THE latest twist in a legal row over the dumping of waste material at an Oxfordshire golf course has left a council with a bill of £27,000.
Oxfordshire County Council mistakenly believed the High Court had made an order allowing it to apply to seize the assets of the Wyatt brothers for a clean-up.
But the court this week said no order had been made and ordered £27,000 costs to the Wyatt brothers, who own Waterstock Golf Club.
They have been wrangling with the council since material from construction of the M40 junction 10 services was put there in the 1990s for landscaping.
The Wyatts have lost several court battles since 1998 and were jailed in 2012 for contempt after failing to comply with rulings to clear the material.
The council wanted to seize some assets from Ron Wyatt, 72 and Mick Wyatt, 76 to help cover the £3.5m clean-up operation.
Council spokesman Paul Smith said the court ruled on Wednesday that an earlier order for sequestration of assets was “made without jurisdiction”.
He said: “When an earlier judge ordered an application for sequestration of assets be deemed to have been made, it was ineffective.”
Mr Smith said the Wyatts did not appeal against the order and met some of its demands, so it had assumed there was no a problem.
The local authority had assumed that an order had been made, but it was ruled this week that the order, which was originally applied for in 2011, did not stand up.
Ron Wyatt said: “To start it off again they will have to start from scratch. Our hope has always been to resolve this. We have served time in prison and feel very hard done by.”
He said the council’s plan to remove the material was “hopelessly wrong” and added: “Nothing should be removed.
“The land is as close as possible to what existed before we started, bearing in mind that we are engineering the lake there.”
He said: “It would be difficult to put it back to how it was before.”
Mr Smith said: “The council had relied on the court’s earlier decisions to seek to use the assets of the Wyatts, but the court has indicated that technical court procedures had to be followed before that step could be taken.
“The council was surprised at the judgment, given the court had appeared to approve of the council’s course of action, and there being no objection from the Wyatts at the time.”
He said the council “will obviously now reconsider what further enforcement action is appropriate in this case, as the Wyatts have still failed to remove the many thousand of tonnes of waste that they unlawfully deposited on their land.”
- Mid-1990s: Brothers Ron and Michael Wyatt use waste construction material at Waterstock Golf Club
- 1998: The first injunction is issued to the brothers to clear the waste
- 1999: A public inquiry is held and the inspector rules against the brothers
- 2000: Ron Wyatt says the soil was brought from the site of the M40 services at Wheatley to construct nine new holes
- 2005: A High Court order tells the brothers to clear the waste
- 2007: Ron Wyatt uses the Freedom of Information Act to discover Oxfordshire County Council has spent £187,000 on consultants to fight its case through the courts
- 2011: The brothers are ordered to comply with an earlier High Court order to search for the building material still within the site
- 2012: A High Court judge jails the Wyatts for repeatedly refusing to comply with the injunction
- 2013: After being released from HMP Pentonville, Mick Wyatt pledges to fight on against the county council
- 2014: The county council hears its attempt to get an order to take the brothers’ assest has failed
- Do you want alerts delivered straight to your phone via our WhatsApp service? Text NEWS, SPORT and JAYDEN depending on what services you want, and your full name to 07767 417704. Save our number into your phone as Oxford Mail WhatsApp and ensure you have WhatsApp installed.
- Our top stories
9:00am Monday 22nd December 2014
THERE is no longer anywhere cheap to live in Oxford, leaving average earners priced out of the market house prices up to 19 times the media salary, new figures show.
12:10pm Monday 22nd December 2014
PEOPLE in Oxfordshire with cancer and rare diseases could get advanced diagnosis and treatment under a new genetics project.
11:10am Monday 22nd December 2014
A LORRY containing egg boxes has caught fire on the A40 near Witney.
6:00am Tuesday 9th December 2014
December is Advent Calendar time and we have a special new interactive graphic for you each and every day until Christmas Eve. I've chosen the best 24 pictures of 2014 and I'll be unveiling one a day - so what is behind's today's door?
8:00am Monday 22nd December 2014
YOU know you’re starting to go places when you get Christmas cards from Oxfordshire's great and the good. Here's David Cameron's offering but can you guess who is responsible for the other five hidden in our interactive graphic and then read why they chose them