Coroner rules out unlawful killing verdict in gem shop raider's death

Clint Townsend in a picture supplied by his family

Clint Townsend in a picture supplied by his family

First published in News
Last updated
Oxford Mail: Photograph of the Author by , Council Reporter, also covering Oxford city centre. Call me on 01865 425429

THE grieving family of Clint Townsend yesterday said his robbery of a city jeweller’s was “completely out of character” as a coroner ruled he had not been unlawfully killed.

Townsend suffered a heart attack when he was tackled by several people after trying to break in to John Gowing Jewellers in Oxford’s Covered Market.

Yesterday, after assistant coroner Alison Thompson recorded a verdict of death by misadventure, the 33-year-old’s family lay flowers at the spot where he had collapsed.

His sister Hailey said: “His actions were completely out of character and he will be greatly missed.”

Ms Thompson ruled Townsend died because of a combination of heart disease and being held down by members of the public.

Townsend, of Barton Road, Oxford, attempted to break in to John Gowing Jewellers with a sledgehammer at around 9.15am on March 30, 2013, but was tackled to the ground.

He died the next day at the John Radcliffe Hospital.

Speaking after the three-day inquest at Oxfordshire Coroner’s Court, Hailey, who struggled to hold back tears, said: “He was a big softie and would never hurt anybody. His death has left a massive hole in our hearts.”

She said Mr Townsend’s family was still considering the verdict. The relatives then went to the Covered Market where they laid flowers near the jewellery shop, which was closed.

Ricardo Chasebi, the owner of Ricardo’s cafe in the Covered Market and a friend of Mr Townsend’s family, said he had visited the cafe before attempting to rob the store.

He said: “When I first heard what happened I didn’t believe it. It doesn’t matter what they have done, nobody deserves to die.

“He was very polite and always very nice to me.”

Oxford Mail:

  • UNITED IN GRIEF: Above, Clint Townsend’s partner and his two sisters, including Hailey, left, at the Covered Market where they placed flowers outside John Gowing Jewellers

In summing up the case Ms Thompson said that there were many inconsistencies between what the nine witnesses had told the inquest, but said this was understandable given the length of time since the incident and the speed at which events unfolded.

One of the inconsistencies surrounded how many people were pinning Townsend to the floor and Ms Thompson said that there must have been a “core group” of three.

She rejected the fact that they acted unlawfully when they tackled the would-be robber.

Ms Thompson said: “The people involved were dealing with a crisis in the heat of the moment and they were intent, not unreasonably, on keeping Mr Townsend to the ground as they had been told the police were on their way.

“I am not satisfied that any of those men acted unreasonably and therefore unlawfully.

“In coming to my conclusion I have regard for the short period of time in which people could consider what was going on and I have in mind the significant contribution of Mr Townsend’s natural disease because I believe that had his heart not been diseased to the extent it was he would not have been over come in a matter of three or four minutes.”

On Tuesday the inquest heard how Townsend had severe undiagnosed coronary heart disease which pathologist Ashley Fegan-Earl said could have led to him dying “at any point”.

Ms Thompson commended the police officers who attended the scene, particularly PC Russell Knapman who stayed with Mr Townsend to carry out CPR until he reached the John Radcliffe.

WHAT IS DEATH BY MISADVENTURE?

Death by misadventure is similar to accidental death - in fact some coroners consider them to be the same thing.

It means that the deceased or someone else was carrying out an intended action – in this case restraining Clint Townsend so he could be arrested by the police – but this had an accidental, unintended outcome – in this example Townsend’s death.

Coroners make their verdicts on the “balance of probabilities”, which is a lower standard of proof than in criminal courts where a decision has to be “beyond reasonable doubt”.

  • Do you want alerts delivered straight to your phone via our WhatsApp service? Text NEWS or SPORT or NEWS AND SPORT, depending on which services you want, and your full name to 07767 417704. Save our number into your phone’s contacts as Oxford Mail WhatsApp and ensure you have WhatsApp installed.

Send your Letter to the Editor

11:20am Monday 28th July 2014

What do you think? We welcome letters from our readers on a wide variety of subjects and you can send us a letter through the blue headline above.

  • Our top stories

Funnyman Fry serves up a bit of self-awareness

Oxford Mail:

9:30am Friday 31st October 2014

NATIONAL treasure Stephen Fry met fans in the Bodleian Library for a “hackathon”.

‘Lonely hearts club scam cost me £631’

Oxford Mail:

8:40am Friday 31st October 2014

A MAN left with a £631 phone bill after a relationship with a woman he met on a dating website is warning others to be wary.

Urban dancers prove they can move to the groove

Oxford Mail:

8:30am Friday 31st October 2014

DANCE group Body Politic took Oxford’s Pegasus Theatre by storm as it rolled into town as part of its UK tour.

Mum of drugs death teenager in plea to MPs for law review

Oxford Mail:

8:30am Friday 31st October 2014

A MOTHER who lost her 15-year-old daughter after she took Ecstasy urged MPs to review drug laws yesterday.

£10m community cash for West Way upgrade

Oxford Mail:

8:00am Friday 31st October 2014

DEVELOPERS behind the planned Botley regeneration have revealed they will fund £10m towards community benefits if the controversial scheme goes ahead.

Height row flats' tree screening plan blasted

Oxford Mail:

7:00am Friday 31st October 2014

UNIVERSITY bosses have put forward plans to screen a student flats development by Port Meadow with trees but ruled out reducing its height.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree