PLANS for a dementia care home in Headington have been thrown out after councillors said it did not fit with the area’s “rural tranquility”.
Oxford City Council rejected the 55-bedroom plan for Pullen Lane for residential and day care for people with dementia.
Developer Carebase wanted to replace a large 1960s house with a three-storey care home with 17 parking spaces.
But council planning officers said it would conflict with the Headington Hill Conservation Area, which gives extra checks against development.
Planning officer Matthew Parry said the site was “essentially greenfield”.
His report said: “The area has a tranquil, rural character with generous spacing between the buildings interspersed with dense greenery.
“This is not found anywhere else in the city.
“Put simply, the building proposed is of a vast scale in comparison to the existing buildings.”
Tony Besse, from the Headington Hill Umbrella Group, urged the east area planning committee reject the plan at its Wednesday meeting.
Raising concerns about extra traffic, the Pullens Lane resident said: “Hundreds of students walk along that road, they’re like sheep in a country lane. It would distract from the enjoyment of the lane.”
But Oxfordshire County Council, responsible for roads, said: “There is no evidence of there being a personal injury accident problem in Pullens Lane.
“The predicted development would have no signficant impact on the capacity or safety of the junction.”
Carebase spokesman David Madden told the committee the complaints conflicted with what others had told them.
He said: “We are disappointed. This is contrary to the advice we received from the design review panel, who we have been working with for the past year.
“This would be less than 40cm higher than the existing building. The highway authority said traffic would be fine and that there would be modest traffic rates.”
He added: “We have already reduced the number of beds from 70 to 55.
“This is the minimum number of beds that we can operate a care home of this quality.”
As of March 31, there were 3,936 dementia sufferers known to the county NHS services, up from 3,566 12 months previously.
Mr Madden said: “There is an urgent and growing need for dementia care in Headington.
The committee unanimously voted against the plan at Oxford’s Town Hall.
Vice-chairman Van Coulter said: “I think this is quite a good development, but not on this site.”
Do you want alerts delivered straight to your phone via our WhatsApp service? Text NEWS or SPORT or NEWS AND SPORT, depending on which services you want, and your full name to 07767 417704. Save our number into your phone's contacts as Oxford Mail WhatsApp and ensure you have WhatsApp installed.
11:20am Monday 28th July 2014
What do you think? We welcome letters from our readers on a wide variety of subjects and you can send us a letter through the blue headline above.
8:30am Wednesday 25th November 2015
TRADE in Oxford is dwindling with businesses blaming the fall in shoppers on roadworks and high parking charges.
8:30am Wednesday 25th November 2015
OXFORDSHIRE’S picturesque countryside, rich history and thriving city centre proved to be a stronger magnet for tourists again last year.
8:00am Wednesday 25th November 2015
BESTSELLING author Philip Pullman has described as “barbarism” proposed cuts to the arts an East Oxford theatre says could hit vulnerable young people.
6:30am Wednesday 25th November 2015
A NATIONAL memorial to the heroic D-Day raid by the Oxfordshire and Buckinghamshire Light Infantry has been approved and the hunt for £50,000 to pay for it has begun.
6:10am Wednesday 25th November 2015
A FORMER Cheney School pupil and now organiser of a major music festival planned for South Park next year has promised there will be a “strong local flavour” to the event.
11:48am Tuesday 24th November 2015
Two of Elton John's five UK 2016 concert dates will be in Oxfordshire, the star reveals today