Harry Potter's Miriam Margolyes new film slammed by critics

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Miriam Margolyes new film has been slammed with a poor review calling it "threadbare" and "unexciting".

Holy Days, starring Miriam Margolyes, has received a brutal two-out-five review.

The Oxford-born actress has starred in multiple films and television shows, including the Harry Potter film series.

The film features three nuns, played by Margolyes, Judy Davis, who stars in Marie Antoinette, and Jacki Weaver, known for her role in The Five-Year Engagement, embarking on a mission with a youngster to save their convent.

The film, directed by Nat Boltt and adapted from Dame Joy Cowley's novel, was found to be a mix of comedy and drama but struggled to establish a strong connection with the audience or deliver significant laughs.

The review said that the film's emotional undertone was not sufficiently compelling to engage viewers.

The endeavour by the fourth character, young Elijah Tamati's Brian, to keep the group together is overshadowed by a perceived lack of intriguing storyline engagement.

Even the picturesque setting of New Zealand did little to alleviate the underwhelming narrative.

The review, The Guardian write Luke Buckmaster, noted that the narrative, which involves the trio of nuns and Brian embarking on a quest to find a property deed to save their convent, became increasingly threadbare, particularly after a mid-movie revelation undermined the central premise.

On the comedy front, the film reportedly resorted to predictable humour, leaning heavily on the 'nuns behaving controversially' trope.

According to the review, the comic punchlines were as subtle as "a giant sign flashing: 'LAUGH.'"

READ MORE: £3million innovative farm which 'suprised' Jeremy Clarkson closes

Miriam Margolyes from Harry Potter rushed to hospitalDespite these criticisms, the review appreciated the contributions of Margolyes (Image: BBC)

Other criticisms included scenarios involving the young Brian making naïve comments or recoiling at the nuns' unexpected behaviour.

As per the review, 'Holy Days' eventually gave way to overt sentimentality, culminating in a rather cringeworthy scene where the main cast had a collective dance-off, complete with large smiles as they embraced the moment.

Despite these criticisms, the review appreciated the contributions of Margolyes, Davis, and Weaver, stating their performances still provided moments of interest.

Margolyes, know for her character actor work across film, television, and stage, received the BAFTA for Best Supporting Actress for her role as Mrs Mingott in Martin Scorsese's 1993 film, The Age of Innocence.

The 85-year-old was awarded an OBE in 2002 for Services to drama, but last July there were calls for this to be taken back.

Ms Margolyes, who is Jewish, had spoken to The Big Issue about Israel’s military campaign in Gaza.

The actress said that it reminded her of the Holocaust and added: “The terrible thing I face is that Hitler won. He changed us, made us like him.”

The Campaign Against Antisemitism (CAA) has responded to Ms Margolyes' remarks and has labelled them as “repugnant”.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos