News RSS Feed


Why do so many city stores stay illuminated even when closed?


TODAY, the Oxford Mail is asking whether businesses need to leave their lights on when nobody is working.

A survey we carried out found almost half of businesses in a city centre street were leaving their shops on throughout the night.

Critics say leaving lights on wastes energy and money, and places an unnecessary burden on the environment.

But some shops in the survey claimed it was prudent to leave lights on for security and advertising purposes.

Our investigation was sparked by reader Maureen Pitson, 60, from Wolvercote, who drew our attention to lights which had been left on day and night at Borders in Magdalen Street.

The vacant store has been illuminated 24 hours a day since the bookstore chain ceased trading on December 22 after being plunged into administration.

Ms Pitson described the lights being left on as a “shocking waste”.

And climate change campaigner Chris Goodall has estimated the shop could be pumping out as much as a tonne of carbon dioxide a week.

It takes one tree 100 years to absorb that amount of CO2.

Ms Pitson said: “It really annoys me every time I walk past.

“I don’t know who pays for the lights being on, but somebody must be paying and it is just a complete waste of energy.

“I can understand for security you might need a few lights on, but this is something else.”

An Oxford Mail survey of shops carried out at 9.45pm on a week night in Cornmarket Street found 18 of the street’s 43 shops left either their main store lights on, display lights to advertise their products, or kept lights on for security purposes.

Gap, Moss Bros, and the 3 Phone store were among those who said they left energy efficient lights on for advertising.

Gennaro Castaldo, a spokesman for HMV which turned all its lights off, said: “Advertising and promotion is important, but the public at large value businesses managing their costs and reducing their impact on the environment more.”

Lois Muddiman, spokesman for Low Carbon West Oxford, said she had spoken to stores about leaving their lights on at night.

She said: “We can’t see any justification for leaving all the lights on overnight in a shop.”

Mr Goodall, who is the Green Party candidate for Oxford West and Abingdon and has written books on cutting carbon emissions, said: “You can see why you might not want to have no lights because it might encourage entry.

“But Borders could be boarded up and the lights turned off.”

Richard Merrin, a spokesman for administrators MCR, said it had handed the shop’s keys over to the lettings agent for the landlord, DTZ, on January 12.

However Andrew King, associate director of DTZ, said his firm did not have the keys and sole responsibility for the shop rested with the administrator.

Neither Mr King or Mr Merrin could provide an explanation as to why the lights had been left on.

l What shops and businesses have you seen lit up at night? And what do you think about the issue? Call 01865 425500 or leave a comment at oxfordmail.co.uk


Comments(13)

Pierre My says...
10:51am Mon 15 Mar 10

Ms Pitson described the lights being left on as a “shocking waste”. .....




What has it got to do with you how anybody spends their money. All of the lights left on contribute £millions to the ecomony all over the country every year in utility bills. Best you get back to your knittting love, and leave business to the businessmen (and ladies). P.S. Driving past the White and Red during the early hours I have noticed illumination coming from both, maybe you should start closer to home.

Sid Hunt says...
11:58am Mon 15 Mar 10

Perhaps the lights are left on so companies aren't sued by burglars having accidents whilst 'working' in unsafe conditions.

Pierre My says...
12:07pm Mon 15 Mar 10

Sid Hunt wrote:
Perhaps the lights are left on so companies aren't sued by burglars having accidents whilst 'working' in unsafe conditions.
That is why the multi-storey car park lights are left on all night. Much cheaper than law suit.

Andrew:Oxford says...
12:28pm Mon 15 Mar 10

Imagine walking through the centre of Oxford at night if many of the commercial businesses *didn't* offer consumers the benefit of courtesy lighting. It is quite comforting having a bit of general lighting when you're waiting for a bus on a dark night.

Floflo says...
12:55pm Mon 15 Mar 10

Pierre My wrote:
Ms Pitson described the lights being left on as a “shocking waste”. .....




What has it got to do with you how anybody spends their money. All of the lights left on contribute £millions to the ecomony all over the country every year in utility bills. Best you get back to your knittting love, and leave business to the businessmen (and ladies). P.S. Driving past the White and Red during the early hours I have noticed illumination coming from both, maybe you should start closer to home.
Your argument applies to any economic activity. For instance cancer, and its treatment, contributes millions to the economy every year but this does not make it desirable.
.
Best you stick with your ranting on the internet love and leave decisions to other people.

Pierre My says...
1:47pm Mon 15 Mar 10

Floflo wrote:
Pierre My wrote: Ms Pitson described the lights being left on as a “shocking waste”. ..... What has it got to do with you how anybody spends their money. All of the lights left on contribute £millions to the ecomony all over the country every year in utility bills. Best you get back to your knittting love, and leave business to the businessmen (and ladies). P.S. Driving past the White and Red during the early hours I have noticed illumination coming from both, maybe you should start closer to home.
Your argument applies to any economic activity. For instance cancer, and its treatment, contributes millions to the economy every year but this does not make it desirable. . Best you stick with your ranting on the internet love and leave decisions to other people.
AHH little Floey love. Pray tell how a comment on street lighting leads to cancer in one easy move. My argument is not about any economic activity, but about what right some old biddy has to tell others how they spend their money. It is a bit early you know, the sun is not even over the yard arm yet.

Floflo says...
5:07pm Mon 15 Mar 10

@ Pierre - read my post again and you may understand it better. To help you understand I'll rephrase - leaving lights on may 'contribute £millions to the ecomony' - but this is not necessary a good thing, as my example should have illustrated to you.
.
And if 'contribute £millions to the ecomony' has nothing to do with your argument why mention it?

angelox99 says...
5:35pm Mon 15 Mar 10

Ok,Ok!!. This is not a bitchfest. Although my personal agreement goes on Pierre's comment. I think their are more pressing issues in this climate today than ''which shops leave their lights on at night''. Lets hope that a new vendor for the Ex-Borders shop is found soon to employ not only those who lost their jobs at Borders but also more besides. I would suggest that it is nothing more than an old dear as usual with to much time on her hands. Maybe she should climb to the top of Didcot power station and protest there instead of boring everyone with such dire opinions.. rock on OAP eco warriors!! lol

diz says...
8:04pm Mon 15 Mar 10

my o my i covered this weeks ago on the oxford flickr group. Why are you lot so late with the news. You need better reporters who are out there.

Pierre My says...
1:08am Tue 16 Mar 10

Floflo wrote:
@ Pierre - read my post again and you may understand it better. To help you understand I'll rephrase - leaving lights on may 'contribute £millions to the ecomony' - but this is not necessary a good thing, as my example should have illustrated to you. . And if 'contribute £millions to the ecomony' has nothing to do with your argument why mention it?
Sorry Floey luv. I should have elaborated, I only mentioned the money thing to counteract the old biddys argument that by leaving the lights on they are destroying the Earth. And I don't understand your point about cancer, are you saying that all sufferers should die so that money can be saved. Cancer is a fact of life, and if it contributes to the economy (although sad for the inflicted) it must be beneficial for some. As my local pastor says, "god works in strange ways"

HarryBo says...
10:40am Wed 17 Mar 10

1) Mr Goodall, Green Party candidate for Oxford West: "Borders could be boarded up and the lights turned off.” And give everyone the opportunity to moan about a shopfront that size covered in boards? That'd be nice. I'm pretty sure the landlords and administrators would rather find new tenants for the property as soon as possible, as the site is costing them money at the moment. Speaking of which:
.
2) I'd imagine that leaving the lights on and windows un-boarded deters squatters and vandals somewhat. Leaving the store lit will allow passers-by to see any unusual activity in the store (at least on the ground floor).
.
3) "Climate change campaigner Chris Goodall has estimated the shop could be pumping out as much as a tonne of carbon dioxide a week." Comparison please? How much did the store produce when it was operating? How much does the average house produce? Is there any evidence for Mr Goodall's calculation? The words "could" and "as much as" are vague at best. If you want to report the figures, please calculate them first.
.
4) And yes, as long as the electricity bill's being paid they can technically burn as much energy as they want. As can I. As can you. It's not necessarily right, but that's the way it is. Perhaps the organisations named in the article could petition the utility company to turn off the site's electricity? But then perhaps the utility company would refuse as they have no reason to do so, as long as the bills are paid.
.
5) The only "shame" about this whole scenario (imho) is that we've lost a great store, the people working there lost their jobs, and there's now a huge unit in central Oxford sitting empty.

Pierre My says...
2:12pm Wed 17 Mar 10

HarryBo wrote:
1) Mr Goodall, Green Party candidate for Oxford West: "Borders could be boarded up and the lights turned off.” And give everyone the opportunity to moan about a shopfront that size covered in boards? That'd be nice. I'm pretty sure the landlords and administrators would rather find new tenants for the property as soon as possible, as the site is costing them money at the moment. Speaking of which: . 2) I'd imagine that leaving the lights on and windows un-boarded deters squatters and vandals somewhat. Leaving the store lit will allow passers-by to see any unusual activity in the store (at least on the ground floor). . 3) "Climate change campaigner Chris Goodall has estimated the shop could be pumping out as much as a tonne of carbon dioxide a week." Comparison please? How much did the store produce when it was operating? How much does the average house produce? Is there any evidence for Mr Goodall's calculation? The words "could" and "as much as" are vague at best. If you want to report the figures, please calculate them first. . 4) And yes, as long as the electricity bill's being paid they can technically burn as much energy as they want. As can I. As can you. It's not necessarily right, but that's the way it is. Perhaps the organisations named in the article could petition the utility company to turn off the site's electricity? But then perhaps the utility company would refuse as they have no reason to do so, as long as the bills are paid. . 5) The only "shame" about this whole scenario (imho) is that we've lost a great store, the people working there lost their jobs, and there's now a huge unit in central Oxford sitting empty.
hear-hear

Jewson Smithee says...
9:28am Thu 18 Mar 10

I suspect many of the lights are left on because the shop keepers are worried about burglars. I used to always leave my lights on which is not very cheap, (especially as over 90 of the light fittings don't take modern echo bulbs), to try and give the feeling that there was at least a couple of the staff on the premises, but even so it could be believable that they were in one wing or another. There is though a very simple solution: timers. You can set the lights to come on and go off with nobody in the building. But people looking in from the outside don't know this. Sadly it's not stopped the staff stealing trinkets to sell on this internet eBay thing.


Maureen Pitson outside Borders in Cornmarket Street, Oxford. The lights are still on despite the fact it closed in December Maureen Pitson outside Borders in Cornmarket Street, Oxford. The lights are still on despite the fact it closed in December

Most popular


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses