'Patients run risk of being denied hip replacements because of Oxfordshire NHS policy'

John Radburn had a hip replacement

John Radburn had a hip replacement

First published in News Oxford Mail: Photograph of the Author by , Health reporter, also covering Kidlington. Call me on 01865 425271

RESIDENTS risk being denied a hip replacement because Oxfordshire NHS bosses are ignoring national guidance and taking patients’ weight into account, leading surgeons have warned.

Patients should not have to complete a questionnaire that helps doctors decide if they get the operation, the Royal College of Surgeons said.

The NHS National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) and the college guidance recommends no referral threshold.

Oxfordshire Clinical Commissioning Group’s (OCCG) use of the Oxford hip score is “in explicit contravention” of these with “no clinical justification” it said.

An OCCG policy to consider a person’s weight when making decisions also goes against British Orthopaedic Association advice, it said.

The OCCG on Thursday said it was reviewing the criteria as part of a wider review into services.

A college report said: “The reliance by some CCGs on the use of scoring thresholds may withhold access to surgery for some patients, thereby denying them medical intervention that can improve their quality of life dramatically.”

It said the hip score — developed at Oxford’s Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre — should only be used to assess a patient’s condition after surgery.

Retired ambulance manager John Radburn, 64, passed the test and had a hip replacement, stemming from car smash aged 20, in February 2012.

He said: “It is probably a reasonable process, you need a measure somewhere.’’ The RCS said using the score to make treatment decisions has “never been validated and evidence suggests that the system is unsuitable for setting referral criteria”.

There is “no consistent evidence” the obese “do better or worse” than others and weight has “no bearing” on the hip prosthesis, he said.

It said OCCG is one of 16 clinical English clinical commissioning groups to use the hip score and one of seven who consider weight, out of 52 responses. Oxford East Labour MP Andrew Smith said: “Local practice will clearly need to be reviewed and changed as a matter of priority.

“Behind the statistics are individual patients, and it is unacceptable if some are being made to wait for treatment because of a scoring system being wrongly applied.”

The NICE guidance says decisions should be based “on discussions between patient representatives, referring clinicians and surgeons, rather than using scoring tools for prioritisation”.

But Jacqueline Pearce-Gervis, a member of the official NHS watchdog Healthwatch Oxfordshire, backed use of the scoring system.

She said: “Everybody should be aware that there is this service which they should take advantage of. A doctor could say ‘you don’t need one’ but if you went through the hip score, it could say you need one.”

Our top stories:

UPDATE: Further warning of ice and snow for end of weekend in Oxfordshire

Oxford Mail: Ice warning for Sussex after more snow falls

12:06pm Thursday 29th January 2015

There have been reports of snow in Chipping Norton and Carterton as the county was issued a warning for wintry weather.

Operation Bullfinch child trafficking suspect rebailed

Oxford Mail: Scales of Justice

8:00am Friday 30th January 2015

A man arrested as part of Operation Bullfinch on suspicion of child sexual exploitation in Oxford has been rebailed.

Headteachers say 2014 results have been made meaningless

Oxford Mail:

8:00am Friday 30th January 2015

HEADTEACHERS have hit out at Government changes that they say have made this year’s league tables meaningless.

Man in court charged with arsons including blaze at council HQ

Oxford Mail:

7:00am Friday 30th January 2015

A man charged with a series of arson attacks is due to appear at Oxford Crown Court today.

Road deaths rise with 27 dead but officials say it is still historically low

Oxford Mail:

7:00am Friday 30th January 2015

THE father of Liberty Baker, the schoolgirl killed in a collision while walking to school, has called for more 20mph zones.

Election tensions begin to rise as Cameron tells rival: My daughter is a better baker than you

Oxford Mail:

6:30am Friday 30th January 2015

PRIME Minister David Cameron has said his 11-year-old daughter Nancy would “thrash” his Labour party rival in Witney, Duncan Enright, in a pre-General Election bake off.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree