Colleges’ outlawed postage system may have been legal

Prof Simon Catling, left, and Bill Jackson, president of Oxford Philatelic Society, examine the Cambridge College Messenger Stamps

The stamps

First published in News Oxford Mail: Photograph of the Author by , Reporter covering North Oxford, Jericho and Summertown. Call me on 01865 425498

OXFORD University colleges are known for doing things their own way.

And at one time they had their own postal system too, before it was outlawed in 1886.

Now a retired professor says his grandfather may have found ‘proof’ that they should have been allowed to keep it.

Former Oxford Brookes University lecturer Simon Catling, of Wheatley, was clearing his mother’s Norfolk home after she died in 2010 when he found an old trunk.

Inside was a manuscript and rare stamp collection owned by his grandfather, Harry Catling.

His grandfather was convinced he had found legal evidence which showed the stamps should not have been banned, but didn’t manage to publish it between 1939, when he completed his research, and when he died in 1947.

Prof Catling, 66, said: “He did try to publish it, but the Second World War got in the way.

“He had sent it to his son, but his son went to war and when he returned there was more pressing business to attend to, so it was put away and completely forgotten.

“It seems to make a very strong case to me and I have spoken to expert stamp collectors who agree.

“Even though it has been in an attic for 75 years, the arguments it makes have never been made before.”

The colleges in Oxford had been using their own messengers for years for an internal mail system, but after Keble College was opened in 1870, cash-strapped staff members decided to start charging students and staff for the service. To do that, they created their own stamps.

The practice spread to seven other colleges in the next decade and even across to Cambridge University in 1882.

But in 1886 the Postmaster General of the UK, Henry Carteret, launched a legal challenge, claiming it infringed on the government-owned General Post Office’s monopoly of the market.

As a result the stamps were outlawed and, over time, intact versions became very difficult for collectors to obtain.

Harry Catling had become interested in them in the 1880s and began to research them when he lived in Cambridge in the 1920s and 1930s.

In his manuscript, he wrote: “I turned to the authorities and carefully investigated the Post Office Acts from their first appearance.

And he made reference to “the Act of Charles II in 1660, which confirmed in 1661... the privileges of the two Universities of the Land were reserved to them ‘in manner as heretofore hath been used’.”

After discovering the manuscript, Prof Catling showed it to friend and Oxford Philatelic Society president Bill Jackson.

Mr Jackson said: “This essay has been completely unknown until now and the stamps are the best collection from Cambridge ever found.

“I doubt it will prompt the colleges to resume their old system, but it is very interesting.”

An Oxford University spokesperson said: “The essay makes for interesting reading, but at present we have no plans to revive the University’s postal service.”

  • Our top stories:

UPDATE: Tributes paid to Ann Ducker, leader of South Oxfordshire District Council, who has died

Oxford Mail: South Oxfordshire District Council leader Ann Ducker

10:21am Monday 22nd September 2014

Ann Ducker, leader of South Oxfordshire District Council, has died.

Corn Exchange's future debated

Oxford Mail: The Corn Exchange

9:10am Monday 22nd September 2014

The future use of the Corn Exchange will be discussed at a meeting tonight.

Minibus in accident near Littlemore

Oxford Mail: oxfordshire fire and rescue logo

9:10am Monday 22nd September 2014

A minibus carrying a group of youngsters was involved in a crash with a car on the A4142 Eastern Bypass. Three adults, 10 teenagers and a child were involved in the crash.

Electricity line drama after fire wrecks shed in Yarnton

Oxford Mail: oxfordshire fire and rescue logo

9:10am Monday 22nd September 2014

Electricity cables collapsed after a blaze in a large garden shed in Yarnton on Sunday.

Attacks prompt appeals for more police on the streets

Oxford Mail:

9:00am Monday 22nd September 2014

TWO men were last night in police custody after two women were raped in Oxford.

Shoppers jump in to stop would-be shoplifter

Oxford Mail: Thames Valley Police logo

8:30am Monday 22nd September 2014

SHOPPERS stopped a would-be thief from escaping from a Wallingford supermarket without paying for a trolley full of goods.

Schoolboy back on the ball after ceramic skull ‘miracle’

Oxford Mail:

8:30am Monday 22nd September 2014

A YEAR ago schoolboy Ollie Kirk became one of the first people in the UK to have half of his skull replaced with a ceramic implant.

Source of chemical that killed fish untraceable

Oxford Mail: Environment Agency logo round

8:00am Monday 22nd September 2014

INVESTIGATORS have been unable to find out the source of a chemical that killed more than 4,000 fish in a Didcot stream.

A green and pleasant event for first Earth Trust runners

Oxford Mail:

8:00am Monday 22nd September 2014

ICONIC landscapes greeted runners who took part in the Earth Trust’s inaugural 10k cross-country race round the Wittenham Clumps beauty spot.

Mystery Oxford pong is back, say residents

Oxford Mail: Pictures submitted by our readers of their memories of Didcot Power Station leading up to the demolition of three of the cooling towers.

7:10am Monday 22nd September 2014

THE mysterious ‘Oxford stink’ has returned for a third time, according to city residents.

Oxford youth hostel manager talks of blaze in laundry room

Oxford Mail: oxfordshire fire and rescue logo

7:10am Monday 22nd September 2014

A YOUTH hostel manager has described how a fire broke out in a laundry room.

Dancing in the streets as Charlbury holds its fair

Oxford Mail:

7:00am Monday 22nd September 2014

MORRIS dancing, cow-milking contests and a Spitfire fly-past were the attractions at this year’s Charlbury Street Fair.

Bishop takes a breather from pilgrimage for a special event

Oxford Mail:

7:00am Monday 22nd September 2014

NOT even finding out he had a heart condition could stop the Bishop of Oxford enjoying events to honour his retirement.

Bikers to raise memorial funds at Ride to the Wall event

Oxford Mail: The DLI honoured at the National Memorial Arboretum, in Staffordshire

6:40am Monday 22nd September 2014

Hundreds of motorbike riders will embark on a “pilgrimage” of more than 70 miles to raise money for an Armed Forces charity next month.

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

3:41pm Fri 23 May 14

Simon33 says...

The Oxford Philatelic Society has 60 members and meets regularly at the Methodist Church, Rose Hill, OX4 4HS. New members are always welcome.
The next meeting is a bring and buy/AGM on Monday 16th June at 7.30pm.

All the details of the society are at:
http://www.communiga
te.co.uk/oxford/oxfo
rdphilatelicsociety/
The Oxford Philatelic Society has 60 members and meets regularly at the Methodist Church, Rose Hill, OX4 4HS. New members are always welcome. The next meeting is a bring and buy/AGM on Monday 16th June at 7.30pm. All the details of the society are at: http://www.communiga te.co.uk/oxford/oxfo rdphilatelicsociety/ Simon33
  • Score: 2

8:56pm Fri 23 May 14

bart-on simpson says...

Stamp collecting makes you so knowledgeable about geography and the world. I hope there are children in Oxford who are being taught about the value of such hobbies, not just electronic games.
Stamp collecting makes you so knowledgeable about geography and the world. I hope there are children in Oxford who are being taught about the value of such hobbies, not just electronic games. bart-on simpson
  • Score: 2

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree