Crown Prosecution Service under fire again after court cases dropped because prosecutor does not turn up

Adrian Foster

Adrian Foster

First published in News
Last updated
Oxford Mail: Photograph of the Author by , Crime Reporter, also covering Barton and Wood Farm. Call me on (01865) 425427

TWO court cases - including one where three people were allegedly assaulted - had to be dropped after a prosecution lawyer failed to turn up.

The independent lawyer had been hired by the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) but did not appear at Oxford Magistrates’ Court last Tuesday.

As a result, a local prosecutor was sent from the CPS’s Cowley office, but arrived at 11.40am, 25 minutes after the cases – one an assault trial – had been dismissed.

Magistrates’ Association chairman Richard Monkhouse said: “Failure to attend court, be it prosecution or defence, wastes the time of magistrates and court staff when it could be better served delivering justice.”

One man was due to stand trial charged with four counts of assault in Witney against three people.

He had pleaded not guilty, but the trial had to be dropped.

It is understood his lawyers are now applying to recoup the money wasted in taking the case to court.

The second case was a man who had been charged with failing to provide a breath specimen.

District Judge Tim Pattinson told him: “For legal reasons I’m formally dismissing the case against you.

“That means, put another way, I’m formally finding you not guilty.”

The unit’s Adrian Foster, chief crown prosecutor for Thames and Chiltern Crown Prosecution Service, said he had personally apologised to the complainants and witnesses in the cases.

It comes as an inspection report published in February revealed the Thames Valley CPS unit was one of the worst in the country.

The report, based on an inspection last year, ranked it 41st out of 42 units in either not getting a guilty plea or a conviction at a trial for magistrates’ cases, and was ranked 38th in crown court cases.

Between April last year and March this year, nine per cent of the Thames and Chiltern CPS’ 15,981 half-day magistrate court sessions were taken on by external prosecutors.

Mr Foster said: “We acknowledge that due to an error, the external barrister that we had instructed did not attend court as expected on Tuesday.

“Since this incident we have put in place an additional check into the process for confirming that instructed barristers will attend their allocated court as expected.”

However, just last month the CPS' handling of cases was lambasted as shambolic by a Crown Court judge frustrated at continual delays.

Judge Francis Sheridan said: "It is a massive implosion into the taxpayers' fund.

"This is a shambles at the moment.

"Somebody has got to seize this. Somebody must take control of the CPS in this courtroom."

Mr Foster said in the past 12 months 0.07 per cent of prosecutions at Oxford Magistrates’ Court failed due to the CPS not being ready to proceed.

He added: “Although this figure is small, any amount of discontinued cases for CPS reasons are disappointing.

“I can assure the public that in all such cases lessons are learned.

“We are disappointed that these cases have been brought to an end in this way and I have personally written to the victims and witnesses to offer an explanation and an apology.”

The local Crown Prosecution Service has also admitted recently it bungled when it twice made untrue allegations against the Oxford Mail over the Ahmed Bullfinch sexual abuse case.

  • Our top stories

300 sign petition over parking fees at Oxfordshire's community hospitals

Oxford Mail:

6:00am Thursday 28th August 2014

MORE than 300 people have signed a petition opposing any moves to introduce parking charges at community hospitals.

Connor Tremble trial: Judge reminds jury of stabbing evidence

Oxford Mail:

2:50pm Wednesday 27th August 2014

JURORS in the Connor Tremble murder trial have this morning been reminded of the evidence before they go out to consider a verdict.

Garden centre targeted by burglars for third time this month

Oxford Mail: Thames Valley Police logo

12:16pm Wednesday 27th August 2014

THIEVES attempted to steal a safe and made off with an undisclosed amount of cash after breaking into Millets Farm Centre near Abingdon.

It's heartbreak for Oxford United, but Appleton so proud of team + VIDEO

Oxford Mail:

9:30am Wednesday 27th August 2014

MICHAEL Appleton was hugely proud by the way Oxford United stood up to West Bromwich Albion as a dramatic night saw the underdogs knocked out after a penalty shoot-out.

Six officers face investigation in Jayden Parkinson inquiry

Oxford Mail:

9:30am Wednesday 27th August 2014

SIX police officers are now under investigation over how the disappearance of murdered teen Jayden Parkinson was handled.

Covered Market robbery 'was to protect family'

Oxford Mail:

9:00am Wednesday 27th August 2014

CLINT TOWNSEND tried to rob a jeweller’s in Oxford’s Covered Market because he was being threatened by “loan sharks”, his sister has claimed.

Comments (4)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

12:22pm Mon 9 Jun 14

Lord Palmerstone says...

CPS staff are far too busy with child care ishoos and many of them are fragile or in meetings , or indeed morbidly obese or trying to thwart their colleague's promotion ambition to be wasting their time on all this court nonsense.
CPS staff are far too busy with child care ishoos and many of them are fragile or in meetings , or indeed morbidly obese or trying to thwart their colleague's promotion ambition to be wasting their time on all this court nonsense. Lord Palmerstone
  • Score: -4

8:57pm Mon 9 Jun 14

consumer52 says...

barrister ? in a magistrates court ?
barrister ? in a magistrates court ? consumer52
  • Score: 1

9:04pm Mon 9 Jun 14

Interestedinoxford says...

Oh dear..mentioning the Oxford Mail bit just looks like it's you're out to get the CPS.
Oh dear..mentioning the Oxford Mail bit just looks like it's you're out to get the CPS. Interestedinoxford
  • Score: 1

12:14pm Tue 10 Jun 14

Interestedinoxford says...

I think my previous comment is backed up by the most ridiculous poll I have ever seen which you are running......this is a joke !

Read this and laugh !.....


After dropping two court cases because of a bungle, on the heels of other failings, is our local Crown Prosecution Service fit for purpose?

No - there's too many mistakes happening
Yes - but it must stop these mistakes
I think my previous comment is backed up by the most ridiculous poll I have ever seen which you are running......this is a joke ! Read this and laugh !..... After dropping two court cases because of a bungle, on the heels of other failings, is our local Crown Prosecution Service fit for purpose? No - there's too many mistakes happening Yes - but it must stop these mistakes Interestedinoxford
  • Score: 1

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree