THE president of the Oxford Union believes people accused of rape should have their identities kept secret until police are sure there is a solid case.
Ben Sullivan was arrested on suspicion of rape and attempted rape last month but police dropped the case on Wednesday.
Now Mr Sullivan has called for a change whereby people like himself who are arrested cannot be named publicly initially, because of the “incredibly poisonous allegations”.
However, Oxford Sexual Abuse and Rape Crisis centre service manager Natalie Brook disagreed with the history and politics student.
Police forces rarely name people who have been arres-ted, but not charged. Howe-ver, there is no legal barrier stopping the media or any member of the public naming the arrested person.
Speaking on BBC’s Newsnight on Thursday, Mr Sullivan, 21, said: “I’m not of the extremist sort who don’t think you should have your identity revealed until you’ve been convicted, or even necessarily after being charged.
“What I don’t agree with is that everyone’s identity is automatically revealed the minute they are arrested.
“I think there should be some sort of happy medium whereby your identity is protected initially, until at least the conclusion of a preliminary investigation.
“I would never say that everyone's identity in the circumstances should be kept secret.”
However, Ms Brook said: “We are concerned giving anonymity to those accused of rape and sexual offences serves only to entrench a myth that women who report these crimes are more likely to be lying than someone who is reporting another kind of crime.
“It is in the public interest to publish names of the accused as it encourages other victims of the same alleged perpetrator to come forward.”
She said false rape allegations were “very rare” and made up as little as one per cent of all reports, adding: “Only an estimated 15 per cent of the 85,000 women who are raped and 400,000 who are sexually assaulted every year in England and Wales currently report to the police. The conviction rate for reported rapes remains at about six per cent. It is clear there is no justification for exceptional treatment for those accused of rape.”
She echoed the thoughts of Sarah Pine, who appeared on Newsnight alongside Mr Sullivan. During the programme, the vice president for women at Oxford Student Union and leader of the campaign to boycott the debating society, said: “If someone is named it encourages other people to come forward.
“It helps the police investigations go much smoother.”
She said the idea of anonymity for those accused would “protect perpetrators of sexual violence rather than potential victims”.
Speaking on Newsnight, Mr Sullivan added: “I’m completely aware that it can be extremely useful to police investigations for people’s identities to be revealed for people to come forward.
“However, these are obviously incredibly poisonous allegations, they are incredibly difficult to deal with.”
Our top stories:
8:30am Wednesday 25th November 2015
TRADE in Oxford is dwindling with businesses blaming the fall in shoppers on roadworks and high parking charges.
8:30am Wednesday 25th November 2015
OXFORDSHIRE’S picturesque countryside, rich history and thriving city centre proved to be a stronger magnet for tourists again last year.
8:00am Wednesday 25th November 2015
BESTSELLING author Philip Pullman has described as “barbarism” proposed cuts to the arts an East Oxford theatre says could hit vulnerable young people.
6:30am Wednesday 25th November 2015
A NATIONAL memorial to the heroic D-Day raid by the Oxfordshire and Buckinghamshire Light Infantry has been approved and the hunt for £50,000 to pay for it has begun.
6:10am Wednesday 25th November 2015
A FORMER Cheney School pupil and now organiser of a major music festival planned for South Park next year has promised there will be a “strong local flavour” to the event.
11:48am Tuesday 24th November 2015
Two of Elton John's five UK 2016 concert dates will be in Oxfordshire, the star reveals today
8:30am Tuesday 24th November 2015
RESIDENTS have accused hospital chiefs of keeping them in the dark over plans which could mean 18 months of disruption on Headington’s roads.
4:43pm Tuesday 24th November 2015
PLANS for a new Aldi in Oxford will be submitted before the end of the year.
3:00pm Tuesday 24th November 2015
A GROUP of travellers who camped on the Marston Ferry Road cycle track for more than a month have now left.
9:00am Tuesday 24th November 2015
LONELINESS affects thousands in the county every year and some areas are particularly vulnerable, according to Age UK Oxfordshire.
8:00am Tuesday 24th November 2015
FUNGUS has forced an Oxford football club to abandon its £800,000 new pitches and clubhouse.
7:00am Tuesday 24th November 2015
A PROPOSAL to allow Oxfordshire County Council to raise an additional two per cent in council tax to help fund vital social care has been given a cautious welcome by its leaders.
6:30am Tuesday 24th November 2015
OXFORD’S new £12m Hilton hotel will help to meet growing demand for rooms in the city, according to its new manager.
6:00am Tuesday 24th November 2015
POLITICIANS have welcomed plans to tackle the county’s bedblocking crisis.