Letters RSS Feed


MP picks and chooses arguments

IF Banbury MP Tony Baldry really believes that “the only person who should determine when we should die is the Almighty” (Oxford Mail, January 12, and Letters, January 30), then he must logically oppose all forms of medical intervention, including antibiotics, surgery and cancer treatment.

We would return to an age where many women died in childbirth and average life expectancy was 30 years, avoiding human interference with God’s will but surely not desirable.

Like everyone on all sides of the argument, Mr Baldry is picking and choosing which interventions are permissible, rather than laying down absolute rules.

ANN BLACK, Howard Street, Oxford

Comments(5)

morgeo says...
7:20pm Fri 3 Feb 12

The government are doing their best to send people to an early grave by freezing therir pensions. Many pensioners living abroad do not receive any increase from the day that they depart while the majority do get the annual uprating. It then becomes a question of cutting back on heating (Canada gets very cold ) -10C today but can get much colder, cutting back on food and / before making commentsor cutting out some necessary prescriptions. Something has to give and of course there is the mental anguish that this treatment causes. So the MP's and the government should look at themselves before commenting. I would hope that this MP has signed EDM 1895 which would correct this bad government policy. This is done
under regulation 3 of the Social Security BenefitsUp-rating Regulations 2011 where more than half a million pensioners have their pension frozen. Some uprating ! No.

morgeo says...
7:27pm Fri 3 Feb 12

Having just checked the signatories on the EDM 1895 I see that Tony Baldry MP has not signed yet.
So come on Tony, show that you mean what you say.

morgeo says...
2:36pm Sat 4 Feb 12

Oh Tony Baldry, you might nudge David Cameron on this issue as well as he seems to be sleeping.

janeybird says...
10:18pm Sat 4 Feb 12

Spare me from another "christian" member of Parliament. But then MP's and religious doctrines go hand in hand with hypocritical dogma. To do nothing to end the discrimination of senior citizens whose only "crime" is to retire to a "wrong" country is disgraceful. To have their rightful uprating frozen in some countries and not others is in direct conflict of all that a once great nation stood for and indeed fought for in two world wars. That is the right to expect freedom of choice and to be treated fairly. State pensioners have all paid into the same National Insurance fund so all should be treated the same. To single out just 4% for this denial of rights is a stain on the character of all politicians who ignore the plight of these pensioners as they slide into poverty, and a slap in the face for those who served in the forces and those who gave up their lives for freedom from repression. David Cameron, Steve Webb and Iain Duncan Smith et al should all hang their heads in shame.

John J Monaghan says...
2:06pm Mon 6 Feb 12

Well said Janey

click2find

Most popular


About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree