Lenagan: unfair to judge Oxford United boss now (From Oxford Mail)
Get involved: send your photos, videos, news & views by texting OXFORD NEWS to 80360 or email us
Lenagan: unfair to judge Oxford United boss now
9:37am Monday 1st October 2012 in Sport
By David Pritchard, Chief Sports Reporter covering Oxford United. Follow us on twitter: @oxfordmailoufc. Call me on 01865 425458
IAN Lenagan has defended under-fire Chris Wilder, saying it would be "wrong and unfair" to judge the Oxford United manager with the number of injuries in the squad.
A 3-1 loss at Rotherham United on Saturday was United's sixth successive league defeat, equalling a club record in a single season.
But the U's chairman believes the number of injuries affecting the squad this season has been a crucial factor in the slump.
As a result Lenagan is determined not to make any changes until the squad returns to near full strength, despite pressure from some supporters to sack Wilder.
He said: "I am strongly of the opinion that one judges a manager when he has had his squad on the field and not before.
"With the injured players returning at a reasonable rate and most of them scheduled to be back and fit by November, it will not be long before such a judgement can be made.
"To make that judgement now, in my experienced opinion, would be both wrong and unfair and I will not do that - even if some are insistent that we do so."
Comments(54)
AylesburyOx
says...
10:01am Mon 1 Oct 12
So essentially it's the same excuse as last year only we'll continue to be dire all season rather than just part of it.
Excuse on excuse on excuse - I'm sick of hearing about injuries; players get injured - deal with it!
Wilder and co. should be working with the fit players and getting them working as a unit. Those on the pitch are playing without a clue and without any sort of character that I would deem acceptable of anyone wearing an Oxford United shirt.
I will not be attending any further games this season. Honestly, this is hopeless and an insult to those of us who genuinely believed in Lenagan, Wilder, Lewis etc. We meet our end of the deal by paying a great deal of money to ‘the biggest club in league 2’ and in return all we get is false hope and broken promises.
Absolute shambles.
martico1
says...
10:08am Mon 1 Oct 12
WindsorYellow
says...
10:33am Mon 1 Oct 12
Open your eyes
says...
10:36am Mon 1 Oct 12
The injury excuse once again rears it's head when we were told no more excuses. I had faith in Ian Lenagan until this morning and he has done nothing at all to manage and act in the wake of an awful six game period, which needs to be looked at over a longer period of time (since early February 2012 and the terrible Novembers we have every single year).
If he expects me to come and support that clown tomorrow night, he can think again.
BigOx22
says...
10:41am Mon 1 Oct 12
Marina Morris
says...
11:41am Mon 1 Oct 12
BigYellowScarf
says...
12:12pm Mon 1 Oct 12
As for the notion that the team are unmotivated – or, as some rumour-mongers darkly suggest without ever giving their source, “don’t get on with Wilder” and “he’s lost the dressing room” – there isn’t the SLIGHTEST evidence of this. Read Wayne Brown’s current piece (“Everybody’s playing for Chris… There are people outside the club who are trying to put a divide between us, but we’re one unit”) – you can disbelieve him if you want, but why would you want to? I see every reason to believe him. Yes, we all know there have been a couple of very poor performances, but it’s always blindingly obvious when teams are unmotivated and don’t want to play for a manager, and at no point has it ever looked like that AT ALL.
Fortunately most of the people I know DO understand the impact of the injury crisis, and DO see a team that’s working for the manager, and they, like me, will be voting with their feet and turning up tomorrow to support. Come on you yellows.
YellowRose
says...
12:38pm Mon 1 Oct 12
jbowling
says...
12:47pm Mon 1 Oct 12
I think its time for true supporters to either demonstrate (see Bournemouth fans) or boycott games.
Drastic measure required - the bloke just isn't listening
oldun
says...
12:50pm Mon 1 Oct 12
Mind you, an Interest point might be folks expecting to see a record breaking 7th consecutive league defeat.
They will be disappointed - Wimbledon are poor - and
we will get at least a point. Hopefully 3. COYY
oldun
says...
12:50pm Mon 1 Oct 12
Mind you, an Interest point might be folks expecting to see a record breaking 7th consecutive league defeat.
They will be disappointed - Wimbledon are poor - and
we will get at least a point. Hopefully 3. COYY
ox85
says...
1:05pm Mon 1 Oct 12
Doctor69
says...
1:12pm Mon 1 Oct 12
The reality is, it may cost X amount to get shot of Wilder, BUT, it will cost an awful lot more when we are sucked into a relegation dog fight and the crowds drop.....lets not even think beoynd that now!
Wilder has clearly taken us as far as he can. He has assembled the squad. Its lop sided. 3 left backs, 1 right back? No pace in the middle of the park. Injury prone players (Dubes, Leven), lack of creativity, and a lack of goalscorers. the warning signs were there last season and injuries were blamed. Why were they not addressed over the summer?
The current run of form since the Swindon game (early March 2012) to today is appaling, its got to be pushing the worst in the league?
I understand injuries are mounting up, BUT why is this? We were told that fittness would be improved, investments would be made, and here we are again. Also, how many of the injured players would come into the team and actually turn us around?......
Will still be there tomorrow, but the support for the manager has gone for me. the sooner he goes the better.
oldun
says...
1:14pm Mon 1 Oct 12
oldun
says...
1:20pm Mon 1 Oct 12
Malkym
says...
1:22pm Mon 1 Oct 12
Equals the dreaded vote of confidence!!!
For whom the bell tolls - it tolls for thee "Gene" Wilder
OUFC 4 EVA
says...
2:13pm Mon 1 Oct 12
Patrick in Devon
says...
2:26pm Mon 1 Oct 12
Doctor69
says...
2:31pm Mon 1 Oct 12
OUFC 4 EVA wrote:its the managers squad, he knew the long term injuries and the shortcomings it had (lack of goals and a serious lack of pace and quality in the middle of the park).
Why don't you all get a grip and start supporting your team (and its manager!) and try to give the players the motivation to give that little bit more and win a game? it's not all about Wilder and how bad he is, he can only pick a side from the squad he has available! How about the players take some of the blame for this as well?
The chairman isnt blameless, he holds the money, and it looks like he wont invest, like he wont bite the bullet and sack wilder.
OUFC 4 EVA
says...
2:57pm Mon 1 Oct 12
Doctor69 wrote:if the manager goes to the chairman and asks for money to buy a better squad and gets nothing apart from a few loans then what can he do? all you "fans" need to get real and get behind your team!
OUFC 4 EVA wrote: Why don't you all get a grip and start supporting your team (and its manager!) and try to give the players the motivation to give that little bit more and win a game? it's not all about Wilder and how bad he is, he can only pick a side from the squad he has available! How about the players take some of the blame for this as well?its the managers squad, he knew the long term injuries and the shortcomings it had (lack of goals and a serious lack of pace and quality in the middle of the park). The chairman isnt blameless, he holds the money, and it looks like he wont invest, like he wont bite the bullet and sack wilder.
Doctor69
says...
3:20pm Mon 1 Oct 12
OUFC 4 EVA wrote:True, the Chairman does seem to be trying to work on a reduced budget. He also shouldn’t have stated that promotion is the aim before a ball was kicked if he knew we couldn’t compete financially. It sets fans expectations to high and then when sh!t hits the fan, we all moan.
Doctor69 wrote:if the manager goes to the chairman and asks for money to buy a better squad and gets nothing apart from a few loans then what can he do? all you "fans" need to get real and get behind your team!
OUFC 4 EVA wrote: Why don't you all get a grip and start supporting your team (and its manager!) and try to give the players the motivation to give that little bit more and win a game? it's not all about Wilder and how bad he is, he can only pick a side from the squad he has available! How about the players take some of the blame for this as well?its the managers squad, he knew the long term injuries and the shortcomings it had (lack of goals and a serious lack of pace and quality in the middle of the park). The chairman isnt blameless, he holds the money, and it looks like he wont invest, like he wont bite the bullet and sack wilder.
However, Wilder needed to address the shortcomings in his squad over the summer.
For instance, Constable, Smalley, Cradock, Potter, JPP didn’t do it last season, why will they suddenly improve this season?.....So, let’s sign a forward, actually, no, lets sign Rigg!!
Another example, Heslop, the most unfit and un-mobile midfielder around, on a 3 year deal?
Another example, Leven. Classy player when (if ever) fit. Capable of scoring long rangers, but has never been truly fit since arriving and is surely a luxury at this level?
Truth is, Wilder signed these players, gave them the long contracts, or decided they didn’t need replacing in the summer after last season’s implosion. Therefore, he has to take accountability.
I firmly believe Wilders time was up at the end of last season, and the longer he stays, the more stale we will become.
I would love to be proved wrong, but I cannot see it happening. A mid table finish isn’t acceptable to me. Year on year progression should always be the aim so Play Offs, at a minimum should be the benchmark.
And a final point ‘fans like me’ are the ones who buy a season ticket every season, go to cup games at £20 extra per game, travel up and down the country to away games, I think we are entitled to our views on the state the club finds itself. BSP was no fun last time, and I for one fear we would never recover if it happens again.
oldun
says...
3:43pm Mon 1 Oct 12
Micky Hazard
says...
3:47pm Mon 1 Oct 12
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Haven't laughed so much at you lot since Lingy's Leyton Orient side sent you back to your rightful place, ie non-league.
Yeh yeh I know - "We beat you!" etc etc........look where that's got you. Can't wait for the next instalment from the Kassam 'Fawlty Towers' Stadium.
swalker260
says...
4:15pm Mon 1 Oct 12
It does nothing for the club and team yes it is not good but we all know that this situation could change, when we had won our first games and everything looked rosy nothing was heard get behind the team otherwise these comments will pour more pressure on the players which we do not need,confidence is inportant and that will come once we start winning and that will start with Tuesday.
Adman
says...
4:18pm Mon 1 Oct 12
OxRoxBox
says...
4:28pm Mon 1 Oct 12
Doctor69
says...
4:40pm Mon 1 Oct 12
Adman wrote:The owner (chairman) has bankrolled us a bit i know. Its a tough decision, spend out and possibly be succesful or watch the pennies and struggle but ultimately be sustainable. The trouble is the owner & chairman came out and said promotion was the aim.....to achieve this we need investment because we are not good enough.
I thought Lenagan spoke a lot of sense, and clearly is his own man. It always makes me smile when people come on this site and start complaining that the chairman isnt putting his hands in his pockets frequently enough. What right does anyone who pays £250 a year to watch their club have to criticise someone who has already funded the club to the sum of £650,000? Get real, it is not your club, you just support it. You dont have to deal with the real repurcussions of failure (or success!). The club need a little luck, and a couple of results and we will be back in the frey. It's dismal I know losing 6 in a row, and I am not convinced that we can really make the play offs after such a setback, but I think that once Whing and Chapman and a few others come back full time, we can still make some sort of showing this year.
Also, it is the fans club. Look at any team that goes into administration. the Chairman and owners walk away. Who is left, the fans. Who really suffers, the fans. Are you telling me if pompy go out of business the 20K fans are not going to suffer? Tiem for you to get real. Business carries risks.
Chapman and Whing will help, although Chappy has only missed 2 games? I still feel there is a massive lack of creativity and ultimately goals?
BigOx22
says...
4:43pm Mon 1 Oct 12
COYY
Beau champ mummy
says...
4:55pm Mon 1 Oct 12
adlibber
says...
5:02pm Mon 1 Oct 12
kckidlington
says...
6:06pm Mon 1 Oct 12
BigYellowScarf wrote:At last someone with sense
I’m sorry some of you are sick of hearing the excuse about injuries. D’you know what? I’m sick of reading posts that bizarrely think of injuries as excuses. INJURIES MATTER – IN A BIG WAY. You’re doing a job with crucial equipment missing. And the scale of the problem that Wilder’s been facing – and for a very long period now – would have taxed ANY manager. It’s been exceptional (in the words of Mickey Lewis “I’ve known nothing like it in my 30 years in the game”) and it’s amazing that some people just don’t get that.
As for the notion that the team are unmotivated – or, as some rumour-mongers darkly suggest without ever giving their source, “don’t get on with Wilder” and “he’s lost the dressing room” – there isn’t the SLIGHTEST evidence of this. Read Wayne Brown’s current piece (“Everybody’s playing for Chris… There are people outside the club who are trying to put a divide between us, but we’re one unit”) – you can disbelieve him if you want, but why would you want to? I see every reason to believe him. Yes, we all know there have been a couple of very poor performances, but it’s always blindingly obvious when teams are unmotivated and don’t want to play for a manager, and at no point has it ever looked like that AT ALL.
Fortunately most of the people I know DO understand the impact of the injury crisis, and DO see a team that’s working for the manager, and they, like me, will be voting with their feet and turning up tomorrow to support. Come on you yellows.
oldun
says...
6:43pm Mon 1 Oct 12
oldun
says...
6:43pm Mon 1 Oct 12
wend
says...
7:30pm Mon 1 Oct 12
oldun
says...
7:45pm Mon 1 Oct 12
Beau champ mummy
says...
8:06pm Mon 1 Oct 12
wend
says...
9:08pm Mon 1 Oct 12
Beau champ mummy wrote:Oh dear a gender neanderthal - I've never watched eastenders. If you can't make a sensible comment don't make any. Shtum pal
Wend stick to east Enders and making tea
marathon2012
says...
11:34pm Mon 1 Oct 12
Jim Rosenthal gone Kelvin Thomas gone football gone to pot.
Lenagan has got what he wants Rugby at the kassam why would he put money in to the football when he has Premiership Rugby the only sport he really understands
This could be the demise of oxford as we know it. I hope not supported them for 50 years since i was a kid and i have not known it this bad went to the Rugby and who was there Lenagan make your own minds up.
COYY
hawkeye1
says...
12:36am Tue 2 Oct 12
In_The_Nikon_Time
says...
12:41am Tue 2 Oct 12
Most you thought Wilder was a god after the first 3 games, nothing has changed. Stability is the key to success.
oldun
says...
4:24am Tue 2 Oct 12
oldun
says...
4:24am Tue 2 Oct 12
adlibber
says...
7:06am Tue 2 Oct 12
AylesburyOx
says...
9:22am Tue 2 Oct 12
adlibber wrote:As usual, you talk a lot of sense. Well said.
Those defending Wilder and his fabulous achievements this season so far plus his spectacular avoidance of a certain play off spot last season - I hope your blind faith is rewarded with success. For the rest of us well we're only basing our doubt on many years of abject failure cheap fixes average players and managers that have one trick often overused in readiness for the next hapless Plan A specialist to take over. As for injuries as an excuse how do other teams cope better? Remembering laughing at our mighty team playing minnows like Crawley - look what happened to them eh - lost their manager brought in an unknown and hey look their still doing well. As for the 'we're only 9 pts from top of table' rubbish no one is mentioning that we're only 5pts from relegation and given our last 6 performances I'm guessing the part of the table we'll be most fond of is the bottom bit. Lenagan is not interested in football.
Brenda Jackson
says...
9:34am Tue 2 Oct 12
''I'll judge the manager when he has a full Squad to choose from'' - Like most of last season Mr Lenagan -When we were atrocious?
We have the same squad of players now
albeit many of them on the sick list, what makes the Chairman think that once they
are ready to return they will be suddenly much better players than last season?
I predict a 'mini revival' and we'll get four points out of the next two home matches, then the old habits will return- a pattern that will repeat itself, and we will just about, but only just, avoid the fall.
Talking of falling, when the inevitable happens and the gates fall, what's the betting the Chairman will be complaining about lack of support?
My answer would be, you have had tremendous support as a bottom tier football club- and what have you done to repay that support?
Served up dire, and losing 'football' in a souless stadium- did you really think you could hang on to 7/8,000 attendances?
Major changes are needed, not just managerial either imo.
In_The_Nikon_Time
says...
10:20am Tue 2 Oct 12
adlibber wrote:9 points from the league leaders is FACT not rubbish. we are less than 2 months into the season so to talk of relegation IS Rubbish. I don't have "Blind Faith", I can see things are not right but, I support my team through thick and thin not just when things are going well. We all want to win every week but no matter who the manager is, it's never going to happen.
Those defending Wilder and his fabulous achievements this season so far plus his spectacular avoidance of a certain play off spot last season - I hope your blind faith is rewarded with success. For the rest of us well we're only basing our doubt on many years of abject failure cheap fixes average players and managers that have one trick often overused in readiness for the next hapless Plan A specialist to take over. As for injuries as an excuse how do other teams cope better? Remembering laughing at our mighty team playing minnows like Crawley - look what happened to them eh - lost their manager brought in an unknown and hey look their still doing well. As for the 'we're only 9 pts from top of table' rubbish no one is mentioning that we're only 5pts from relegation and given our last 6 performances I'm guessing the part of the table we'll be most fond of is the bottom bit. Lenagan is not interested in football.
OxRoxBox
says...
10:42am Tue 2 Oct 12
This season is heading in a similar fashion.
Please polish your lens and see the clearer picture - your long lens should help you then realise that our form is on the wane and spiralling
adlibber
says...
12:19pm Tue 2 Oct 12
In_The_Nikon_Time wrote:6 defeats on the bounce clearly fiction in your world yes?
adlibber wrote:9 points from the league leaders is FACT not rubbish. we are less than 2 months into the season so to talk of relegation IS Rubbish. I don't have "Blind Faith", I can see things are not right but, I support my team through thick and thin not just when things are going well. We all want to win every week but no matter who the manager is, it's never going to happen.
Those defending Wilder and his fabulous achievements this season so far plus his spectacular avoidance of a certain play off spot last season - I hope your blind faith is rewarded with success. For the rest of us well we're only basing our doubt on many years of abject failure cheap fixes average players and managers that have one trick often overused in readiness for the next hapless Plan A specialist to take over. As for injuries as an excuse how do other teams cope better? Remembering laughing at our mighty team playing minnows like Crawley - look what happened to them eh - lost their manager brought in an unknown and hey look their still doing well. As for the 'we're only 9 pts from top of table' rubbish no one is mentioning that we're only 5pts from relegation and given our last 6 performances I'm guessing the part of the table we'll be most fond of is the bottom bit. Lenagan is not interested in football.
Doctor69
says...
1:17pm Tue 2 Oct 12
adlibber wrote:Yes we are only 9 points off the auto places....but are we really going to make them up, and stay constant over the course of the season not to drop further points? No way! The league winners will probably lose 6 games over the whole season.
In_The_Nikon_Time wrote:6 defeats on the bounce clearly fiction in your world yes?
adlibber wrote:9 points from the league leaders is FACT not rubbish. we are less than 2 months into the season so to talk of relegation IS Rubbish. I don't have "Blind Faith", I can see things are not right but, I support my team through thick and thin not just when things are going well. We all want to win every week but no matter who the manager is, it's never going to happen.
Those defending Wilder and his fabulous achievements this season so far plus his spectacular avoidance of a certain play off spot last season - I hope your blind faith is rewarded with success. For the rest of us well we're only basing our doubt on many years of abject failure cheap fixes average players and managers that have one trick often overused in readiness for the next hapless Plan A specialist to take over. As for injuries as an excuse how do other teams cope better? Remembering laughing at our mighty team playing minnows like Crawley - look what happened to them eh - lost their manager brought in an unknown and hey look their still doing well. As for the 'we're only 9 pts from top of table' rubbish no one is mentioning that we're only 5pts from relegation and given our last 6 performances I'm guessing the part of the table we'll be most fond of is the bottom bit. Lenagan is not interested in football.
As stated by myself, and several other posters, the run we are on, including end of last season is shocking. The 3 wins at the start of this season were a blip, thats all. I also dont belive that any fan who has been going for a number of seasons belived all our troubles were over 3 games into a new season.
3 points tonight is essential, because otherwise with Gillingham on saturday, and Port Vale the following Monday it could easily be no wins in 9
In_The_Nikon_Time
says...
6:36pm Tue 2 Oct 12
"6 defeats on the bounce clearly fiction in your world yes?"
Your words not mine, fortunately I live in the real world and I can speak for myself. Yes its a FACT we have lost 6 on the bounce we well may lose more. My post is and was about getting behind and supporting my team - Oxford United. You are absolutely entitled to your opinion as I am mine, neither is more valid than the other.
oldun
says...
6:57pm Tue 2 Oct 12
Severely struggling teams at any level above parks pitch will draw two or three of any nine matches
seven in a row can't happen - a new club record for United - impossible - Dons are struggling
oldun
says...
6:57pm Tue 2 Oct 12
Severely struggling teams at any level above parks pitch will draw two or three of any nine matches
seven in a row can't happen - a new club record for United - impossible - Dons are struggling
oldun
says...
9:48pm Tue 2 Oct 12

northampton yellow says...
9:57am Mon 1 Oct 12