'Shake-up threatens fraud investigations'

City councillor Ed Turner

City councillor Ed Turner

First published in News Oxford Mail: Photograph of the Author by , Council Reporter, also covering Oxford city centre. Call me on 01865 425429

HOUSING benefit fraud investigations could suffer when they are handed to the Government, Oxford City Council’s deputy leader has warned.

The council will lose the powers to a Government body from February under national reforms.

Ed Turner, the Labour-run council’s deputy leader, said the move to a “Single Fraud Investigation Service” was “nonsense”.

He said: “The Government has said it is going to take over detecting all fraud and we remain to be convinced whether it will be able to do that.

“It has told us it is taking away the money to fund this and if the Government has the same success taking over this service as it had with the reforming of benefits then it is not going to go very well.”

He added: “It is very likely that we as a council will retain some general fraud capacity.

“There are other areas which are vulnerable to fraud such as council tax and business rates that we wouldn’t trust the Government to root out.

“We won’t go down the road of saying that the Government is looking after this so it will be all right.”

The council is reviewing “resourcing requirements” but Holywell councillor David Thomas said he feared it would hit other benefit investigations. The Green Party member said: “I think they do a brilliant job and I would like to see the team maintained.

“My concern will be that the council will not be able to recover the same amount of cash from fraud as it has done in the past.”

Suzy Drohan, joint manager of Oxfordshire Welfare Rights, which gives benefits advice, said she was also concerned.

She said: “When you deal with a Government agency it is normally through a call centre and it just ends up with a lot of frustration.

“You will probably lose that personal touch and local knowledge.

“It might look like it cuts costs but it could cost more in the end because it means more work and the investigations might not be as thorough.

“Not all benefit investigations lead to fraud charges or money being paid back.”

Council spokesman Louisa Dean said: “The council continues to be committed to eliminating all forms of bribery, fraud, corruption and to protecting public funds.”

The Department for Work and Pensions did not comment.

Its benefit reforms include the introduction of universal credit, a single payment to replace six means-tested benefits and tax credits.

It was meant to be piloted in October 2013 ahead of a national roll-out by 2017.

But so far only one of the four pilots has gone ahead following IT system failures.

  • Do you want alerts delivered straight to your phone via our WhatsApp service? Text NEWS or SPORT or NEWS AND SPORT, depending on which services you want, and your full name to 07767 417704. Save our number into your phone's contacts as Oxford Mail WhatsApp and ensure you have WhatsApp installed.

Send your Letter to the Editor

11:20am Monday 28th July 2014

What do you think? We welcome letters from our readers on a wide variety of subjects and you can send us a letter through the blue headline above.


Our top stories

FOOTBALL Rising star Roberts eager for Oxford United first-team action as Morris returns to Norwich

Oxford Mail:

9:30am Friday 24th October 2014

James Roberts is in no mood to rest on his laurels as the young Oxford United striker looks to feature in a fourth successive game when they visit Carlisle United tomorrow.

Blueprint for a £110m cancer research centre

Oxford Mail: Oxford Univesity logo white lettering blue background new logo

7:00am Friday 24th October 2014

A £110m cancer research centre is planned for Headington to study pioneering treatment with hundreds of county patients.

City roadworks hassle is worthwhile, says minister

Oxford Mail: OCC Cabinet member for transport, David Nimmo-Smith.

6:30am Friday 24th October 2014

MULTIPLE roadworks that cause city traffic gridlock are “worth it”, a minister has said.

Temporary Oxpens car park will have only half the space

Oxford Mail:

6:00am Friday 24th October 2014

A TEMPORARY replacement car park for Oxford’s Westgate multi-storey will provide less than half the number of spaces at present, it has been announced.

Oxfordshire bid for record Poppy Appeal total to mark centenary of start of First World War

Oxford Mail:

9:00am Thursday 23rd October 2014

PEOPLE in Oxfordshire are being urged to help break the £500,000 barrier for the first time as this year’s Poppy Appeal is launched today.

Judge criticises "catastrophic" CPS after trial postponement

Oxford Mail: Oxford Crown Court

2:30pm Thursday 23rd October 2014

A JUDGE has criticised a “catastrophic failure” by the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) which caused a trial to be put off until next year.

Comments (9)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

4:06pm Wed 30 Jul 14

norton manor says...

whatever happened to cameron's 'localism statergy'
whatever happened to cameron's 'localism statergy' norton manor
  • Score: 3

6:02pm Wed 30 Jul 14

Andrew:Oxford says...

norton manor wrote:
whatever happened to cameron's 'localism statergy'
Fraud doesn't have "local" borders though.

A local team may well spot some small-scale fraud... But what happens when that fraud crosses the border into Botley, Kennington, Kidlington or Garsington?

Well, we find that everyone in the various local authority teams works non-standard or "flexible" hours, doesn't do Friday afternoons, or Tuesday mornings and Wednesday mornings are for training...

So nothing gets done.

I worked in fraud for many years - you need to think big data for analysis.
[quote][p][bold]norton manor[/bold] wrote: whatever happened to cameron's 'localism statergy'[/p][/quote]Fraud doesn't have "local" borders though. A local team may well spot some small-scale fraud... But what happens when that fraud crosses the border into Botley, Kennington, Kidlington or Garsington? Well, we find that everyone in the various local authority teams works non-standard or "flexible" hours, doesn't do Friday afternoons, or Tuesday mornings and Wednesday mornings are for training... So nothing gets done. I worked in fraud for many years - you need to think big data for analysis. Andrew:Oxford
  • Score: 0

7:56pm Wed 30 Jul 14

bicesterlady says...

Councils have been using data matching for years with great success to fight fraud.


When the fraud crosses boarders, I should imagine the councils involved work together.
Councils have been using data matching for years with great success to fight fraud. When the fraud crosses boarders, I should imagine the councils involved work together. bicesterlady
  • Score: 0

9:45pm Wed 30 Jul 14

Andrew:Oxford says...

bicesterlady wrote:
Councils have been using data matching for years with great success to fight fraud.


When the fraud crosses boarders, I should imagine the councils involved work together.
But when does a temporary guest become a boarder and as such the the occupier lose their single person discount?

I imagine the occupier would be very cross when they get caught...
[quote][p][bold]bicesterlady[/bold] wrote: Councils have been using data matching for years with great success to fight fraud. When the fraud crosses boarders, I should imagine the councils involved work together.[/p][/quote]But when does a temporary guest become a boarder and as such the the occupier lose their single person discount? I imagine the occupier would be very cross when they get caught... Andrew:Oxford
  • Score: 0

12:35pm Thu 31 Jul 14

King Joke says...

Bicesterlady, can't we just repel boarders?
Bicesterlady, can't we just repel boarders? King Joke
  • Score: 0

12:50pm Thu 31 Jul 14

bicesterlady says...

Andrew:Oxford wrote:
bicesterlady wrote:
Councils have been using data matching for years with great success to fight fraud.


When the fraud crosses boarders, I should imagine the councils involved work together.
But when does a temporary guest become a boarder and as such the the occupier lose their single person discount?

I imagine the occupier would be very cross when they get caught...
But that's nothing to do with benefits & those issues will remain with councils
[quote][p][bold]Andrew:Oxford[/bold] wrote: [quote][p][bold]bicesterlady[/bold] wrote: Councils have been using data matching for years with great success to fight fraud. When the fraud crosses boarders, I should imagine the councils involved work together.[/p][/quote]But when does a temporary guest become a boarder and as such the the occupier lose their single person discount? I imagine the occupier would be very cross when they get caught...[/p][/quote]But that's nothing to do with benefits & those issues will remain with councils bicesterlady
  • Score: 0

12:56pm Thu 31 Jul 14

King Joke says...

You're right 'boarders' (sic) have nothing to do with benefits so why did you bring them up?
You're right 'boarders' (sic) have nothing to do with benefits so why did you bring them up? King Joke
  • Score: 0

3:59pm Thu 31 Jul 14

bicesterlady says...

Just realised my mistake....
Just realised my mistake.... bicesterlady
  • Score: 0

8:33pm Thu 31 Jul 14

King Joke says...

Biceserlady - now worries.

Andrew - curse those tiresome parents who fancy having a career and caring for their children or seeking a life outside of work. How dare they think of having both, how inconsiderate.
Biceserlady - now worries. Andrew - curse those tiresome parents who fancy having a career and caring for their children or seeking a life outside of work. How dare they think of having both, how inconsiderate. King Joke
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree