Watchdog rules council data refusal was wrong

Stephen McCormick

Stephen McCormick

First published in News

A COUNCIL was wrong to refuse information to a resident about alleged bullying at a city college, the national information watchdog has ruled.

The Information Commissioner (ICO) said Oxfordshire County Council should not have denied Mike White’s requests about City Of Oxford College.

The council ruled his Freedom of Information Act requests about how allegations of bullying and harassment between students were handled as “vexatious”.

The college – formerly Oxford & Cherwell Valley College – said police investigations in 2009 found “no case to answer” over allegations.

Last September Mr White requested paperwork relating to the number of meetings a council officer had with college leaders.

After another request that month for internal emails, the council – to which he put in eight previous related requests – ruled them vexatious.

The ICO said the council had “concerns that information about a sensitive subject” was being requested for “not absolutely clear” reasons.

Given previous requests it said the two were “effectively unjustified and represent a disproportionate use of council resources in a matter which has been substantively addressed”.

“Scattergun” requests to different staff led to “disruption and duplication” it argued.

But the ICO’s Andrew White said: “Oxfordshire County Council is a large authority and 10 requests over a period of approximately one year does not appear to be excessive.”

They were not for “voluminous” amounts and the council “failed to provide evidence that they would have caused a disproportionate burden”.

He said: “It is difficult for the public to establish what actions were taken as a result of the allegations. Clearly a disclosure of the information requested by the complainant would shed greater transparency over the issue.”

Mr White, 45, who lives in Berkshire said he was made aware of allegations by a friend but was not directly involved before that.

Stephen McCormick, group deputy chief executive of Activate Learning, which runs the college, said allegations were “fully investigated at the time by the college, Thames Valley Police and local authority and there was found to be no case to answer”.

He said: “Around the same time an incident came to light in which a member of staff behaved inappropriately in the company of other staff members. This individual was dismissed according to our disciplinary procedures.”

Do you want alerts delivered straight to your phone via our WhatsApp service? Text NEWS, SPORT and JAYDEN depending on what services you want, and your full name to 07767 417704. Save our number into your phone as Oxford Mail WhatsApp and ensure you have WhatsApp installed.
Our top stories

Jury told fire started because businessman thought best man was having affair with wife

Oxford Mail:

8:29am Friday 22nd May 2015

A HOUSE fire that forced people to jump for their lives was started by a businessman who accused his best man of having an affair with his wife, a jury heard.

Person hit by train between Slough and Reading likely to affect Oxford rail services to London

Oxford Mail: A First Great Western High Speed Train

3:24pm Friday 22nd May 2015

TRAINS from Oxford could be disrupted after a person was hit by a train between Slough and Reading.

Teenagers arrested after robbery in Hythe Bridge Street

Oxford Mail: Thames Valley Police logo

3:23pm Friday 22nd May 2015

TWO teenagers have been arrested after a robbery in Hythe Bridge Street.

Appeal to find missing woman Rachel Selby from Banbury

Oxford Mail:

3:16pm Friday 22nd May 2015

A WOMAN has gone missing from Banbury, police said.

Oxford United stepping up interest in striker Ryan Taylor

Oxford Mail:

9:30am Friday 22nd May 2015

Ryan Taylor remains firmly on Oxford United’s radar despite the signing of Kemar Roofe, according to head coach Michael Appleton.

UPDATE: Broken down van removed from near Water Eaton park and ride

Oxford Mail: Traffic Alert general

7:54am Friday 22nd May 2015

ALL LANES have reopened on the A4165 Oxford Road after a earlier incident involving a broken down van.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree