A journalist has criticised plans to honour J.R.R. Tolkien at Westminster Abbey.
Writing for Spectator Australie, Alexandar Larman questioned whether Tolkien deserves a place in Poets' Corner.
He acknowledged the author's influence in fantasy fiction but expressed reservations about his literary merits.
He commented: "It is possible to admire Tolkien as a literary figure and storyteller while still being agnostic about the books that he produced."
The forthcoming memorial, celebrating Tolkien’s creative vision and storytelling by artist Stephen Broadbent will be revealed at a dedication ceremony in Spring 2027, which is also the 90th anniversary year of The Hobbit and 50th anniversary year of The Silmarillion.
READ MORE: Oxfordshire village being eyed up for low traffic neighbourhood scheme
The first ever UK Hobbit Festival took place recently. (Image: Emma Trimble / SWNS)
It will be two and a half metres tall and incorporate a piece of the fallen Pinus nigra from Oxford's Botanic Garden, colloquially known as "Tolkien's tree."
Predominantly made from native woods found in the UK, it will include a piece of the iconic black pine, which was felled from Oxford University’s Botanic Garden in 2014.
The tree, a Pinus nigra, was a favourite of Tolkien during his time in Oxford.
The Dean of Westminster, the Very Reverend Dr David Hoyle, said: "We will remember here a master storyteller, a scholar, a man with a Christian imagination and a writer who helped some of us understand that a commitment to life and virtue might be costly and courageous."
Larman acknowledged Tolkien's influence and vision in creating Middle Earth, a world that has become a cornerstone in fantasy fiction.
He also highlighted Tolkien's scholarly contributions to the study of Old and Middle English, noting that his work on Beowulf remains relevant today.
However, he said: "Tolkien’s literary output was tiny compared to many of the writers similarly honoured in Westminster Abbey."
A blue plaque installed where Tolkien lived with his family at 22 Northmoor Road from 1926 to 1930 and at 20 Northmoor Road (above) from 1930 to 1947. (Image: Oxford Blue Plaque Board)
His works primarily consist of The Lord of the Rings trilogy, The Hobbit, and a few other pieces, excluding his academic research.
Larman suggested that Tolkien, who was reportedly uncomfortable with the fame and fortune his writing brought him, would likely not have welcomed the memorial and the ensuing attention.
Tolkien spent his later years in Bournemouth, avoiding fans who sought him out after his books gained popularity with the counter-cultural movement in the 1960s.
Despite Larman's criticism, the memorial will be unveiled next spring, amid a resurgence of interest in Tolkien's life and work.
D.J. Taylor's recent quasi-biography of Tolkien, The King Under the Mountain, has been critically acclaimed as the first serious examination of the author's legacy since 1977.
The announcement of the memorial has sparked a wider conversation about which authors deserve such recognition.
Larman suggested that Agatha Christie should be the next to be honoured in Poets' Corner, noting that this year marked the 50th anniversary of her death.
Share