Is early intervention more important than the ‘troubled families’ scheme?

Picture posed by models

Picture posed by models

First published in News

YES - Val Smith, Oxfordshire County Councillor for Blackbird Leys

Early intervention – stepping in as soon as possible when things are going wrong – works.

It is an approach which offers us a real opportunity to make lasting improvements in the lives of children, to forestall many persistent social problems and end their transmission from one generation to the next.

It has been proven in so many ways. It works for children, it works in healthcare, it works for young offenders. A 2011 report on early intervention by MP Graham Allen said: “The culture of late intervention is both expensive and ineffective”.

Oxford Mail:

Val Smith

Ideally intervention should be as early as possible, that is why the fabulous children’s centres and family centres are so important to us all.

Children’s centres are for children under five and their families.

They are places where they can find a variety of activities, information and support from professionals, whatever their background or circumstances. It’s all about working with and for families.

When we talk about early intervention we must also give praise to organisations like Home Start and PEEP (Parents Early Education Partnership).

Home Start’s volunteers offer befriending, as well as practical and emotional advice in the homes of families who are having difficulties managing parenting.

This is introducing support for those who need it most.

PEEP, which was born here in Oxford, was the inspiration for Sure Start Children’s Centres.

It helps whole communities of children improve their education from an early age by working with parents and carers.

Much as we want intervention to be early, stuff happens. Families break up, people lose their jobs and people get into debt.

It can happen overnight or it can take years before the consequences are apparent.

Families can get missed and do not get the intervention when needed – but it is vital never to give up on a child, young person or the family.

People have a great capacity to change.

It is often a question of giving confidence, the right support and the inspiration when most needed.

Decent housing is crucial. People and families need chances and deserve a decent home. We must build more houses that are affordable so people can be independent and that children can have space to do things like homework.

Stable housing gives children the chance to stay at the same school and not have to move on every couple of years, which is what so often happens when families are stuck in private rented accommodation.

Government cuts to local councils make it increasingly hard to give the support which is needed.

This is not only tragic for the families concerned, but the consequences will cost society dear in the long run.

NO - Melinda Tilley, Oxfordshire County Council’s cabinet member for children, education and families.

I am a strong follower of Iain Duncan Smith’s “Broken Britain” agenda, and when I read his book on the subject, and before Oxfordshire County Council had any money or any support from Government, I thought we should be working with families to try to help them sort out their lives.

The Thriving Families project is part of a Government initiative to identify the most troubled families in society and directly tackle problems such as crime and antisocial behaviour, poor school attendance, unemployment and drug and alcohol abuse.


Oxford Mail:

Melinda Tilley

Sometimes the problems families have are so many and varied that it is difficult to work with them, but this agenda does just that.

Each family taking part meets national criteria identifying them as among the most troubled in terms of poor school attendance and behaviour, antisocial behaviour, youth offending and adults out of work. They are assigned a dedicated worker from the county council’s Thriving Families team who acts as the single point of contact for the family.

The worker liaises with other agencies to deliver an agreed plan of action geared towards achieving specific results.

Families’ progress is measured through real-terms improvements in school attendance, behaviour, and reductions in levels of offending over a sustained period of time.

In taking on this challenge the county council is confident that the families we manage to turn around will be much less of a burden on society in that they will be in work, their children in school and making progress and that they will contributing to society.

We are committed to the long-term savings from this project and therefore reduce the financial burden these issues place on society.

New figures show the programme, in which a dedicated worker is assigned to each family to give hands-on support, has brought about positive outcomes for 444 of Oxfordshire’s most troubled families with real-terms improvements in these areas.

This means more than half (55 per cent) of the 700 families the council has worked with so far, have turned their lives around.

The results we are continuing to see in Oxfordshire demonstrate that, with early intervention into the lives of some families, the scheme is working well.

By taking a firm but positive approach, our dedicated staff are helping families overcome their problems and make positive contributions to society.

It is in everyone’s interest that these families take the necessary steps to get their lives back on track.

If we can do something about chaotic families, we can set people back on the right track in life and give them chances, hopes and (hopefully) happiness and could also save everybody huge amounts of money.

The council has invested £1.6m in the scheme and is on course to secure a further £3m through the Government’s ‘payment by results’ model so that this work can continue in future years.

  • Top News

Our top stories:

Garden centre targeted by burglars for third time this month

Oxford Mail: Thames Valley Police logo

12:16pm Wednesday 27th August 2014

THIEVES attempted to steal a safe and made off with an undisclosed amount of cash after breaking into Millets Farm Centre near Abingdon.

It's heartbreak for Oxford United, but Appleton so proud of team

Oxford Mail:

9:30am Wednesday 27th August 2014

MICHAEL Appleton was hugely proud by the way Oxford United stood up to West Bromwich Albion as a dramatic night saw the underdogs knocked out after a penalty shoot-out.

Six officers face investigation in Jaden inquiry

Oxford Mail:

9:30am Wednesday 27th August 2014

SIX police officers are now under investigation over how the disappearance of murdered teen Jayden Parkinson was handled.

Covered Market robbery 'was to protect family'

Oxford Mail:

9:00am Wednesday 27th August 2014

CLINT TOWNSEND tried to rob a jeweller’s in Oxford’s Covered Market because he was being threatened by “loan sharks”, his sister has claimed.

Bath tragedy home will not be reopened, says NHS trust

Oxford Mail:

8:30am Wednesday 27th August 2014

AN NHS facility where an Oxford teenager died will not reopen according to the health trust that runs it.

Santa’s elf recruiters are feeling festive already

Oxford Mail:

8:30am Wednesday 27th August 2014

IT MAY still be August, but Father Christmas has just started a recruitment drive.

Hunt for witnesses after two men stabbed in chest

Oxford Mail:

8:00am Wednesday 27th August 2014

TWO men stabbed in Rose Hill were recovering in hospital last night.

Keeping the legacy of historic power station alive

Oxford Mail:

8:00am Wednesday 27th August 2014

DIDCOT Civic Hall has embraced its powerful history with a series of artworks.

Sister queries hospital decision on suicidal man

Oxford Mail:

7:00am Wednesday 27th August 2014

THE sister of racehorse trainer James Douglas-Home questioned why a psychiatrist did not admit him to hospital the day before he shot himself in the head.

‘Death penny’ may unlock riddle of unknown soldier

Oxford Mail:

7:00am Wednesday 27th August 2014

A BRONZE coin could unlock the mystery of a man who appears on a North Oxford First World War memorial but not in official records.

St Giles toilets to become offices

Oxford Mail:

6:40am Wednesday 27th August 2014

HISTORIC public toilets in St Giles can be turned into office space, council planning officers have ruled.

Blencowe 'felt in danger when he knifed teenager

Oxford Mail:

6:30am Wednesday 27th August 2014

WILLIAM Blencowe fatally stabbed Connor Tremble because he thought he was in “imminent danger of attack”, a jury was told yesterday.

Racing to victory on a heap of scrap at Red Barn Farm

Oxford Mail:

6:30am Wednesday 27th August 2014

HARRY Dudley and his wacky racer celebrated victory in both categories of the Trax Scrap Heap Challenge at Red Barn Farm, Woodstock Road.

Defibrillator campaign’s taking off after Mail pitches in to help

Oxford Mail:

6:00am Wednesday 27th August 2014

THE number of people in Oxfordshire being trained to use life-saving equipment has soared thanks to an Oxford Mail-backed campaign.

Comments (1)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

10:10pm Wed 21 May 14

JanetJ says...

Yes it is! why wait until children are at school (or not) before taking any action. Support needs to be there for some families from birth.
Yes it is! why wait until children are at school (or not) before taking any action. Support needs to be there for some families from birth. JanetJ
  • Score: 1

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree