Baby is not 'disabled enough' for benefits (From Oxford Mail)
Get involved: send your photos, videos, news & views by texting OXFORD NEWS to 80360 or email us
Baby is not 'disabled enough' for benefits
11:00am Thursday 30th August 2012 in Oxford
By Amanda Williams
Leah Cato with seven-month-old Max who was born with Hirschsprung’s disease which severely affects his bowel. She has been told that he does not qualify for Disability Living Allowance
THE mother of a baby who will be incontinent for the rest of his life has been told he is currently not disabled enough for benefits.
Seven-month-old Max Royan was born with Hirschsprung’s disease which severely affects his bowel.
As a result of a series of operations he will always be faecally incontinent.
At the moment Max, from Garsington, has a colostomy bag, but after an operation within the next few months, mother Leah Cato said she has been told he will need more than 30 nappy changes a day.
The average baby will go through around eight changes a day.
Ms Cato, who also has two healthy daughters, said she applied for Disability Living Allowance (DLA) to help with the costs of extra nappies and special creams for her baby son but was told that even after the operation he would be no more disabled than any other baby his age.
She said: “I have had two children before Max and I know he is not ‘just the same as any other baby’.
“The operation will leave Max completely incontinent. He will always be incontinent.
“The consultant has said he will constantly need changing, and will also be very sore so will need special creams which don’t come cheap. He also has special dietary requirements.
“To look at him you would think he is like any other healthy baby.
“But he isn’t.”
Hirschsprung’s disease usually affects sufferers by causing an obstruction in the bowel.
But in Max’s case – total colon Hirschsprung’s – his other complications and surgery will mean he will be unable to control his bowel movements at all.
Ms Cato, 32, said any additional money from the DLA would help the family.
She added that without DLA support she cannot apply for a carer’s allowance, which would allow her to be able to care for her son full- time.
She is due to return to work soon and cannot afford to pay for a specialist nursery which could care for her son.
A Department for Works and Pensions spokesman said Disability Living Allowance was not generally paid on the condition someone has, but because they have specific care and mobility needs.
He added: “All young children have care and mobility needs but parents can claim DLA for children who need a lot more help or supervision than other children of the same age.
“Anyone who disagrees with a decision can ask the department to look at the case again, presenting any new evidence, or appeal the decision.”
Ms Cato said she and her partner would be appealing.
Sara Jones, from Wigan, set up CHAMPS (Curing Hirschsprung’s And Making Positive Steps) after her own son Jacob, now five, was diagnosed. She said: “DLA for Hirschsprung’s is so hit and miss.
“It is very hard for people to prove it’s a disability.
“Life became much easier for us when we were approved for it.
“It’s easy for them to say your child is not disabled, but they don’t see your child screaming blue murder each night because they need constant changing and they’re in pain.
“I know people who have to go through 50 nappies a day.”
About the condition:
Hirschsprung’s is a life-threatening, congenital condition where the nerve supply of an area of the bowel has not developed properly
This causes a blockage of the large intestine due to improper muscle movement in the bowel.
Usually discovered either within the first few days or weeks of birth, the condition is rare and only occurs in about one in 5,000 children.
Treatment to remove the diseased bowel can make the sufferer incontinent.
Comments(19)
Feelingsmatter
says...
2:29pm Thu 30 Aug 12
sandra2012
says...
3:34pm Thu 30 Aug 12
nt is costly.also he was in and out of hospital a lot.this is costly as you have to pay for parking and meals.then theres the different medications he needed.again costly.in my opinion she should be given the payment.I didn't receive any payment for my son (I live in Ireland) but if I had it would have really helped.
Myron Blatz
says...
3:57pm Thu 30 Aug 12
matthewsmum
says...
4:55pm Thu 30 Aug 12
flowers68
says...
5:08pm Thu 30 Aug 12
tion (just to name a few) Son ~ diapers,creams, colostomy bags flanges iliostomy bags flanges, long distance Doc appointiments, surgeries, (not to mention, 9 years of washing childs bedding down every morning: having to pay for a tutour for child because he is way behind in school as a result of constantly waking up in the middle of the night in a mess, entrocolitis,bowel obstructions, ect.... so I do not believe that anyone in their right mind could say these children r the same a a child without Hirschsprung's...... further more us hd parents work so hard to make them appear normal. Just cause a person can't see the disabilitie does not mean its not their! All the best and this baby will require way more expenses then a healthy child, the family should push for this as a baby cause every week the family has to come up with the extra money and if they can't the child is the one to suffer!
Max's mum
says...
5:27pm Thu 30 Aug 12
My son has no large intestine and 20cm missing from his small intestine. Obviously that doesn't mean that he is fine until he has his operation to reverse his stoma in a couple of months time, as you are suggesting.
He currently has a colostomy bag which needs regular changing and cleaning to keep it from getting sore or infected. He constantly has stool coming from it, day and night.
How many babies do you know that poo out of their tummies?? My maternity leave has now ended and if I went back to work, who would change his bag for him? At present, only me and my partner do it, we had to be trained how to do it, and believe me, its not easy. When it leaks it messes all his clothes and bedding, and makes his skin extremely sore. So sore that it bleeds. He had his last operation 4 months ago and his skin still hasn't healed properly due to it being constantly covered in stool.
He also gets dehydrated as fluid passes through him a lot quicker than other children. We have to give him sodium supplements for this.
Yeah I guess he's just like any other baby.
a hd nana
says...
5:55pm Thu 30 Aug 12
karen moon
says...
7:50pm Thu 30 Aug 12
Myron Blatz
says...
9:29pm Thu 30 Aug 12
A Hirschsprung's Mummy
says...
9:38pm Thu 30 Aug 12
Also, to address the first couple of comments - this mother is caring for a child who has HAD operations and will require more. It's a long process which spans over months: Biopsy tests to confirm the disease; irrigations; for Children that weren’t diagnosed at birth a Stoma is created so that the good bowel has time to recover from being severely stretched due to being backed up with poop because the section with Hirschsprung's couldn't push it along; followed by a major and lengthy operation to actually remove the affected bowel, which for some involves a significant amount. This lady's little boy currently has a Stoma which means the child requires specialist care that is extremely time consuming so to say the little boy hasn't got any needs which differ from those of other babies is ludicrous.
The children affected by this condition are very brave little souls indeed and they, along with us parents caring for them, deserve support. Sadly as it's a rare condition the lack of awareness and understanding often means that it’s a battle to get help. Fortunately we were granted DLA (middle rate) on first application (my boy currently has an Ileostomy). Leah - appeal and I’m sure upon review the right decision will be made. Good luck x
Summer83
says...
11:57pm Thu 30 Aug 12
xjohnx
says...
6:47am Fri 31 Aug 12
Max's mum wrote:I understand your story.
I think the first person who commented on this didn't really understand the story.
My son has no large intestine and 20cm missing from his small intestine. Obviously that doesn't mean that he is fine until he has his operation to reverse his stoma in a couple of months time, as you are suggesting.
He currently has a colostomy bag which needs regular changing and cleaning to keep it from getting sore or infected. He constantly has stool coming from it, day and night.
How many babies do you know that poo out of their tummies?? My maternity leave has now ended and if I went back to work, who would change his bag for him? At present, only me and my partner do it, we had to be trained how to do it, and believe me, its not easy. When it leaks it messes all his clothes and bedding, and makes his skin extremely sore. So sore that it bleeds. He had his last operation 4 months ago and his skin still hasn't healed properly due to it being constantly covered in stool.
He also gets dehydrated as fluid passes through him a lot quicker than other children. We have to give him sodium supplements for this.
Yeah I guess he's just like any other baby.
I also understand the benefit system.
The lady should contact the CAB as I advised, at present she is making claims the benefit system ( all of us ) will not consider.
Max's mum
says...
9:23am Fri 31 Aug 12
xjohnx wrote:Did you not read the above comments??
Max's mum wrote:I understand your story.
I think the first person who commented on this didn't really understand the story.
My son has no large intestine and 20cm missing from his small intestine. Obviously that doesn't mean that he is fine until he has his operation to reverse his stoma in a couple of months time, as you are suggesting.
He currently has a colostomy bag which needs regular changing and cleaning to keep it from getting sore or infected. He constantly has stool coming from it, day and night.
How many babies do you know that poo out of their tummies?? My maternity leave has now ended and if I went back to work, who would change his bag for him? At present, only me and my partner do it, we had to be trained how to do it, and believe me, its not easy. When it leaks it messes all his clothes and bedding, and makes his skin extremely sore. So sore that it bleeds. He had his last operation 4 months ago and his skin still hasn't healed properly due to it being constantly covered in stool.
He also gets dehydrated as fluid passes through him a lot quicker than other children. We have to give him sodium supplements for this.
Yeah I guess he's just like any other baby.
I also understand the benefit system.
The lady should contact the CAB as I advised, at present she is making claims the benefit system ( all of us ) will not consider.
Buffetcrasher
says...
9:37pm Fri 31 Aug 12
Buffetcrasher
says...
9:56pm Fri 31 Aug 12
Lord Palmerstone
says...
9:09am Sun 2 Sep 12
Oxford City Council will contact residents to help them find work and understand the universal credit changes covering income and housing benefit which are being rolled into a single payment. from next year."
Not "universal" I think: few will fly to Somalia-or indeed Roumania, or Mars-to pick up a welfare cheque. No, it's just sad old, soft old, England.
fronfoot
says...
2:57pm Tue 4 Sep 12
leahp1983
says...
4:38pm Sat 8 Sep 12
As soon as I turned 16 they cut it off despite appeals so I have had to work myself into the ground to pay for everything myself and that made me very ill so I chose to have a stoma back 2 years ago as I was still incontinent at 28 years old and enough was enough!
Maybe the people who sit there assesing these forms should actually get off theit butts and spend a day in the life of someone with hirschsprungs and then tell us we're "NORMAL".
xjohnx says...
1:29pm Thu 30 Aug 12
The cost of nappies and medicinal creams will be met by the NHS, not the benefit agencies.
In this country, parents are expected take care of babes in arms. As the child grows, benefits will become payable.
This lady should contact the CAB for proper advice.