cleared of murder.
1:21pm Monday 5th October 2015
The brother of Oxford United striker James Roberts has died after being involved in a car accident on Saturday night.
12:03pm Monday 5th October 2015
THE A34 in South Hinksey is currently partially blocked due to a broken down tipper-truck.
11:50am Monday 5th October 2015
PARTS of Oxfordshire are due to be hit by heavy rain later today, according to the Met Office. A severe weather warning has been issued by the agency for the South East, which will be in place from 12pm until 10pm today. It has been forecast that some areas will see more than 15 mm of rain in an hour, with overall totals more than 40 mm in several hours. Small patches of localised flooding and disruptions to transport are also possible. A Met Office spokesman said: "A very complex area of low pressure will bring warm, moist air northwards into Britain. There is a developing signal for heavy rain to affect some southeastern parts of England later on Monday. "Some minor disruption due to flooding is likely, with an additional risk of some very isolated more substantial impacts."
8:30am Monday 5th October 2015
A FAMILY stole thousands of pounds of benefits from a man with severe learning disabilities while forcing him to do menial and manual labour for £5 a day, a court heard.
7:00am Monday 5th October 2015
GREY pavements will be transformed with striking street art as one woman hopes to chalk up yet another successful art event this weekend.