College colleagues back Patten to stay

Oxford University Chancellor Lord Patten

Oxford University Chancellor Lord Patten

First published in News Oxford Mail: Photograph of the Author by , Oxford Times Chief Reporter. Call me on 01865 425434

WITH Lord Patten’s position as chairman of the BBC Trust under mounting pressure, support has been offered in the city, where he is Chancellor of Oxford University.

Lord Patten has faced calls for his resignation from MPs as the crisis engulfing the BBC worsened, with news that Lord Patten approved a £450,000 pay-off for the corporation’s former director-general George Entwistle.

The payout, worth twice as much as Mr Entwistle was entitled to, was criticised by the Prime Minister as hard to justify.

But Lord Patten should keep both his job at the BBC and as Oxford University’s ceremonial head, said one senior university figure and leading media commentator, Will Hutton.

Mr Hutton, former editor-in-chief of The Observer, who is now principal of Hertford College, said those demanding more blood-letting at the BBC needed a greater sense of proportion.

Mr Hutton, who recently conducted an inquiry into public sector salaries for Prime Minister David Cameron, said: “Lord Patten carries more battle scars than he did and he would be the first to admit that.

“But he is an effective operator and a good man, who is a widely-respected Chancellor of Oxford University.

“At a time like this it is easy to call for his resignation. But it is starting to get like Medieval England with people wanting to see more blood loss.

“There is no reason for him to go. It wasn’t Lord Patten who was in charge of those making the journalistic calls.

“He is now doing what needs to be done. I really cannot see the point in creating another vacancy at the top at an organisation that badly needs to get a grip.”

Mr Hutton said horrific journalistic mistakes had been made on Newsnight, when a former top Tory was wrongly linked to a child sex scandal, but four had paid for them with their careers, including Mr Entwistle.

Related links

Mr Hutton said: “I would say 99.9 per cent of what goes out of the BBC is excellent.

“I think we need to get a sense of proportion here. The enemies of the BBC are now circling the wagons, with calls for the BBC to be smaller and broken up.”

Mr Hutton believed that Lord Patten had been damaged by the £450,000 payout to Mr Entwistle, with the sense of outrage predictable.

He said: “It is another damaging thing that the BBC could have avoided in the current climate.”

While the payout to Mr Entwistle was an “awful” outcome, Mr Hutton said he understood how it had happened. Sacking Mr Entwistle could well have proved a far costlier alternative, fraught with legal difficulties.

Mr Hutton was commissioned two years ago to carry out a review into public sector pay, with recommendations to promote pay fairness in the public sector by tackling disparities between the lowest and the highest paid.

Another senior Oxford college head, Frances Cairncross, the rector of Exeter College, expressed her support for Lord Patten.

She said: “I do not know enough about what has happened at the BBC to comment, but I would say that Lord Patten seems to be a good and enthusiastic chancellor of the university.”

Lord Patten, the former Conservative Party chairman, became Chancellor of Oxford University in 2003 and was made £110,000-a-year chairman of the BBC Trust in May 2011.

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

12:00pm Fri 16 Nov 12

riman09 says...

I get the sense of 'belonging' from this college associate of the BBC Chair. That makes me take his perspective with a pinch of salt.

If I were Lord Patten, I would resign because of the immoral amounts of public, license payer money, being wasted in this scandal. When it is finally concluded I would not be surprised it will have cost the BBC millions of pounds.

That is not the sort of money to allow an organisation like the BBC to lose, all because you appointed, or were part of the due process of appointing, a Director who messed up big time.
I get the sense of 'belonging' from this college associate of the BBC Chair. That makes me take his perspective with a pinch of salt. If I were Lord Patten, I would resign because of the immoral amounts of public, license payer money, being wasted in this scandal. When it is finally concluded I would not be surprised it will have cost the BBC millions of pounds. That is not the sort of money to allow an organisation like the BBC to lose, all because you appointed, or were part of the due process of appointing, a Director who messed up big time. riman09
  • Score: 0

12:19pm Fri 16 Nov 12

CLLR KEN TIWARI says...

May be millions more are interested to talk about this position, so who is the best to serve this sacered seat (Position) ? (why change)?
May be millions more are interested to talk about this position, so who is the best to serve this sacered seat (Position) ? (why change)? CLLR KEN TIWARI
  • Score: -2

5:45pm Fri 16 Nov 12

Myron Blatz says...

It's all a bit of a circus, and at both tax and tv licence payers expense. Seems that whilst 'Auntie' can get people tajen to court for not having a tv licence (even if they don't watch BBC progs) that for donkey's years the Corporation has been unable to police itself, those who work for the BBC and get paid from publc money, and more recently cannot even manage to run editorial and programme departments. Tgey need someone more like Sir 'innit' Alan Sugar, than Lord 'help us' Patten, perhaps?
It's all a bit of a circus, and at both tax and tv licence payers expense. Seems that whilst 'Auntie' can get people tajen to court for not having a tv licence (even if they don't watch BBC progs) that for donkey's years the Corporation has been unable to police itself, those who work for the BBC and get paid from publc money, and more recently cannot even manage to run editorial and programme departments. Tgey need someone more like Sir 'innit' Alan Sugar, than Lord 'help us' Patten, perhaps? Myron Blatz
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree