Be canny when choosing your charity giving

Renee Watson

Renee Watson

First published in Columns Oxford Mail: Photograph of the Author by , (It's Not) Rocket Science

It seems 2014 may well go down in history as the year when Chinese Water Torture went viral in the form of a bucket of ice-cold water over the head.

And all in the name of science! Whether or not you have been doused yourself you have undoubtedly heard about the Ice Bucket Challenge, in which participants are sponsored to tip freezing water over themselves and post the reults online.

If like me, you had never heard of Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis, ALS for short, fear not. You are not ill-informed, it is the just the American name for Motor Neurone Disease.

The Ice Bucket Challenge has raised in the region of £60m from more than 1.7 million donors in less than one month for – the charity that launched the challenge. Not bad for an organisation that raised £1.6million during the same time last year.

As the challenge seems to be reaching its peak more and more people are beginning to express an unwillingness to take the plunge (those who have done it nominate others to take part).

It has highlighted a very interesting science question: research costs a lot of money, but how do we decide, both as individuals and as societies, how we allocate money to the hundreds of good causes that need our help?

People will have a whole host of personal motives for donating to one research charity over another but if you are struggling to decide whether to make a donation or not these are some of the things I like to consider:

1: How much money does the charity spend on administration? We need to be realistic – running a charity costs money – however you don’t want to be giving your hard-earned cash to a charity that spends huge chunks of their income on posh cars. I like to check out their last accounts and see what percentage they spend on admin – 20 per cent and under is a sign that they are putting the vast majority of their income where you want it; into finding new treatments for disease.

If they don’t clearly state their admin spend I would be a little suspicious.

2: How many middle-men stand between my donation and the people who I want it to reach? Each time money is passed through a different organisation, a little bit is going to be taken off to pay for that service. Local charities tend to be good at being a direct route from your pocket to the recipient without chunks being syphoned off.

3: Could my time be more valuable than my money? Having worked with many charities the answer to this is often no – but when it comes to research, volunteering to take part in a clinical trial could be a more valuable contribution to finding effective new treatments than a few pounds in a bucket.

There has been a lot of talk about amounts of money raised versus number of people affected by the disease. I don’t think this matters.

It is interesting to compare how much money is invested in research on different diseases. But think about the vast amounts of money slushing around the wealthiest parts of our world and I don’t think we can begrudge a less common disease having a brilliant awareness and fundraising campaign. After all if I, or someone I loved got Motor Neurone Disease I would be very grateful for every single piece of ice thrown.

  • Do you want alerts delivered straight to your phone via our WhatsApp service? Text NEWS or SPORT or NEWS AND SPORT, depending on which services you want, and your full name to 07767 417704. Save our number into your phone’s contacts as Oxford Mail WhatsApp and ensure you have WhatsApp installed.

Travel: Finding the hidden charms of Brittany with Siblu

Oxford Mail:

8:20pm Monday 26th January 2015

Jason Collie finds an unexpected idyllic spot in Brittany

I'd rather keep my eyes on life's road than look inwards

Oxford Mail: Rebecca Moore

11:00am Saturday 24th January 2015

Rebecca Moore on why she's not keen to discover herself any time soon

'I believe that climate change is happening'

Oxford Mail: Climate change could have a huge environmental impact

11:00am Saturday 24th January 2015

Rebecca Moore on why we should all care about climate change

Would-be Valentines to get help finding lurve

Oxford Mail: Happy Couple Enjoying the Party (16530860)

11:00am Saturday 24th January 2015

Jaine Blackman gets some top tips on attraction as an Oxford bar prepares to call in an expert on Flirtology to give singleton customers a lesson in chat-up lines

Triumphant Oxford return for student turned author Samantha Shannon

Oxford Mail: Samantha Shannon

11:00am Saturday 24th January 2015

Jaine Blackman meets best-selling author Samantha Shannon who is heading back to Oxford where she wrote and set her first novel about a dystopian future

Why worms are a friend of the gardener

Oxford Mail: Sheena Patterson

11:00am Saturday 24th January 2015

My new best friend in the garden is a cheerful little robin who has continued throughout this gloomy month to make me feel loved.

Poppy Royal proves laptops give hope for a better future

Oxford Mail: Long Hanborough 13.01.2015 11:00 Poppy Royal (07783768403), who is raising money to send laptops to young women in Sri Lanka, poses at her house.PictureSales Ref: OX72126Catchline: Laptops For Ladies Poppy RoyalLength: spread Weekend LifePhotographer: Jul

11:00am Saturday 24th January 2015

After tracking down her birth family in Sri Lanka, Poppy Royal aims to help women fight poverty. Jaine Blackman reports

Caring about the sharing of cars and sofas

Oxford Mail: Photograph of the Author

11:00am Saturday 24th January 2015

How about lending your car to a complete stranger, or allowing someone you’ve never met before crash on your sofa while you sleep a few feet away?

Ellie Bedford has a fresh look at the family's diet

Oxford Mail: PictureSales Ref: OX72192 Ellie Bedford who has written a raw vegan recipe book for children.Catchline: Ellie BedfordLength: Spread Weekend LifeContact: Ellie 01869 233134 or 07855458550Requested by: Jaine Blackman Picture by Richard Cave 16.01.15 (163567

11:00am Saturday 24th January 2015

Jaine Blackman talks to archaeologist turned nutritionist and author Ellie Bedford who wants to spread the message of the benefits of fresh food

I'm full of awe for height of achievement

Oxford Mail: Katherine Rees

11:00am Saturday 24th January 2015

As an eternal optimist and positive thinker, I never fail to be impressed by feats of human endeavour.

A head for heights on the roof of Europe

Oxford Mail: Freeride: In action above Europe's highest ski resort

11:00am Saturday 24th January 2015

Tim Hughes enjoys some skiing, along with a luxurious visit to Val Thorens in the French Alps

Get yourself ready for the revolution

11:00am Saturday 24th January 2015

Let's face it: the topic of economics is something that’s as mysterious as the moon to most of us.

Be healthier and slim for the long term

Oxford Mail: Photograph of the Author

11:00am Saturday 24th January 2015

At this time of year lots of people are going on a new diet and trying a new fitness regime. There are so many to choose from, how do you know which one works and which are short term fixes?


Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree