One-party election branded ‘mockery’

Tim Hallchurch was unopposed

Tim Hallchurch was unopposed

First published in News Oxford Mail: Photograph of the Author by , Council Reporter, also covering Oxford city centre. Call me on 01865 425429

A NATIONAL campaign group has branded an uncontested election in Oxfordshire a “mockery of democracy”.

There is only one candidate standing in the Cherwell District Council seat of Otmoor at Thursday’s elections.

Conservative incumbent Tim Hallchurch has, therefore, been elected to the council unopposed by any other parties or candidates.

His seat is one of only five which are uncontested in the rest of the country, and the only one in Oxfordshire.

The Electoral Reform Society has calculated that this will leave 2,500 people in the ward without a vote this year and condemned the situation as a “blight” on democracy.

Darren Hughes, the society’s deputy chief executive, said: “The first principle of democracy is that you get to choose who represents you.

“But for thousands of people in Oxfordshire, this fundamental democratic right is being denied. Uncontested seats make a mockery of democracy.

“If a seat is uncontested, democracy in that area effectively does not exist.

“The councillor elected in Otmoor will have no proper mandate from the people as they will not have had to win a single vote.

“Local electoral reform would mean there would be incentives for parties to field candidates wherever they have a vote, no matter how small.”

Mr Hughes suggested the implementation of the single transferable vote system over first past the post, the current voting system.

With the single transferable vote system, voters can select a second preference on their ballot paper rather than just voting once.

Mr Hallchurch, pictured, said: “I know it is very difficult to get people who have got the time to be a councillor, especially people who work all the time.

“The question is if we have proportional representation are you going to get more people to stand? I doubt it.

“I think we have probably got it about right.

“Proportional representation leads to hung councils and that makes it very hard to make decisions.”

David Winchester, secretary of the Henley Labour Party – which covers Otmoor – said: “It is the policy of the Labour Party to be represented in all local government elections.

“In 2013 there was a re-organisation of local government boundaries to reduce the total number of seats. This left a number of seats spanning constituencies or being in constituencies that were different from the majority of the council.

“Otmoor is such a seat and unfortunately it fell into a hole between two constituencies. It would appear that Labour was not the only party affected by this situation.

“We will be introducing administrative procedures to ensure that we will be represented in the future.”

We also contacted Tim Emptage, the leader of the Lib Dems on the district council, to find out why no candidate had been put forward, but he did not return our call.

  • Our top stories:

City handouts give big lift to the less fortunate

Oxford Mail:

5:00pm Saturday 30th August 2014

ROSE Hill has the highest child poverty rate in Oxford.

Acts jump through hoops as Big Feastival begins

Oxford Mail:

9:30am Saturday 30th August 2014

SOPHIE Greenwood showed punters at the Big Feastival how to hula yesterday, as the event opened with musical performances from Reggae Reggae sauce entrepreneur Levi Roots and Abba tribute act Bjorn Again.

Mullins believes cup will lift U's

Oxford Mail:

9:30am Saturday 30th August 2014

Johnny Mullins is confident Oxford United’s midweek cup exertions will be a help rather than a hindrance in the search for their first points of the season today.

Hospital complaints up

Oxford Mail: Where will funds come from?

9:10am Saturday 30th August 2014

New data from the Health and Social Information Centre revealed that the number of written complaints to Oxford University Hospitals NHS Trust, which runs the county’s main hospitals, increased to 890 in 2013/14, from 792 in 2012/13.

Make-up driver fined

Oxford Mail: Thames Valley Police logo

9:10am Saturday 30th August 2014

A driver putting on make-up close to Abingdon police station was among drivers stopped and fined for motoring crimes on Thursday morning.

Police fear for welfare of missing teenager

Oxford Mail:

9:10am Saturday 30th August 2014

A teenager was missing last night, with police and his family fearing for his welfare.

It's all in the worst possible taste - hospital's food condemned

Oxford Mail:

9:00am Saturday 30th August 2014

FOOD quality at Witney Community Hospital has been ranked as the third worst in England.

Motorist who killed his friend is spared jail

Oxford Mail:

9:00am Saturday 30th August 2014

AN ELDERLY driver who killed his friend driving back from bowls practice has been spared prison.

Veteran is told: you can't fly your Union Flag here

Oxford Mail:

8:30am Saturday 30th August 2014

A DISABLED army veteran has said he is being made to feel ashamed to be British after he was told to remove a Union flag from his garden.

New major city roadworks ‘will not hit commuters’

Oxford Mail: An artist’s impression of how Frideswide Square will look

8:00am Saturday 30th August 2014

AFTER years of waiting, work on redeveloping Frideswide Square is to start on Monday – and council officials have promised the first stage of the work will not affect people’s journeys to work.

Sowing seeds for learning

Oxford Mail:

6:50am Saturday 30th August 2014

VISITORS to Harcourt Arboretum have been sowing the seeds of a good time this week.

Cyclists rush in as 'Boris bikes' are relaunched

Oxford Mail:

6:40am Saturday 30th August 2014

MORE than 200 people have signed up for Oxford’s “Boris bike” scheme after it relaunched earlier this summer.

Depressed woman died after hospital discharge

Oxford Mail: Oxfordshire County Council county hall

6:40am Saturday 30th August 2014

A WOMAN with a history of depression found dead the day after being discharged from a mental health hospital died of natural causes, a coroner has ruled.

Connor Tremble murder: Couple recall 'confrontation with psychopath'

Oxford Mail:

6:30am Saturday 30th August 2014

TEENAGER Denise Stratford says killer Will Blencowe’s footprint is still on her window after he tried to break into her home, a week before he murdered Connor Tremble.

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

9:56am Wed 21 May 14

snert says...

You can hardly condemn Mr Hallchurch or the system for allowing him to be elected uncontested if there are no people to run in contest with him.
You can hardly condemn Mr Hallchurch or the system for allowing him to be elected uncontested if there are no people to run in contest with him. snert
  • Score: 2

10:54am Wed 21 May 14

icba1957 says...

What would be the point of a transferable vote when there's no-one to transfer it to!
Unless they're suggesting the alternative IS no-one!
How democratic would that be?
What would be the point of a transferable vote when there's no-one to transfer it to! Unless they're suggesting the alternative IS no-one! How democratic would that be? icba1957
  • Score: 1

12:01pm Wed 21 May 14

King Joke says...

^ What they said. I am no Tory but if no-one else can be fagged to stand then the seat has to go to the one person who can.
^ What they said. I am no Tory but if no-one else can be fagged to stand then the seat has to go to the one person who can. King Joke
  • Score: 2

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree