'Put emotions aside' jurors told in Fiaz Munshi arson case

'Put emotions aside' jurors told in Fiaz Munshi arson case

'Put emotions aside' jurors told in Fiaz Munshi arson case

First published in News
Last updated

JURORS have been told to put emotions aside when they decide if a mum-of-four murdered two children in an arson attack 17 years ago.

Justice Robin Spencer yesterday began summing up at Oxford Crown Court in the double murder trial of Fiaz Munshi.

The 38-year-old denies murdering Anum Khan, eight, and her brother Majid, 15, in a house fire in Magdalen Road in 1997.

Justice Spencer firstly asked the jury to try to remember what its members were doing in August 1997.

He said: “Just a few days later the world was mourning the death of Princess Diana. For the Khan Akhtar family here in Oxford the family were mourning their own tragedy.”

Giving the jury legal directions, he said they should convict Munshi of the murders only if they were sure she intended to kill or cause serious harm to anyone in the house.

He also said Munshi would be guilty if the jury found she knew about the plan to burn the house down and encouraged others to do it.

But he said jurors could convict Munshi of manslaughter if they found she unlawfully caused the death of the siblings, intended to cause bodily harm, or realised there was a risk someone would suffer some bodily harm.

But he warned jurors to leave emotion out of their decision making.

He said: “In case as harrowing as this there is a danger of influence by sympathy. You must put aside all feelings of sympathy and empathy in this case.”

The judge is expected to finish summing up the case today.

  • Our top stories:

Tuberculosis victim accused of breaching Asbo by spitting inside medical centre

Oxford Mail:

5:30am Tuesday 21st April 2015

A HOMELESS man given an anti-social behaviour order for trying to spread tuberculosis (TB) has gone on trial in Oxford Crown Court.

Randolph Hotel: Damage runs to millions but we may re-open on Saturday

Oxford Mail:

8:08am Monday 20th April 2015

THE manager of Oxford’s Randolph Hotel has said the fire caused millions of pounds of damage.

Randolph Hotel: Flambe cooking thought to be cause of fire

Oxford Mail:

8:00am Monday 20th April 2015

FIRE crews were expected to return the flame-stricken Randolph Hotel to management today after spending the weekend making the building safe.

UPDATE: Randolph Hotel: Beaumont Street reopens westbound

Oxford Mail:

3:05pm Monday 20th April 2015

BEAUMONT Street is set to partly reopen later today after engineers assessed damage to the Randolph Hotel following Friday’s fire.

Jury retires to consider verdict in Robert Dobinson murder trial

Oxford Mail:

3:21pm Monday 20th April 2015

THE jury has retired to consider its verdict in the trial of a woman who denies fatally stabbing her boyfriend in a drunken rage.

Update: Delays expected until midnight after signalling problems between Oxford and Charlbury

Oxford Mail: A First Great Western High Speed Train

11:03am Monday 20th April 2015

There are delays and cancellations on train services between Oxford and Charlbury due to signalling problems.

Oxford United striker Kemar Roofe celebrates double delight

Oxford Mail:

9:30am Monday 20th April 2015

Kemar Roofe insists he does not know where his future lies after netting his second double in a fortnight to help Oxford United to a 3-0 win at Tranmere Rovers on Saturday.

Randolph Hotel: Blaze a 'damaging blow' to city's tourist trade

Oxford Mail:

8:03am Monday 20th April 2015

THE blaze has been described as a “damaging blow” to the city ahead of tourist season.

Harry's Grill kebab van to learn fate tonight after zero-food hygiene rating

Oxford Mail: oxford city council logo

8:00am Monday 20th April 2015

A CITY kebab van is to find out its fate today after being awarded a zero food hygiene rating.

Randolph Hotel: We still got married despite the fire

Oxford Mail:

7:59am Monday 20th April 2015

IT WAS a moment in the making for months, almost ruined by a single night.

Randolph Hotel: Crews expected to remain at the scene until this afternoon

Oxford Mail:

7:46am Monday 20th April 2015

A SMALL section of Beaumont Street remains closed this morning following Friday’s fire at the Randolph Hotel.

Classic car fans celebrate manufacturing heritage in Pride of Longbridge Rally

Oxford Mail:

7:42am Monday 20th April 2015

A CONVOY of more than 100 classic cars paraded through Oxford to show off the county’s manufacturing heritage.

Dance and music wows crowd at city’s colourful folk festival

Oxford Mail:

6:30am Monday 20th April 2015

A CELEBRATION of bright colours, energetic music and impressive dancing took hold of the city centre at this weekend’s Oxford Folk Festival.

Video special report: Banbury sex gang victim speaks + police and arrest interviews of defendants

Oxford Mail:

10:00am Sunday 19th April 2015

ONE of the victims in the Banbury sex abuse case has said she'd like to help others going through the same as she did.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree