Family’s High Court wrangle over dead mum’s inheritance

Joyce Smith’s former house in Home Close

Joyce Smith’s former house in Home Close

First published in Oxford Mail: Photograph of the Author by , Health reporter, also covering Kidlington. Call me on 01865 425271

A FORMER Oxford woman was moved to a Kent care home and cut off from her family against her wishes, a judge at London’s High Court has been told.

Georgina Leigh, daughter of Joyce Smith, 85, was also gifted £300,000 from the sale of her late mother’s Wolvercote home of 40 years after Mrs Smith’s death, it was alleged.

Mrs Smith’s niece and nephew are taking Mrs Leigh to court in a bid to get the house proceeds and interest from the sale split among her family.

They claim that Mrs Leigh, 60, waged a “sustained campaign” to isolate the widow from relatives after moving her in December 2009.

Mrs Leigh is alleged to have denied grandchildren Lisa Martin, 35, and Paul Kicks, 36, of Carterton, access to Mrs Smith from 2010 to December 2011, when she died.

They were on a list of relatives given to staff at Maidstone Care Centre who Mrs Leigh did not want her mother to see, Judge Stephen Morris heard on Monday.

Mrs Martin, from Derby, said of the final visit: “It breaks my heart to say that was the last time I ever saw her and the last time she saw her great-grandchildren, who were the last link to her dead daughter.

Oxford Mail:

  • Georgina Leigh

“I was very close to my grandmother. I loved her with all my heart and I wanted the chance to say goodbye to her.”

Mrs Leigh has said Mrs Smith’s Home Close house in Wolvercote – almost her entire estate – was given to her and husband Desmond as a gift to partly pay care home bills.

But her grandchildren said this went against her 2008 will, which divided proceeds among the family.

They claim she lacked the mental capacity to make an informed decision and Mrs Leigh exerted “undue influence” over her.

It is claimed her daughter moved her in December 2009 without telling the family and the locks were changed the next day.

Their barrister, Constance McDonnell, said Mrs Smith had made it clear she did not want to leave her house or be “put in a home” and her family located her through Kent social services.

She said: “Mrs Leigh carried out a sustained campaign of trying to prevent her having any contact with any relative other than her, her husband and their sons.”

She said Mrs Leigh, of Catkin Close, Maidstone, appeared to have “completely disregarded the deceased’s own wishes” that she wanted to see her wider family.

Mr Leigh, speaking for his wife, said Mrs Smith choked in her sleep and was taken to hospital in December 2009 and, as such, they feared for her safety. He said Mrs Smith said she did not want Oxford relatives at her funeral to avoid “trouble”.

In a statement to the court, next door neighbour Eddie Fidler, a resident since 1966, said: “Joyce regularly told me that she wanted to stay in her own home.

“Joyce loved her grandchildren and there is no way she would have cut them out of her inheritance willingly.”

Yesterday Judge Stephen Morris QC reserved judgement for a later date.


  • Do you want alerts delivered straight to your phone via our WhatsApp service? Text NEWS, SPORT and JAYDEN depending on what services you want, and your full name to 07767 417704. Save our number into your phone as Oxford Mail WhatsApp and ensure you have WhatsApp installed.

Our top stories

14 minutes to drive just a mile in Oxford - where are the worst congestion hotspots on our interactive map?

Oxford Mail:

8:30am Thursday 28th May 2015

MOTORISTS travelling into Oxford took a staggering 14 minutes to complete one mile on the Botley Road last year.

Botley Road goes from this to this just by adjusting traffic lights

Oxford Mail:

8:39am Thursday 28th May 2015

DRIVERS went from despair to delight in 24 hours as the huge traffic delays experienced on Botley Road on Tuesday disappeared yesterday.

Anti-fossil fuel protesters plan protest at Didcot Power Station

Oxford Mail: Didcot Power Station

8:12am Thursday 28th May 2015

A PROTEST at Didcot Power Station at the weekend will be monitored, police said.

Touching scenes as family unveil plaque to tragic Oxford station worker Steve Cross

Oxford Mail:

8:08am Thursday 28th May 2015

FAMILY, friends and colleagues gathered at Oxford station to unveil a plaque commemorating a ticket barrier man who died earlier this year.

Parents' relief as inquiry to look into Nico Reed’s death in supported living home

Oxford Mail:

7:59am Thursday 28th May 2015

THE mother of a man who died in a supported living home has welcomed an inquiry into his death.

Holly Bush owner loses battle to stay open until 3am and fears for future

Oxford Mail:

7:48am Thursday 28th May 2015

THE future of a West Oxford pub has been thrown into doubt after its proposed licensing hours were reduced.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree