Rape case jury must consider nature of sex

.

.

First published in News

SUBMISSION by a woman does not mean consent, a jury was told in the case of a Headington man accused of eight counts of rape and five of causing actual bodily harm.

Judge Gordon Risius was directing the jury while summing up at Oxford Crown Court in the case of Lewyn Rudge.

The court heard how the 26-year-old, of Valentia Road, allegedly forced one of the girls to give him oral sex as well as “beating up” and raping the other one on her birthday.

The alleged offences took place between August 2008 and January last year, the jury was told.

On one occasion Rudge is alleged to have punched one of the girls in the nose and forced her to give him oral sex. When she attempted to go to hospital it is alleged that he caught up with her, grabbed her by the hair and pulled her home.

Judge Risius said: “Submission by a woman to something she doesn’t want to happen does not amount to consent.

“There have been references to alcohol in this case and you might be wondering whether it would make any difference to your decision if Mr Rudge was under the influence of alcohol. The answer is that you should certainly take into account any influence of alcohol.”

Rudge said he had consensual sex with both girls and the allegations have been brought forward to “get back” at him.

He denies the charges in relation to the two women.

Judge Risius will conclude his summing up today at which point the jury will retire to consider its verdict.

Top News
• Our top stories:

Randolph Hotel: Hundreds of witnesses watch as iconic venue burns

Oxford Mail:

6:00am Saturday 18th April 2015

WITNESSES of the fire that gripped the Randolph Hotel for hours yesterday described the moment they watched one of Oxford’s historic landmarks go up in flames.

Randolph Hotel: We won't let the fire destroy our wedding today

Oxford Mail:

6:00am Saturday 18th April 2015

WEDDING parties, transatlantic tourists and couples celebrating their anniversaries were among the guests evacuated from the five star hotel yesterday afternoon.

Randolph Hotel: Firefighters try to work out what sparked blaze

Oxford Mail:

6:00am Saturday 18th April 2015

FIRE crews are trying to establish exactly what caused the huge blaze at Oxford’s Randolph Hotel yesterday.

Sewage flows down the street as drains back up

Oxford Mail:

2:00pm Saturday 18th April 2015

SEWAGE overflowing at a block of flats in Barton has sparked anger from residents.

Reward to find cancer victim's missing dog

Oxford Mail:

12:58pm Saturday 18th April 2015

A CANCER sufferer has offered a “substantial financial reward” for anyone who can find her missing dog.

And they're off! More than 100 classic cars leave the Mini plant in Cowley for Longbridge Rally

Oxford Mail:

11:09am Saturday 18th April 2015

A CONVOY of more than 100 Minis, Morris Minors and other classic cars left the BMW plant in Cowley this morning to parade through Oxford.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree