News RSS Feed


'Time to get rid of the monarchy' says Oxford councillor


THE former Lord Mayor of Oxford and an academic will today call for the abolition of the monarchy.

Despite Oxford’s royal connections, notably as Charles the First's capital during the Civil War, republicans will use the occasion of the 360th anniversary of his execution to call for the end of Britain having a hereditary head of state.

Anti-monarchist and Labour councillor for Littlemore, John Tanner, a former Lord Mayor, said: “I happen to think we have a very good Queen, who is a very nice lady and very committed to the country.

However, if she wasn’t, we’d still be stuck with her.

“I just think a monarchy is an outdated, undemocratic way of running the country.

“We need a more grown up system of Government.”

Although many believe Queen Elizabeth has no power, she is permitted to ask the leader of one of the parties to try to form a government if one party has no majority in the House of Commons.

In the 2007/08 financial year, the Royal Family’s official accounts showed they cost the taxpayer £40m a year – the equivalent of 66p per person in the UK.

Royalists argue the Queen attracts many millions of pounds more in tourism, as well as surrendering millions in revenue from the Crown Estates in exchange for Civil List payments.

However, Mr Tanner believes the taxpayer could save about 90 per cent of the cost of the Civil List if Britain had an elected president.

“As taxpayers we subsidise the monarchy a lot and all the extended family and hangers-on. That money, in my view, ought to be spent on important things like education and tackling poverty instead of being spent on big palaces and chauffer driven cars.

“The economy is in a mess, we need every penny and I think to waste it on the paraphernalia of the monarchy isn’t very sensible.”

The rally, to be held outside Carfax tower at 6pm, will also see Merton College professor of literature David Norbrook, city councillor David Will-iams and trade union activist Bill McKeith speak.

Mr McKeith, a member of the Oxford and District Trades Union Council, said: “Freedom from an unelected monarch is one of the greatest civil liberties we could want.”

cwalker@oxfordmail.co.uk


Your Say YourOxford

beetle & wedge, Chippy says...
7:29am Tue 17 Mar 09

So right, we need another greasey politician as Head of State with zillions of our tax pounds spent on their election. How about President Mugabe, he's done a cracking job in a country that once groaned under the yolk of our Queen? Or, equally President Amin, unless someone he ate has disagreed with him and he's dead. The list is endless.
I love the idea of the head of one of the worst councils in England telling us about good governance. Motes and beams, Bob Tanner, comes to mind.

Voter Rick, Oxford says...
7:49am Tue 17 Mar 09

We already have an unelected PM his name is Gordon Brown. Nobody voted for him and he is costing us an absolute fortune.Quite unlike HM who has open books and full accountability to parliament in annual audit of the Crown Estate.I know which one I trust more with running the country cheaply and efficiently and is not the bent-moral compass New Labour one. Come to think of it, if we abolished several layers of councils,local authorities,regional authorities etc (all currently approved by Gordon) we could save millions and have closer democracy. As taxpayers we subsidise gold-plated pensions of council and city hall staff at much greater cost than supporting a stable monarchy. If you checked the Civil List Mr Tanner, you would also find the country makes a massive profit on it, as the Queen yields a vast amount of income in return for a Civil List allowance. The bulk of the cash goes to the Exchequer which wastes wastes wastes.Save money closer to home : sack spendthrift councillors!

Zimmer, Oxon says...
7:52am Tue 17 Mar 09

Or do we want a dictatorship led by Broon or would you have Cherie Blair as Head of State Mr Tanner both of whom would hide the true cost of their excesses.
If the City Council cost the rate payers of Oxford 66p per head (or the equivelant) I suspect many would be highly delighted.

olfar, didcot says...
8:02am Tue 17 Mar 09

More zanulabour moral compost.

LadyPenelope, Oxford says...
12:52pm Tue 17 Mar 09

For 66p/person a year, we may as well keep her!

LadyPenelope, Oxford says...
12:52pm Tue 17 Mar 09

For 66p/person a year, we may as well keep her!

tanchris, oxford says...
1:13pm Tue 17 Mar 09

Tanner is, and always has been, a real live waste of space.off with his head!

Quentin Walker, Oxford says...
2:26pm Tue 17 Mar 09

It was OK for Mr Tanner to don a set of antiquated robes and silly hat to be chauffeur-driven around the City playing the 'big I am', but he doesn't see any value in others doing it.

That's socialism for you.

philg, Oxford says...
2:43pm Tue 17 Mar 09

I find it very very hard to believe that a president would cost us less than 66p each.

And we'd have to pay English Heritage or some such to keep Windsor and Buck House up to scratch.

But John Tanner will get his wish when the Lisbon treaty is fully enacted: there will be a European President (unelected) who will have a whole lot more power than our Liz.

Zimmer, Oxon says...
2:52pm Tue 17 Mar 09

Quentin Walker wrote:
It was OK for Mr Tanner to don a set of antiquated robes and silly hat to be chauffeur-driven around the City playing the 'big I am', but he doesn't see any value in others doing it. That's socialism for you.
Think that it may be Communism not socialism!

ex so'ton, Abingdon says...
9:33pm Tue 17 Mar 09

Communism and Socialism are one of the same, Tanner is about as bright as a damp sparkler, with not one good idea in his head! He is the kind of idiot who would say that the old East Germany(DDR) was a workers' paradise, yeah, right, he should have lived there, he would not have dared to speak out, you see, free speach was 'verboten' and he would have been reporte to the Stasi and punished. Wonderful idea, I wish it could happen here! I am absolutely sure that he does not believe in anything he says, why should the populace? Talk about speaking as his belly guides him!

lil-lynz, Kidlington says...
12:17pm Mon 23 Mar 09

Voter Rick wrote:
We already have an unelected PM his name is Gordon Brown. Nobody voted for him and he is costing us an absolute fortune.Quite unlike HM who has open books and full accountability to parliament in annual audit of the Crown Estate.I know which one I trust more with running the country cheaply and efficiently and is not the bent-moral compass New Labour one. Come to think of it, if we abolished several layers of councils,local authorities,regional authorities etc (all currently approved by Gordon) we could save millions and have closer democracy. As taxpayers we subsidise gold-plated pensions of council and city hall staff at much greater cost than supporting a stable monarchy. If you checked the Civil List Mr Tanner, you would also find the country makes a massive profit on it, as the Queen yields a vast amount of income in return for a Civil List allowance. The bulk of the cash goes to the Exchequer which wastes wastes wastes.Save money closer to home : sack spendthrift councillors!
why dont we domolish 10 downing street with the complete labour party in it!

Comments are closed on this article.

John Tanner John Tanner

Debt Help from My Financial Solutions | Stay with Prague Hotels | Visit Spain with Barcelona Hotels | 70% off Designer Glasses at Posh Eyes

Local Advertisers

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »