This summer’s debate has exposed tensions between two key claims

Pupils sit their GCSE exams

Pupils sit their GCSE exams

First published in Letters

Writing as an early-taking, resit-improved student of English language O-Level, I sympathise with certain schools’ reluctance to publish anything other than final grades achieved by young people who may have had two or more bites at the maths and English cherries in their GCSE exams.

Two key points may be borne in mind: exam results ‘belong to’ the young person who has earned them and, consequently, they should stand as a mark of that person’s final achievement in any particular subject; and schools need a common system of comparison if meaningful conclusions are to be drawn about which are the ‘better’ schools, and which ‘worse’. This summer’s debate exposes the tensions between these two claims.

With school or training now continuing until 18, and with an expectation that maths and English should continue supported through these years for students yet to reach their full potential, then the notion of continuing improvement is built in, and any artificial horizon at 16 is just that – an arbitrary staging post erected outwith the individual interests of each of the young people concerned.

In healthcare, if drinking plenty of barley water fails, then a course of antibiotics might be prescribed; in law, if a case seems to have been decided contrarily, then an appeal may be launched.

In each case, the profession operates in a framework allowing repeat and improving interventions, to the benefit of the patient or appellant.

If schools don’t like their common system or framework, let them negotiate a better one. Doctors and lawyers appear less buffeted than headteachers.

James Dasaolu might never run as fast as Usain Bolt, but we don’t want to discourage him from trying. We keep a common system of comparison (a good watch and 100m), and let them go again and again.

Peter Martin, Church Close, Bampton

  • Do you want alerts delivered straight to your phone via our WhatsApp service? Text NEWS or SPORT or NEWS AND SPORT, depending on which services you want, and your full name to 07767 417704. Save our number into your phone's contacts as Oxford Mail WhatsApp and ensure you have WhatsApp installed.

Send your Letter to the Editor

11:20am Monday 28th July 2014

What do you think? We welcome letters from our readers on a wide variety of subjects and you can send us a letter through the blue headline above.

Today’s letters

I think police were going through the motions

Oxford Mail: Nurse got me through some difficult times

11:00am Tuesday 16th September 2014

I am writing concerning Andrew Castle’s letter (September 11) and his drawing attention to the fact that all the public toilets in one area were under renovation at the same time.

A few spoilt the music at Oxford Open Doors

Oxford Mail:

11:00am Tuesday 16th September 2014

Well done to the organisers and those who took part in the Oxford Open Doors over the weekend. It really was an excellent way to find out more about our city and its history and the interesting places that we are not usually able to visit.

Blackwood focusing on the wrong target here

Oxford Mail: Nurse got me through some difficult times

11:00am Tuesday 16th September 2014

I note with some exasperation that the Tory MP for Oxford West and Abingdon has started a campaign to get customers to praise the local shops on the West Way site in Botley.

Politicians lack empathy with the working class

Oxford Mail:

11:00am Tuesday 16th September 2014

In my personal view Sir Tony Baldry has had many achievements as he has been my local MP for Banbury since 1983. But I have a few issues such as the Horton.

A comprehensive strategy needs to be in place to meet challenges

Oxford Mail:

11:00am Tuesday 16th September 2014

The award of £35m to address congestion on the A40 between Witney and Oxford is very welcome. Bus lanes or a separate guided busway have been proposed; these would help to get buses to the Wolvercote roundabout faster, but not at all to address the current traffic queues from that roundabout into the city centre.



Post a comment

Remember you are personally responsible for what you post on this site and must abide by our site terms. Do not post anything that is false, abusive or malicious. If you wish to complain, please use the ‘report this post’ link.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree