Parents fear train line will cause havoc during lessons

Oxford Mail: Leanne McClements, pictured with 11-month-old son Rowan, is concerned that noise and vibrations from trains will affect children at Wolvercote Primary School Leanne McClements, pictured with 11-month-old son Rowan, is concerned that noise and vibrations from trains will affect children at Wolvercote Primary School

VIBRATIONS and noise from a nearby railway line will disturb school lessons, parents fear.

Wolvercote Primary School hopes to build new classrooms, but they could end up near to a train line that is being upgraded.

Chiltern Railways and Network Rail are working to double track the line between Oxford and Bicester, which passes through the area.

Meanwhile, the school is hoping to replace its reception class buildings to take on more pupils – which would place it right next to the upgraded line.

Mother-of-two Leanne McClements has claimed that nothing has been proposed to dampen noise and vibrations coming from the nearby line when it is finished.

The 39-year-old, who lives in a neighbouring complex of flats, said: “I am very concerned about the affect of noise and vibrations on our children and our properties.

“We could end up with children trying to learn with a lot of noise every 15 minutes, throughout the school day. I do not think that is acceptable.

“It seems to me that the two schemes (the school extension and the rail works) should be taken into account together, but that does not seem to have happened.”

After a public consultation in 2013, Oxfordshire County Council decided to expand Wolvercote Primary School so it could cater for more pupils.

Related links

It will demolish its existing nursery building and build new classrooms next to the neighbouring railway line on the east side of the school grounds.

In its planning application, the school said it had consulted on the plans with Network Rail.

It also commissioned a noise assessment, done by consultancy firm Cole Jarman.

The assessment said: “(The building) will be in close proximity to the eastern boundary of the site and the rail lines in cutting beyond.”

The firm added that trains could also run “much faster”, possibly at 100mph, than current services which go past the school, but that some protection from noise was given by greenery.

It recommended the expansion go ahead, but warned: “Current noise levels are at the threshold of where single-sided natural ventilation via open windows would be acceptable... With changes to the train line, the noise climate will increase.”

The city council will decide whether noise and vibration mitigation measures are required later this year.

  • Our top stories:

4.40pm UPDATE: Queues beginning on A34 this evening due to Kennington roundabout work

Oxford Mail: A34 traffic alert

4:40pm Monday 28th July 2014

TRAFFIC is starting to build up back on to the A34 because of the new contraflow on the Southern Bypass because of the Kennington roundabout work.

COMMONWEALTH GAMES: French rues just missing out on gold medal

Oxford Mail:

9:20am Monday 28th July 2014

Matt French admitted he had been unlucky to secure only a silver medal at Glasgow 2014.

Watch: Didcot's tumbling towers - A dawn chorus of excitement as Didcot's skyline changes forever + video

Oxford Mail:

9:00am Monday 28th July 2014

FIFTY years of history – gone in 15 seconds. Despite Didcot’s sadness at seeing its cooling towers sink to the ground, there was applause and cheering when the moment arrived.

Hundreds join protest against Gaza war

Oxford Mail:

8:00am Monday 28th July 2014

OPPONENTS of Israel’s bombardment of the Gaza strip took to the streets of Oxford in support of victims of the conflict.

William, 4, is lining up for charity sports fest

Oxford Mail:

8:00am Monday 28th July 2014

A FOUR-year-old will take on a triathlon to raise money for the hospital ward that saved his life.

Update: Man in Blackbird Leys 'hit by car after argument with woman'

Oxford Mail: Thames Valley Police logo

7:49am Monday 28th July 2014

A SILVER car mounted the pavement and hit a man in Blackbird Leys after he had been arguing with a woman, police have said. 

Comments (6)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

7:01am Tue 1 Jul 14

Andrew:Oxford says...

Railway noise isn't anything like road noise for distraction, in early course the line will be electrified too*. The best option for the classrooms is probably triple glazing and air-conditioning if it is felt truly necessary.

The biggest worry for most parents will be the council's stance on the current pedestrian level crossing which is being kept open as the council's bargaining tool.


*Electrification will no doubt be subject to the traditional vexatious activism in Oxford. Just wait for the photographs in this paper of misery and upturned noses as "Activists" point to the industrial catenary alongside Port Meadow.
Railway noise isn't anything like road noise for distraction, in early course the line will be electrified too*. The best option for the classrooms is probably triple glazing and air-conditioning if it is felt truly necessary. The biggest worry for most parents will be the council's stance on the current pedestrian level crossing which is being kept open as the council's bargaining tool. *Electrification will no doubt be subject to the traditional vexatious activism in Oxford. Just wait for the photographs in this paper of misery and upturned noses as "Activists" point to the industrial catenary alongside Port Meadow. Andrew:Oxford
  • Score: 4

8:40am Tue 1 Jul 14

thomashenry says...

I bought a house right by the rail station. Before I moved in I was a bit worried about train noise. Within a week, I had stopped even noticing the trains at all.

It's not an issue. Parents need not worry, and would be advised not to expend energy complaining about it.
I bought a house right by the rail station. Before I moved in I was a bit worried about train noise. Within a week, I had stopped even noticing the trains at all. It's not an issue. Parents need not worry, and would be advised not to expend energy complaining about it. thomashenry
  • Score: 6

10:55am Tue 1 Jul 14

Dilligaf2010 says...

What a load of tosh, a train going past ever 15 minutes isn't going to cause any problems what-so-ever........
What a load of tosh, a train going past ever 15 minutes isn't going to cause any problems what-so-ever........ Dilligaf2010
  • Score: 2

1:11pm Tue 1 Jul 14

ElderP says...

Perhaps Wolvercote Primary should have a chat with Phil and Jim's Primary, which was built new, next to the main line a few miles south, and see how they cope with train noise.
Like thomashenry, I too lived adjacent to the railway line near the station. The units that will be running on this line will not be much noisier than a bus going by.
Perhaps Wolvercote Primary should have a chat with Phil and Jim's Primary, which was built new, next to the main line a few miles south, and see how they cope with train noise. Like thomashenry, I too lived adjacent to the railway line near the station. The units that will be running on this line will not be much noisier than a bus going by. ElderP
  • Score: 3

1:12pm Tue 1 Jul 14

Neonlights says...

"the school is hoping to replace its reception class buildings to take on more pupils – which would place it right next to the upgraded line. "

Well build the reception class buildings somewhere else away from the upgraded line then.
"the school is hoping to replace its reception class buildings to take on more pupils – which would place it right next to the upgraded line. " Well build the reception class buildings somewhere else away from the upgraded line then. Neonlights
  • Score: 2

6:36pm Tue 1 Jul 14

King Joke says...

Trust me, when you hear a noise every fifteen minutes, all day, every day, you will soon filter it out. I grew up with the East Coast Main Line behind my house, in the Deltic days. You got used to even these howling past. Modern trains are much quieter.
Trust me, when you hear a noise every fifteen minutes, all day, every day, you will soon filter it out. I grew up with the East Coast Main Line behind my house, in the Deltic days. You got used to even these howling past. Modern trains are much quieter. King Joke
  • Score: 2
Post a comment

Remember you are personally responsible for what you post on this site and must abide by our site terms. Do not post anything that is false, abusive or malicious. If you wish to complain, please use the ‘report this post’ link.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree