'Put emotions aside' jurors told in Fiaz Munshi arson case

'Put emotions aside' jurors told in Fiaz Munshi arson case

'Put emotions aside' jurors told in Fiaz Munshi arson case

First published in News
Last updated

JURORS have been told to put emotions aside when they decide if a mum-of-four murdered two children in an arson attack 17 years ago.

Justice Robin Spencer yesterday began summing up at Oxford Crown Court in the double murder trial of Fiaz Munshi.

The 38-year-old denies murdering Anum Khan, eight, and her brother Majid, 15, in a house fire in Magdalen Road in 1997.

Justice Spencer firstly asked the jury to try to remember what its members were doing in August 1997.

He said: “Just a few days later the world was mourning the death of Princess Diana. For the Khan Akhtar family here in Oxford the family were mourning their own tragedy.”

Giving the jury legal directions, he said they should convict Munshi of the murders only if they were sure she intended to kill or cause serious harm to anyone in the house.

He also said Munshi would be guilty if the jury found she knew about the plan to burn the house down and encouraged others to do it.

But he said jurors could convict Munshi of manslaughter if they found she unlawfully caused the death of the siblings, intended to cause bodily harm, or realised there was a risk someone would suffer some bodily harm.

But he warned jurors to leave emotion out of their decision making.

He said: “In case as harrowing as this there is a danger of influence by sympathy. You must put aside all feelings of sympathy and empathy in this case.”

The judge is expected to finish summing up the case today.

  • Our top stories:

Cuts and rising care demands putting more children at risk

Oxford Mail:

8:30am Tuesday 30th June 2015

THE man in charge of the county’s children’s services has warned a surge in cases on the back of Operation Bullfinch and other child abuse scandals is leading to huge pressure on his department.

Fraudster posing as store detective cons pensioner in Blackbird Leys

Oxford Mail: Thames Valley Police logo

4:07pm Tuesday 30th June 2015

A MAN pretending to be a store detective stole cash from an 85-year-old man.

Update: First RAF flight carrying bodies of Tunisia victims to arrive at Brize Norton tomorrow

Oxford Mail:

10:36am Tuesday 30th June 2015

ONE of the victims of the Tunisian beach massacre is being treated at the John Radcliffe Hospital in Oxford.

Mourners pay their respects to much-loved Aown Dogar

Oxford Mail:

9:00am Tuesday 30th June 2015

A TEENAGER who was the “life and soul” of his family was given a heartfelt farewell from hundreds of mourners yesterday.

Get the suncream ready as a heatwave hits Oxfordshire

Oxford Mail:

9:00am Tuesday 30th June 2015

A MINI heatwave will hit Oxfordshire this week, with temperatures set to reach 30C tomorrow.

Police call on charities for help supporting victims

Oxford Mail:

8:30am Tuesday 30th June 2015

CHARITIES and voluntary organisations could increasingly help Thames Valley Police tackle crimes such as rape in the future, the force’s new chief constable has said.

Ceremony honours veteran ‘whose colour saved his life’

Oxford Mail:

8:00am Tuesday 30th June 2015

A BLACK RAF veteran who said his skin colour saved his life in Nazi-occupied Europe will be remembered at a ceremony in Thame today.

Pupils on parade to help forces charity

Oxford Mail:

8:00am Tuesday 30th June 2015

A SCHOOL that took part in Camouflage Day said it was vital their pupils learned about the armed forces.

Charlotte Nott’s family welcomes arrival of meningitis vaccine

Oxford Mail:

7:00am Tuesday 30th June 2015

THE family of meningitis survivor Charlotte Nott has welcomed a lifesaving vaccine that will be rolled out this summer.

Couple discover lost Constable drawing

Oxford Mail:

7:00am Tuesday 30th June 2015

AN Oxfordshire couple have unearthed what is believed to be a lost piece by John Constable after it had been hanging above their mantelpiece for years.

Elephant Man play ‘brings human frailties to life’

Oxford Mail:

6:30am Tuesday 30th June 2015

THE true story of The Elephant Man is being brought to life in Abingdon.

Traffic jams feared as £12.5m transport revamp is unveiled

Oxford Mail:

6:30am Tuesday 30th June 2015

A £12.5M transport scheme has been unveiled for Headington amid fears that the roadworks will bring traffic to a standstill.

Flooding victims give plan for city relief channel their votes

Oxford Mail:

6:00am Tuesday 30th June 2015

HOUSEHOLDS in one of Oxford’s worst-hit flooding areas said they were positive about the progress of a proposed £120m relief channel as consultations continue this week.

Animal charity will benefit from family fun day

Oxford Mail:

6:00am Tuesday 30th June 2015

FROM furry animals to boat trips and bouncy castles, a host of activities will be at this year’s Muddy Waters family fun day.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree