MP criticises mental hospital's suicide failings

A HEALTH trust responsible for an Oxford mental hospital has been told to take action after failing an inspection.

Care Quality Commission staff failed the Warneford Hospital, Headington, left, following an unannounced inspection late last year.

They found points patients could hang themselves from and glass mirrors that could have been used for self-harm in bathrooms.

But the report said Oxfordshire Health NHS Foundation knew about the risk and did nothing.

Oxford East MP Andrew Smith, right, said: “The hospital needs to put its house in order.

“The really worrying thing about this is that staff told the inspectors that the hospital trust knew about the dangers, but nothing was being done about them.”

Oxford Health NHS Foundation Trust, which runs the hospital, said an action plan was now in place and changes were being made.

Alexis Elliott, suicide prevention coordinator at charity Papyrus, said: “It is alarming and shocking to hear what has come out of the report. Reducing access to means will help reduce suicide attempts because people are not able to harm themselves.

“The fact they are doing something about it now is encouraging, but it is luck that nothing has happened before now.”

Related links

County councillor Susanna Pressel, of Oxfordshire’s joint health overview & scrutiny committee, said: “I shall look with interest at the action plan which Oxford Health has drawn up – perhaps rather belatedly.

“This is something that the health overview and scrutiny committee should look at at our next meeting.”

The CQC report said taps and bath handles in bathrooms could have been used in an attempt at hanging or self-strangulation and glass mirrors in bathrooms and toilets could have been broken and used by a patient to self-harm.

It said: “Some of the bathrooms were potentially unsafe for people at risk of self harm. The trust had identified but not addressed these issues.”

It also found some bedrooms were shared, compromising privacy and dignity, and garden access was restricted and only available under supervision.

An Oxford Health spokeswoman said the trust had put in place an action plan and improvements, which have started, would be completed by May 31.

She said: “The recently published CQC report identified a moderate concern for the Trust’s attention, namely that the type of mirror and taps could have been a possible risk for patients intent on self-harming.

“The trust can confirm there have been no instances of patients self-harming using the existing fixtures and fittings.

“However, Oxford Health NHS FT will be installing new fixtures as part of a programme of continuous improvement to the wards at the Warneford Hospital.”

The hospital opened in the early 19th century now provides care for about 100 mental health suffers at any one time.

It has three acute adult inpatient units, an eating disorder unit, a new £11m adolescent inpatient unit and houses community mental health teams.

Comments(6)

Feelingsmatter says...
10:28am Sat 16 Mar 13

There's FAR more to it than that! They have windows on a secure ward which people can get out of, allow plastic bags with possessions to be brought in, not searched, then used in an attempt at suffocation, allow patients to have CAMERA phones on them, so anyone can be photographed and posted on FB. The ward managers KNOW this, and choose to do nothing. It's a shameful situation which is completely avoidable, but would involve staff actually getting off their backsides and out of the office.

Andrew:Oxford says...
10:43pm Sat 16 Mar 13

Feelingsmatter wrote:
There's FAR more to it than that! They have windows on a secure ward which people can get out of, allow plastic bags with possessions to be brought in, not searched, then used in an attempt at suffocation, allow patients to have CAMERA phones on them, so anyone can be photographed and posted on FB. The ward managers KNOW this, and choose to do nothing. It's a shameful situation which is completely avoidable, but would involve staff actually getting off their backsides and out of the office.
Why shouldn't patients have mobile phones with a camera?

Just try and find a phone or tablet device that doesn't have a camera in it.

Mental health is a very broad area and it would be a disgrace if people were abused and isolated by refusing them access to their friends and families through modern communication systems and devices.

ellyholmes says...
2:08pm Sun 17 Mar 13

It would be helpful if Mr Jennings, writer of this article, could acquaint himself with language that does not cause offence. The term "mental hospital", while short, readily understood and amenable to headlines, is unacceptable, carrying as it does the pejorative sense of the word "mental" to describe people who receive treatment there. While it may not be intended to offend, using such language perpetrates existing stereotypes about experiencing mental distress / illness, and suggests that doing so is acceptable, especially when the phrase is used on billboards all over Oxford. Just adding one word to the title would make all the difference: "Mental Health Hospital" is both more descriptive and less offensive.

Feelingsmatter says...
10:10pm Sun 17 Mar 13

Andrew:Oxford wrote:
Feelingsmatter wrote:
There's FAR more to it than that! They have windows on a secure ward which people can get out of, allow plastic bags with possessions to be brought in, not searched, then used in an attempt at suffocation, allow patients to have CAMERA phones on them, so anyone can be photographed and posted on FB. The ward managers KNOW this, and choose to do nothing. It's a shameful situation which is completely avoidable, but would involve staff actually getting off their backsides and out of the office.
Why shouldn't patients have mobile phones with a camera?

Just try and find a phone or tablet device that doesn't have a camera in it.

Mental health is a very broad area and it would be a disgrace if people were abused and isolated by refusing them access to their friends and families through modern communication systems and devices.
There is a ward phone which we can use and relatives can ring us on. I object strongly to being at the mercy of anyone with a camera phone. People with psychiatric illness, particularly those who have been sectioned and are in lockdown, deserve privacy and confidentiality. Maybe if you stay in one for a while your view will change. I find it disgraceful that people can video me or take my photo without my permission, and with a few clicks my photo can be seen by the whole world.

Andrew:Oxford says...
1:51pm Mon 18 Mar 13

Feelingsmatter wrote:
Andrew:Oxford wrote:
Feelingsmatter wrote:
There's FAR more to it than that! They have windows on a secure ward which people can get out of, allow plastic bags with possessions to be brought in, not searched, then used in an attempt at suffocation, allow patients to have CAMERA phones on them, so anyone can be photographed and posted on FB. The ward managers KNOW this, and choose to do nothing. It's a shameful situation which is completely avoidable, but would involve staff actually getting off their backsides and out of the office.
Why shouldn't patients have mobile phones with a camera?

Just try and find a phone or tablet device that doesn't have a camera in it.

Mental health is a very broad area and it would be a disgrace if people were abused and isolated by refusing them access to their friends and families through modern communication systems and devices.
There is a ward phone which we can use and relatives can ring us on. I object strongly to being at the mercy of anyone with a camera phone. People with psychiatric illness, particularly those who have been sectioned and are in lockdown, deserve privacy and confidentiality. Maybe if you stay in one for a while your view will change. I find it disgraceful that people can video me or take my photo without my permission, and with a few clicks my photo can be seen by the whole world.
That can happen out on the street.

Indeed, just go into any regular gym locker room and you'll find people frobbing away on their phones or tablet devices whilst they (and the people around them) change.

Clearly you don't have an issue with using a device where you are at the moment...

Feelingsmatter says...
4:21pm Mon 18 Mar 13

You just don't get it, do you? I am at home, in private, using a PC. When I was in the Warneford, I was ill, distressed, and didn't wish for anyone to witness it. If you were having a medical procedure and someone walked in with a video-camera, you might object. If you don't, well, what ever rocks your boat .........

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree