Murder trial’s defence team of Fiaz Munshi question police procedure

Murder trial’s defence team of Fiaz Munshi question police procedure

Murder trial’s defence team of Fiaz Munshi question police procedure

First published in News Oxford Mail: Photograph of the Author by , Education Reporter, also covering West Oxford. Call me on (01865) 425437

THE lead inspector in the murder trial of Fiaz Munshi has been questioned over the way in which the investigation leading to her arrest was carried out.

Yesterday at Oxford Crown Court Det Insp Craig Kirby was cross-examined by defence barrister Stephen Kamlish.

Munshi, 38, denies murdering eight-year-old Anum Khan and her brother Majid, 15, in an arson attack in Magdalen Road, East Oxford, on August 26, 1997.

Mr Kamlish questioned the “credibility” of prosecution witness Sunder Khutan, who finished giving evidence last week.

Mr Khutan alleged Munshi was a “puppet master” who manipulated others into carrying out the arson attack.

Mr Kamlish said: “He is in fact a hopeless witness.”

Det Insp Kirby said: “I don’t agree he is a hopeless witness.

“He is a witness with additional challenges and issues. Back in 1997 and 1998 he came forward and gave an account which has been subsequently corroborated by independent evidence. That is as important as what he says.”

Mr Kamlish put to Det Insp Kirby that a video of Mr Khutan’s police interview should have been made, to be presented to the jury, under police guidelines.

A video suite was not booked by the officers for when his interview took place.

Det Insp Kirby said: “The key was always to get the account of the evidence from the witness as early on as possible and we could not risk delaying as that was not seen as the preferred option.”

He said the police interview advice was “guidance not rules”.

Munshi, of Manley Road, in Oldham, was arrested last October after a police error meant she was not arrested until nine years after returning from Pakistan.

Five men were convicted in 1998 for the murders of the two children and Munshi’s sister Riaz Munshi was later jailed for manslaughter.

The prosecution is expected to close its case today.

Our top stories:

E-fit released in connection with Wood Farm robbery

Oxford Mail:

12:34pm Sunday 26th April 2015

A MAN was punched after being forced to hand over his phone and cash to man on Wood Farm Road, police said.

UPDATE: Mayfair Road man appears in court on Barton murder charge as alleged victim is named as Wojciech Ryniak

Oxford Mail: oxford magistrates court

11:04am Saturday 25th April 2015

A MAN has today appeared in court charged with murder after a man was found with chest injuries in Barton late on Tuesday night.

Defibrillator campaign smashes its 200 target - now let's go for 500

Oxford Mail:

9:04am Saturday 25th April 2015

ONE man’s mission to get 200 more public defibrillators across Oxfordshire has smashed its target thanks to the Oxford Mail.

Barton man appears in court charged in connection with Mayfair Road incident

Oxford Mail: oxford magistrates court

1:56pm Saturday 25th April 2015

A MAN has today appeared in court charged with conspiracy to commit robbery and possession of a stun gun after an incident in Mayfair Road on Tuesday evening.

Oink: Warning to dog walkers as wild boar seen in Oxfordshire

Oxford Mail:

12:00pm Saturday 25th April 2015

WILD boar have been spotted in parts of Oxfordshire.

Randolph Hotel: Historically important parts largely unscathed by fire

Oxford Mail:

8:57am Saturday 25th April 2015

A CONSERVATION group has said historically important sections of The Randolph Hotel were left largely unscathed by last week’s major fire.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree