Damon Smith says that Russell Crowe’s first film as director shows some promise

In front of the camera, New Zealand-born actor Russell Crowe has enjoyed both critical and commercial success since coming to the fore in 1997, as a brutish detective in LA Confidential.

Successive Oscar nominations as Best Actor for The Insider, Gladiator and A Beautiful Mind – including a win for Ridley Scott's swords and sandals epic – solidified his status as a performer with emotional depth to complement his physical presence.

More recently, he has embraced political corruption as a shady mayor in Broken City, sung for his supper in Les Miserables and built an ark as a tormented Noah.

For his directorial debut, Crowe casts himself as a crusading father, who will stop at nothing to locate his three fallen sons, in this fictional historical drama based on the book of the same name, adapted for the big screen by Andrew Anastasios and Andrew Knight.

The Water Diviner is a solid first effort, including well-choreographed scenes of conflict and self-sacrifice during the First World War’s Gallipoli campaign in late 1915.

However, his film falls victim to heavy-handed sentiment when it comes to a central romance across the cultural divide that flourishes, despite a total absence of on-screen chemistry with leading lady Olga Kurylenko.

Rugged farmer Joshua Connor (Crowe) possesses a rare gift for divining water, which he uses to irrigate the sprawling property he shares with his wife, Eliza (Jacqueline McKenzie), and their sons, Art (Ryan Corr), Edward (James Fraser) and Henry (Ben O’Toole).

The boys head off to war, but soon perish in the ill-fated clash with Turkish forces on the Gallipoli peninsula.

Their final resting places are unknown, like those of so many who fought, and Eliza is devastated.

Later, Joshua honours a promise to his wife to bring the remains of their boys back home.

He seeks lodgings in Constantinople at a hotel run by Muslim widow Ayshe (Kurylenko) and her cherubic son, Orhan (Dylan Georgiades).

Unfortunately, the military refuses to allow Joshua safe passage to Gallipoli, so he ignores protocol and makes his own way to the site, where he clashes with Australian Lieutenant Colonel Cyril Hughes (Jai Courtney).

Unexpectedly, a visiting Turkish officer, Major Hassan (Yilmaz Erdogan), takes pity and pledges his assistance to reunite Joshua with his boys, because “he’s the only father who came looking.”

Blessed with lustrous cinematography, The Water Diviner is a heartfelt tale of broken men and redemption.

Crowe doesn’t have to stretch himself as a father in crisis, but his character’s search for answers tugs heartstrings, including a devastating scene of his boys scythed down by Turkish bullets.

The romantic subplot doesn’t work and its resolution is unintentionally hilarious, but the rest of Crowe’s first foray into direction shows promise.

The Water Diviner (15)   
Directed by Russell Crowe  
Starring Russell Crowe, Olga Kurylenko, Jai Courtney, Dylan Georgiades, Yilmaz Erdogan, Cem Yilmaz, Ryan Corr, James Fraser, Ben O’Toole, Jacqueline McKenzie