Web ruling will ‘raise the bar’ for internet use

Prof Luciano Floridi is a professor of philosophy and the ethics of information at Oxford University

Prof Luciano Floridi is a professor of philosophy and the ethics of information at Oxford University

First published in News

AN Oxford professor has said that a controversial legal ruling will change the way hundreds of millions of people use the internet.

Prof Luciano Floridi, a professor of philosophy and the ethics of information at Oxford University, has been appointed by Google to work out how it should comply with the landmark ruling that means people can ask for their personal information to be removed.

The European Union Court of Justice has ruled that people have the “right to be forgotten”, meaning some of their details have to be taken down if they request it.

Speaking to The Independent, Prof Floridi said the main beneficiaries of the ruling are “reputation management companies”.

He said: “They now have the power to ask for embarrassing information about their clients to be removed.

“If I was the chief executive of a reputation management company, I would be laughing.”

He said that the ruling “raised the bar so high that the old rules of the internet no longer apply”.

Prof Floridi is director of research at the Oxford Internet Institute, which is based in St Giles.

The case which triggered the ruling was brought by a Spanish man who complained that an auction notice of his repossessed home on Google’s search results infringed his privacy.

Top News
Our top stories:

MP Nicola Blackwood: I'm battling a genetic mobility condition

Oxford Mail: Nicola Blackwood

8:00am Tuesday 31st March 2015

MP NICOLA Blackwood has revealed she has been battling with a genetic condition for years but believes it has not affected her performance as a politician.

Two appear in Oxford court over slavery charges following raids in Redbridge Hollow

Oxford Mail: oxford magistrates court

1:27pm Tuesday 31st March 2015

TWO people appeared at Oxford Magistrates' Court today following a series of dawn raids by police investigating slavery allegations.

Gold engagement ring stolen in Banbury burglary

Oxford Mail: Thames Valley Police logo

11:22am Tuesday 31st March 2015

Burglars broke into a property in Banbury and stole jewellery including a gold engagement ring.

Food ratings: Kennington Bangladeshi restaurant gets zero star rating

Oxford Mail:

7:10am Tuesday 31st March 2015

THE manager of a Bangladeshi restaurant given a food hygiene rating of zero out of five has branded the decision unfair.

Letitia and Elliot take gold for Britain in ice skating champs as they dream of Olympics

Oxford Mail:

10:00am Tuesday 31st March 2015

A TEENAGE ice dancing couple from Oxfordshire have taken another step closer to their Olympic dream with a first European title.

100 people facing redundancy at Agilent Technologies

Oxford Mail:

9:30am Tuesday 31st March 2015

ABOUT 100 staff at a Yarnton office are facing being made redundant after US-based life sciences company Agilent Technologies decided to stop manufacturing one of its products.

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

8:14pm Tue 3 Jun 14

Andrew:Oxford says...

A message saying:-

"European legislation prohibits this result being displayed"

Will do more damage than a regular result could.
A message saying:- "European legislation prohibits this result being displayed" Will do more damage than a regular result could. Andrew:Oxford
  • Score: 0

8:15pm Tue 3 Jun 14

Andrew:Oxford says...

A message saying:-

"European legislation prohibits this result being displayed"

Will do more damage than a regular result could.
A message saying:- "European legislation prohibits this result being displayed" Will do more damage than a regular result could. Andrew:Oxford
  • Score: 1

11:19am Wed 4 Jun 14

ashleyc says...

It sounds to me that Prof Floridi has only heard the slightest of details about this ruling. It is not as simple as being able to request the removal of any result you don't like - it's specifically in regards to incorrect or outdated information (the Spanish man in question had results about a debt recovery auction coming up for his name but it dated from 1998) Each and every request has to be considered before removal and anything found to be in the public interest will automatically be kept.
Don't get me wrong, I think forcing Google to remove results when the original data is kept is stupid, but it isn't as simple as anyone being able to manipulate results however they like.
It sounds to me that Prof Floridi has only heard the slightest of details about this ruling. It is not as simple as being able to request the removal of any result you don't like - it's specifically in regards to incorrect or outdated information (the Spanish man in question had results about a debt recovery auction coming up for his name but it dated from 1998) Each and every request has to be considered before removal and anything found to be in the public interest will automatically be kept. Don't get me wrong, I think forcing Google to remove results when the original data is kept is stupid, but it isn't as simple as anyone being able to manipulate results however they like. ashleyc
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree