News RSS Feed


Tree felling angers dog walker

5:49pm Monday 30th June 2008

comment Comments (8)   Have your say »


A dozen mature trees have been felled in an Oxford park and will be used as seating for an outdoor theatre production.

The city council says the chestnut, ash and other specimens in Headington Hill Park have been chopped down for safety reasons.

The Creation Theatre company, which starts its two-month run of Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream in the park on Friday, will use the trees as benches for audience members.

Glynis Robinson, who regularly walks her dog in the park, said the trees did not look diseased or rotten.

Ms Robinson, from St Mary's Road, East Oxford, said: "I have never seen such wholesale destruction in that park.

"I thought that park was safe, but it is so shocking to see 12 lovely, healthy, mature trees lying in pieces.

"You can tell from a tree trunk if it is diseased and these ones looked in perfectly healthy condition. A tree is home to 4,000 species, like insects, bugs and caterpillars. Those have been lost."

A council spokesman said: "Some trees in Headington Hill Park are being cut down as part of our tree management programme.

"This programme, which started last year, involves surveying 32,000 trees over three years and creating a database of tree stock to highlight any arboricultural work required.

"The dangers of falling trees are well publicised and the council's first duty is to do all it can to protect Oxford's citizens."

City councillor Bob Timbs, board member for leisure and sport, said: "I know that all relevant tests, both sonic and probing, have been used to confirm that the trees have been identified to be felled for safety reasons.

"New semi-matured trees will be planted to replace the fallen, although not in the same spot, but as near as possible."

Nicola West, Creation's producer of A Midsummer Night's Dream, stressed that the trees had not been cut down for the theatre production.

She added: "The council has been doing a survey of its trees and it has been told to cut down trees in all its parks for health and safety reasons.

"We were going to provide log or bench seating for our audiences which we were going to rent or buy in, so when the council said to us they were cutting down some trees it was perfect for us."


Your Say YourOxford Mail

Paul, Oxford says...
8:24pm Mon 30 Jun 08

Typical of the jobsworths at OCC - if in doubt, cut 'em down. Can't risk the council being sued can we, that would look bad on the CV when we apply for the next job.

Why not cut *all* the trees down, then we'll all be really, really safe.

Mr Ison, England says...
8:42pm Mon 30 Jun 08

The article has a definate bias towards hokum.

Who wants to sit among diseased and spore ridden wood?

Send me a piece and i will evaluate any spalting.

Jock, Headington says...
12:13am Tue 1 Jul 08

I live right adjacent to the park and walk through it every day. Last Monday there were noticed up about felling trees that had been inspected and found to be damaged. So on Monday night I made sure to go round the park again to check out which were marked for destruction, and I have to say that all that were marked, except one in my opinion, did look as if they had had problems - either completely bare for the second year running or where you could see branches had already fallen off them recently and so on. The one that didn't look as if it had any major problems was an ash? tree right down along the fence by Clive Booth Halls of Residence.

The area by the dairy lodge entrance to the park seems to have been most hit, a couple of silver birches and an acer had stopped growing and the birches suffered in last years' storms from ripped off branches.

On Friday however I did notice that they had felled one of the chestnuts in the avenue up by Cuckoo Lane which had not, I am sure, been marked with the big red 'X'. So I don't know what happened there.

It would be nice to see the trees in that park managed/planned more actively as an arboretum. And maybe a Friends of Headington Hill Park group like some other parks in the city have would be a useful forum for that? But I've not seen anything to suggest that really healthy mature trees are being felled just to create benches for the play.

Mr Ison, England says...
1:18am Tue 1 Jul 08

Ash an honey fungus,is there a relationship?

Any strop fungus on the Birch?

Never seen a horse chestnut so diseased as to become dangerous,in the woods there are some magnificent Sweet Chestnuts,those nearest the major paths have limbs pruned sometimes.

The only time these big old trees were destroyed is when they wanted to open the area for new parking.


Mr Ison, England says...
1:25am Tue 1 Jul 08

Why did they want more parking?

So the National Trust had room for the customers at it's visitors centre.


Why did the visitors centre expect more customers?

Because it was enlargened for a food hall.

Those trees and your trees would still be standing if it were not for special interest groups changing the use of the area.

Gimmerman, Planet Earth says...
11:24am Tue 1 Jul 08

Mr Ison - you are a complete idiot and your comments that you give in almost every story on this website are juvenile and not welcome. If you are lonely go and join the library, i am sure they would love to hear your drivel. Alternatively please turn your computer off at the wall and never turn it on again

Mr Ison, England says...
11:36am Tue 1 Jul 08

Looks like Gimmermann wants to stick a road in there.

Questioner, Abingdon says...
9:15pm Tue 1 Jul 08

What have the council in Oxford got against trees? After the debâcle of the willow trees being torn down at Osney lock the council have still not learned anything by that experience. Planting saplings is useless because they get vandalised, plant anything bigger they die through neglect and lack of water, rain itself is not enough to get a young tree off to a good start, they need c .300 gallons each in the first year. Here in Abingdon they planted some six trees in Caldicot Road and they are already wilting in the dry spell that we are currently having. These will surely perish at great expense to the public purse.

Comments are closed on this article.

UK Debt Help and Advice | IVA help and advice | The truth about IVAs | Stay with Prague Hotels | Visit Spain with Barcelona Hotels

Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »