It's all in the worst possible taste - Witney Community Hospital's food condemned

Prime Minister and Witney MP David Cameron on a tour of Witney Community Hospital’s new Emergency Multidisciplinary Unit in June. The review of food took place in March

Prime Minister and Witney MP David Cameron on a tour of Witney Community Hospital’s new Emergency Multidisciplinary Unit in June. The review of food took place in March

First published in News
Last updated
Oxford Mail: Photograph of the Author by , Reporter covering Headington and Marston. Call me on (01865) 425411

FOOD quality at Witney Community Hospital has been ranked as the third worst in England.

The Oxford Health NHS Foundation Trust hospital in Prime Minister David Cameron’s constituency achieved a food quality rating of 49.43 per cent after inspectors visited in March.

As a result, the Welch Way site ranked 1,256th out of 1,258 NHS hospital sites, according to the Department of Health which published the findings to ramp up standards of hospital food.

Oxford Health said it improved the quality of food after the learning of the findings, which it called “disappointing”.

Witney town councillors and patients were surprised by the results of the results of the study.

Valerie Williamson’s 79-year-old husband, James, spent seven weeks in Witney Community Hospital in May, after he broke his hip and wrist in a fall.

The 73-year-old former administrative worker, of Brize Norton Road, Minster Lovell, said: “I just can’t believe it because I have high standards and thought the food was very good.

“It was well-presented, hot, fresh and we were more than happy with everything.”

The score was worked out after patients and members of the public sampled every item of food on offer, rated it for taste, temperature and texture.

They also looked at how the food was served, including whether the ward was prepared for mealtimes, whether patients had the chance to wash their hands and if unnecessary activity was stopped.

Oxford Mail:

Valerie and James Williamson

Witney Community Hospital provides 60 beds, a specialist stroke unit, day care services, a minor injuries unit, an outpatient clinic, therapy services as well as X-ray services.

Witney East ward Labour Party councillor Duncan Enright urged people not jump to conclusions about its standard of care.

He said: “Like all ranking systems that the Government uses, this can be crude and poorly-designed, so I would expect this to be something that the management of the hospital will look at, not something to judge the hospital on.

“I question the value of a league table like this.”

The findings are part of an announcement from the Department of Health that hospital trusts will be legally-bound to follow new food standards.

They must identify patients at risk of becoming malnourished, have protected mealtimes, promote healthy diets and source food in a sustainable way. Patient and public feedback will be used to assess and rank the quality of food on offer before the results are made public.

Alistair Duncan, a spokesman for the trust, said: “We were pleased to learn that almost all of the sites run by Oxford Health NHS Foundation Trust were assessed as providing food of good quality to patients.

“We were, however, disappointed that assessors rated the food at Witney Community Hospital as requiring improvement.”

Mr Duncan said the trust put in place an action plan to improve food at Witney.

He added that a survey it carried out in August resulted in 85 per cent of patients rating new meals as ‘good’ or ‘excellent’.

But the trust did not respond to the Oxford Mail’s requests for information about how food was prepared or sourced at the hospital.

Healthwatch Oxfordshire chief executive Rachel Coney said she endorsed the move for mandatory food standards.

She said: “It is clearly a concern if any hospital within the county is not offering the high quality of food the patients it serves have the right to expect.”

Oxford University Hospitals NHS Trust runs Oxford’s Churchill Hospital, John Radcliffe Hospital, Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre and Banbury’s Horton Hospital.

Wendy Robinson, head of food services at the trust, said: “Currently our food policy is focused on patient nutrition and providing patients with the food they need to help them recover whilst giving them plenty of choice.”

Prime Minister and Witney MP David Cameron last night was not available for comment.

How has the food been when you’ve been in hospital? Tweet us your pictures via @The OxfordMail

HOW THEY FARED

  • 252nd: Wallingford Community Hospital (99.02%)
  • 253rd: Bicester Community Hospital (99.02% )
  • 381st: Didcot Community Hospital (97.92%)
  • 703rd: Fiennes Centre (93.75%)
  • 720th: Fulbrook Centre (93.56%)
  • 779th: Wantage Community Hospital (92.64%)
  • 930th: The Churchill Hospital (89.43%)
  • 960th: The Horton Hospital (88.79%)
  • 963rd: John Radcliffe Hospital (88.68%)
  • 1,027th: Littlemore Hospital (87.15%)
  • 1,039th: Oxford City Community Hospital (86.76%)
  • 1,045th: Manor House Hospital (86.57%)
  • 1,046th: Abingdon Community Hospital (86.49%)
  • 1,087th: Warneford Hospital (84.76%)
  • 1,146th: Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre (80.68%)
  • 1,256th: Witney Community Hospital (49.43%)
  • Do you want alerts delivered straight to your phone via our WhatsApp service? Text NEWS or SPORT or NEWS AND SPORT, depending on which services you want, and your full name to 07767 417704. Save our number into your phone’s contacts as Oxford Mail WhatsApp and ensure you have WhatsApp installed.

Send your Letter to the Editor

11:20am Monday 28th July 2014

What do you think? We welcome letters from our readers on a wide variety of subjects and you can send us a letter through the blue headline above.

Our top stories

Tributes paid to man stabbed to death by Abingdon riverbank

Oxford Mail:

9:00am Tuesday 21st October 2014

A WOMAN was last night being held in custody on suspicion of murder after a man was found fatally stabbed in Abingdon.

Robber sent to prison for part in £11,000 Park End Street attack

Oxford Mail: Oxford Crown Court

9:00am Tuesday 21st October 2014

A ROBBER who beat a man up as a distraction while his accomplice stole £11,000 from his victim’s wife has been jailed.

Let Oxford expand beyond its boundaries says housing crisis report

Oxford Mail: oxford city council logo

7:30am Tuesday 21st October 2014

OXFORD is an example of a city which should be allowed to grow beyond its boundaries, according to a national report.

Drop former English Defence League leader as speaker, Oxford Union urged

Oxford Mail: The Oxford Union

6:40am Tuesday 21st October 2014

NEARLY 200 Oxford academics, students, councillors and trade union leaders have signed an open letter calling for the Oxford Union to cancel an invitation to the former leader of the English Defence League to speak.

We've had enough of pay freezes say striking JR radiographers

Oxford Mail:

6:40am Tuesday 21st October 2014

RADIOGRAPHERS from Oxford’s John Radcliffe Hospital went on strike for four hours yesterday in protest at a pay freeze.

Lorry driver failed to brake in time to avoid fatal crash, jury told

Oxford Mail: Oxford Crown Court

6:30am Tuesday 21st October 2014

A LORRY driver had 12 seconds in which he failed to brake before fatally crashing into a broken-down car on the M40 in Oxfordshire, a jury was told.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree