Abingdon's £50k Jubilee celebrations bill branded 'madness' (From Oxford Mail)
Get involved: send your photos, videos, news & views by texting OXFORD NEWS to 80360 or email us
Abingdon's £50k Jubilee celebrations bill branded 'madness'
6:00pm Wednesday 9th May 2012 in Abingdon
By Ben Wilkinson, Crime Reporter. Call me on (01865) 425427
OPPONENTS have criticised big spending plans for the Queen’s Jubilee celebrations in Abingdon as “madness”.
Abingdon Town Council has put aside £50,000 for next month’s four-day celebration, more than 20 times what neighbouring Didcot Town Council will spend.
Events to mark Queen Elizabeth’s 60 years on the throne will include a street party in Ock Street, bun-throwing, park festivals and firework displays.
But Angela Lawrence, independent member for Northcourt, said: “I think £50,000 is a horrific amount. It’s out of proportion.”
She added of the Queen’s reign: “It’s an achievement and, whether you are a Royalist or a Republican, I think we all admire the Queen.
“We can respect and celebrate 60 years but to spend £50,000 when there are so many things our town needs just seems mad. It is an irresponsible amount to spend.”
The authority, which has an annual budget of about £1.3m, also hopes to spend about £15,000 on a bandstand.
Samantha Bowring, Lib Dem member for Ock Meadow, said it was likely a significant amount of extra cash had been spent on administration and publicity.
She said: “I don’t think it is what people want.”
Sandy Lovatt, leader of the Conservative-run council, said the authority hoped to reduce the cost to £30,000 through sponsorship from businesses and ticket sales to some of the events.
He said: “We feel we have to put on a big celebration.
“We are the second biggest town in Oxfordshire and we have a lot of tradition with events like the bun-throwing.
“The town is notable in it’s desire to celebrate royal occasions.
“We are getting great enthusiasm from the population on what we are doing.”
Aidan Melville, Labour councillor for Caldecott, said: “It may seem like an extravagance but it’s the Queen’s 60th Jubilee and it’s worth marking. But where we can be wise with budget, we should be.”
Didcot Town Council’s deputy clerk Karen Dodd said £2,200 would be spent on the town’s celebrations.
She said: “Didcot Town Council is mindful of the need to balance the expenditure of public funds against the desire to properly celebrate and commemorate the Queen’s Diamond Jubilee.”
Wantage Town Council has budgeted £10,000 but expects to spend less than £2,000, and Wallingford Town Council said it would spend no more than £5,000.
Oxford City Council and Bicester Town Council are combining celebrations with annual events and do not anticipate extra spending.
Banbury and Witney Town Councils said they were funding celebrations through sponsorship from businesses.
Comments are closed on this article.
Comments (66)
6:17pm Wed 9 May 12
PK Nuts says...
6:45pm Wed 9 May 12
wizardofox2 says...
8:29pm Wed 9 May 12
saddletramp says...
org/wiki/Banbury
http://en.wikipedia.
org/wiki/Abingdon,_O
xfordshire
Good to know that Sandy Lovatt is so in touch with what is going on,that she thinks Abingdon is the 2nd biggest town in Oxfordshire,despite being smaller than Banbury!
9:31pm Wed 9 May 12
goridebus says...
PK Nuts - councillors don't have a salary. And please don't forget that councillors are taxpayers too!
10:11pm Wed 9 May 12
PK Nuts says...
11:53pm Wed 9 May 12
Iain L says...
11:54pm Wed 9 May 12
Iain L says...
12:29am Thu 10 May 12
Abingdon Neil says...
£50,000 (probably more once staff time is accounted for) is a huge amount of money to spend on events that could be run for much less and still be just as enjoyable.
Why is the Town Council spending thousands of pounds paying for a big screen to watch a concert which could have been put on in local pubs, supporting town businesses at the same time.
Why is the Council paying for the closure of Ock Street for a day, and causing all the disruption that goes with it, when it could have run an equally good event on the Market Place or in Abbey Grounds?
Everyone would have been delighted with a traditional bun-throwing and a few extra events but there is no need to throw money at it like the Town Council seems to be doing.
Abingdon is indeed the second largest town in Oxfordshire. Banbury, which is the largest, is celebrating the Jubille with a number of events but spedning far, far less than Abingdon to do so.
7:39am Thu 10 May 12
Lord Palmerstone says...
8:34am Thu 10 May 12
wizardofox2 says...
8:57am Thu 10 May 12
Iain L says...
The budget is indeed £50k but as Sandy mentions in the article the expected cost will be around £30k . As I know you are aware (I think we discussed the point at the agm) this is to do with prudent budgeting rather in case sponsorship did not materialise, however this money is not expected to be required.
The budget does include staffing costs relating to jubilee events.
Also these expected costs are approximately in line with what tge previous administration had earmarked for the event.
More importantly, I recall at tge agm that you welcomed that we were taking the jubilee seriously, so let's not spoil what will be a fantastic community celebration in June with party political point scoring.
9:05am Thu 10 May 12
carioca says...
9:18am Thu 10 May 12
Abingdon Neil says...
I strongly support Abingdon putting on good events for the Jubilee, my concern is that they are also good value for money and I cited specific examples of where I thought the same or similar positive outcomes could be achieved at less expense.
By 'party political point scoring' I assume you mean 'expressing a different point of view'?
9:23am Thu 10 May 12
Iain L says...
More importantly I think there's a plan for beer and curry on Tuesday (Richard organising) if you fancy joining us (I usually get outnumbered politically there so you can have done fun)
9:23am Thu 10 May 12
Abberdon says...
Perhaps OXFAM could be in attendance at the bun throwing to pick up all the dirty buns for the poor folk to eat later?
If the Queen came to town, she could be put to good use opening another charity shop, in the new revamped charity shop arcade once known as the shopping centre, and people from Didcot might flood over buying the gear to look a little smarter than now, eh Lord P?
I do hope we have a four day long Morris Dance intercounty dance-off up and down Ock Street with a 'stuff yer face with buns' eat-off to compliment it, that would be really good.
11:37am Thu 10 May 12
Notopolotics says...
2:37pm Thu 10 May 12
Abingdon Rob says...
9:23am Thu 10 May 12
Delightful. But do any of our councillors have interests in local bakeries, which stand to make a fortune?
Is a local bakery making the buns? i looked at the town council website and couldnt find who was doing and what the different bakerys quoted for the buns.
5:11pm Thu 10 May 12
Abingdon Neil says...
@Iain - I will do my best - I've got a 7pm meeting in Botley but will pop in later if I've time. Is it at Tiffins? BTW - I am equally capable of disagreeing with those in my party too you know ;-)
5:21pm Thu 10 May 12
Iain L says...
Ps you're correct about tescos who are providing buns at a highly discounted rate as part of their community outreach programme - a step in the right direction at least although I think I share your general view about tescos (the expresses at least)
6:04pm Thu 10 May 12
wizardofox2 says...
6:24pm Thu 10 May 12
HPG says...
7:21pm Thu 10 May 12
davidofabingdon says...
11:50pm Thu 10 May 12
Abberdon says...
grocer, wants to 'outreach' to the community, the one where it drives small business out of business by opening small TESCO shops on top of their giant ones, then maybe they should GIVE the buns away, not sell them at a 'discount'?
Just as well I mentioned the source of the buns, eh?
Maybe Abberdon's citizenry should drop in to Tiffins and lob a few buns at the table of councillors, to let them really know what they think of 50 thousand smackers going on an orgy of doubtful value?
If the Tories cannot see the problem with demanding Greek style austerity from we Brits at the same time as they fawn over a royal family by paying out scarce public funds to glorify their queen, then they deserve to be laughed at, and have buns thrown at them.
8:24am Fri 11 May 12
Iain L says...
Wizard, Abberdon - I'm sure tiffins would welcome your custom. Would be happy to continue the debate in person but would be difficult to recognise you given that you choose to operate behind the cloak of anonymity. If you feel strongly about how things are done, as I do, you could always put yourself forward for election and try and do something about it rather than trolling from the sidelines.
8:24am Fri 11 May 12
Iain L says...
Wizard, Abberdon - I'm sure tiffins would welcome your custom. Would be happy to continue the debate in person but would be difficult to recognise you given that you choose to operate behind the cloak of anonymity. If you feel strongly about how things are done, as I do, you could always put yourself forward for election and try and do something about it rather than trolling from the sidelines.
8:26am Fri 11 May 12
Iain L says...
9:11am Fri 11 May 12
Abberdon says...
Tiffins are the innocents here comrade, I think the buns will be aimed at the elected, not the servant servers of the elected.
And when you come to accusations of trolling, that ratrher assumes that your posts are regarded as squeaky-clean by every reader here does it?
Did I read a comment on your ability to take-over this thread to organise your social life?
Does that show a total disregard for genuine readers and posters here?
David seeks a lasting ebenefit for the town- is that trolling too?
But of course, there will be a lasting benefit won't there?
Another set of fossilised buns in the town museum for our children and grand children to gaze in wonder at and say...
WOW! that bun cost 50k quid, but thankfully the Great Grocer Tesco supplied it for only 30k quid, that's really Community Outreach at its best!
9:39am Fri 11 May 12
Iain L says...
3:21pm Fri 11 May 12
Abingdon Neil says...
3:58pm Fri 11 May 12
davidofabingdon says...
6:41pm Fri 11 May 12
Feelingsmatter says...
Totally agree, although I don't feel it's appropriate to arrange a social get-together on a public forum. It's hardly setting a good example about online safety, plus, if you know each other why not directly email?
That aside, I am almost incandescent with rage at the waste of OUR money!! (Almost, because I save absolute incandescence for matters relating to the NHS). I do not choose to live under the ancient spell of a family born into great privilege and money, and when I think that the amount being squandered on this big party would keep Abingdon Alzheimer's Cub running for a whole YEAR I want to cordially invite the stuck-up fools who made this decision to meet me for a drink and a chat.
I would stand for election if I wasn't so busy raising my two boys with special needs without any financial or practical support.............
...
8:16am Sat 12 May 12
wizardofox2 says...
11:06am Sat 12 May 12
cynicality says...
11:42am Sat 12 May 12
Abberdon says...
No doubt while they all slum it with champers and big fat steaks, telling themselves what a 'jolly good job we done' with the Queens bash.
2:00pm Sat 12 May 12
orangefoot says...
I can't be sure but I imagine that there would be plenty of cries along the lines of 'even more cuts' and people asking where the money that has been earmarked for this would be spent instead.
9:05pm Sat 12 May 12
Abingdon Neil says...
9:18pm Sat 12 May 12
icecreamlady says...
12:31am Sun 13 May 12
Iain L says...
The total expenditure will be far closer to cllr lovatt's estimates than the budget which insides a large and prudent contingency.
The major items of expenditure are staffing of road closures etc, screen hire for the national concerts, street decorations and somoe fireworks.
You can of course take the headlines on face value if you prefer.
1:01am Sun 13 May 12
DoctorBob says...
1:51am Sun 13 May 12
Abberdon says...
10:49am Sun 13 May 12
steve1955 says...
10:28am Mon 14 May 12
Dr D Prest says...
11:23am Mon 14 May 12
Abingdon Neil says...
11:32am Mon 14 May 12
DoctorBob says...
1:09pm Mon 14 May 12
Ellie the Bruce says...
1:27pm Mon 14 May 12
steve1955 says...
But did the romans have so many levels of government national and local all with people on them taking money out of the public purse for their ego trips and wasting scarce funds on jollies not forgetting expenses after all they all beg to be elected ?
2:40pm Mon 14 May 12
colbart says...
5:19pm Mon 14 May 12
Feelingsmatter says...
12:31am Sun 13 May 12
"The budget is entirely public and in no way secret - if you wish to understand the detail please don't hesitate to pop into the council offices - this is not a secret activity
The total expenditure will be far closer to cllr lovatt's estimates than the budget which insides a large and prudent contingency.
You can of course take the headlines on face value if you prefer."
Bit of a snotty comment, if I may be so blunt. No one is criticising the transparency of the celebrations, we're just stunned by the waste of money!!
Could I ask you to clarify one of your points as I can't understand it; "The total expenditure will be far closer to cllr lovatt's estimates than the budget which insides a large and prudent contingency."
6:07pm Mon 14 May 12
Iain L says...
Regarding your query - I think the computer's autocorrect kicked in. It should say 'actual figure will be closer to the figure quoted by cllr Lovatt as the budget includes a large contingency for reasons of prudence' (or sonething like that anyway)
10:04pm Mon 14 May 12
DoctorBob says...
12:04am Tue 15 May 12
Abberdon says...
Of course, for the literal amongst we posters, the Romans did produce far more than the Royals ever have, here or in other nation-states, but isn't that also part of the original joke?
What next? Well if anyone sees our councillor blogger with a gourd in his hands, or holding a sandal, we know where the mob will go already.
Let's just hope no one makes any cracks about 'the bunmakers inheriting the Earth'.
We all know that is for the Greeks, and aren't they doing a good job of that right now?
So, if the buns are only costing 500quid, where is the other 49500 going?
It was almost more reassuring to think that the whole 50k quid was going on buns for the Massive Pelting in the market place. Now I really am upset at the cost!
9:07am Tue 15 May 12
steve king says...
9:18am Tue 15 May 12
Iain L says...
9:29am Tue 15 May 12
steve1955 says...
9:39am Tue 15 May 12
steve king says...
10:29am Tue 15 May 12
GTS kiddy says...
3:30pm Tue 15 May 12
Feelingsmatter says...
3:35pm Tue 15 May 12
steve1955 says...
5:33pm Tue 15 May 12
Feelingsmatter says...
2:29am Wed 16 May 12
Abberdon says...
So, with that in mind, what about a perpetual Morris dancer?
Day and night, 24/7, 365 days a year, tinkling bells, bashing sticks, drinking Abingdon Bridge all the while, and prancing from one end of Ock Street, around the Market Square and back again, starting and finishing each round at the White Horse?
THAT would put Abingdon-on-Thames on the map, bring tourists by the coachload, fame and fortune to the charity shop industry of Abingdon, and may even start a new line in replica Morris gear- who knows where such a forward thinking idea could take our moribund town?
As for paying councillors, let us use the Abingdon Charity Shop Scale as the relevant marker.
Count the ones we have now, make that the 100% level, and pay them more as the shops close, through lack of use, and less when more open up, due to poor economic conditions and the need for extra 'charity'.
BUT, let's not stop there, how about using this as the trial basis for a national MP and senior beaurocrat pay scale?
They all love measuring everything but their own performance, so this would be a world first.
What does our chatty councillor think?
8:35am Wed 16 May 12
Iain L says...
I'm not convinced about you perpetual Morris machine idea, although I guess Morris dancing is as good a tradition as any to recognise in a lasting memorial. I understand the two rival Morris troops are dancing together for the first time ever in a specially created dance at the jubilee celebrations which is quite nice (I had never realised how much politics there is in Morris dancing).
The article is slightly misleading on a permanent memorial in the it is £5k rather than £15k that was put aside in the budget (i dont think any decisions have been made on it yet) and the idea (not mine by the way) is that this should be used as seed funding for some sort of public subscription scheme, like happened for the Albert memorial for example, to create a permanent jubilee memorial, with a bandstand being the initial idea proposed.
On your point about performance related pay for councillors I probably agree in principle but think the reality for the town council is it would cost more to administer than the 21x£760 currently paid in allowances (in fact less as not all councillors claim the allowance).
In reality councillors (in non safe areas like abingdon anyway) get hired or fired every 4 years by the electorate who get to make their own judgement as to our performance.
On the serious point about allowances, my view is that we need to make it possible for people from a wide variety of backgrounds and circumstances be able to afford to become councillors. Regardless of what is often suggested in these threads, the reality is that most councillors are very conscientious and put in a lot of time often at the expense of time spent working which obviously has a financial impact on those of us who work.
Anyway - there's a slightly verbose answer for you - happy to discuss this or any of the issues hilighted in the thread in person if you're serious - I can be contacted via the council website.
Ps thanks for not pelting me with buns at my curry last night - tiffins was excellent as always.
9:27am Wed 16 May 12
steve1955 says...
11:39am Wed 16 May 12
Iain L says...
Turnout at last years local elections was around about 48% in Vale (not sure of exact figures for Abingdon but will be about that) which I agree is depressingly low. I fail to understand why people don't use a right so many of our forefathers fought for, and which people are still dying in order to gain in other countries.
In regard to why councillors put themselves forward, we all have different reasons, but I think none of us have become town councillors for the money and there is an element for all of us in wanting to help Abingdon become a better place. You may disagree with some or all of the things we do (we represent a whole town most of whom want slightly different things, often contradictory so are bound not to keep everyone happy) but I think we all work quite hard to try and do the things we each believe will best help the town.
In terms of why I personally put myself forward as a councillor, I can categorically say has nothing to do with money (it costs me money to be a councillor in lost income) and everything to do with being frustrated a lack of progress in creating town centre vitality. I decided to stand for office and try and influence things as a councillor rather than just moaning from the side. Most other councillors from across the parties will have similar stories.
11:56am Wed 16 May 12
Abberdon says...
1:52pm Thu 17 May 12
Abingdon Rob says...
It is a wind up about the buns being from tesco I hope. Someone told me they are baked specially by milletts farm. Who would get the club card points?
I was amused seeing the councilers arranging a night out - it made them seem more human
10:39pm Tue 22 May 12
Iain L says...
We are more or less human - honest!
To pick up your query on budget, the specific one for the jubilee isn't on website (although I think the overall council one is). If you drop tge council an email they will send you the jubilee one (they may need a day or so to turn this sort of request around). If you have any problem let me know (email details on council website) and I will get you a copy.